News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Insanity Virus by defen on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @07:14PM (#1938922)
This article reminds of something Gregory Cochran has been saying for years - "Your genes didn't evolve to kill you". He has a hypothesis that many of the illnesses and chronic conditions that do not have a clear genetic or environmental toxin basis are actually caused by germs - bacteria or viruses. This would include things like heart disease, diabetes, some cancers, some mental illnesses, etc. The problem is that many of these things do not satisfy Koch's postulates for infectious disease, making it very difficult to test. Or the disease progression takes 40+ years. Unfortunately I'm on my phone at the moment so I can't look anything up, else I would post some links.
Re:The Insanity Virus by hugh3 on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @09:18PM (#1939139)
Your genes sure as hell didn't evolve to make you immortal, either. They evolved in the hopes that you'll live long enough to make a few new copies of them, and engineering the vital parts of the body to last significantly longer wasn't a high priority.

I'd be disinclined to throw out the huge volume of research on the subject of what actually causes heart disease and cancer due to a pithy slogan.

Re:The Insanity Virus by InclinedPlane on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @09:21PM (#1939146)
Death is an evolved trait. It's an advantage for most organisms because it ensures a steady turnover of populations which enables micro and macro evolution at a reasonable pace in response to environmental, climate, et al changes.
Re:The Insanity Virus by powrtoch on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @10:28PM (#1939269)
Sounds like the bad kind of group selectionism hypothesis to me. Death bestows no fitness benefit to the individual, and is therefore not evolutionarily selected for. Organisms don't die because evolution says they should, they die because evolution doesn't care.
Re:The Insanity Virus by skybrian on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @10:43PM (#1939294)
It's more active than that. A trait that enhances reproduction and reduces longevity will be selected for, so whenever there are engineering tradeoffs between reproduction and longevity, evolution will select in favor of reproduction.
Re:The Insanity Virus by loewenskind on Thursday November 25, 2010 @06:52AM (#1940016)
Odd then that the most advanced species have the longest gestation periods and the simplest species have the shortest.
Re:The Insanity Virus by eru on Thursday November 25, 2010 @09:06AM (#1940248)
That's because there's no advanced and simple in evolution.
Re:The Insanity Virus by loewenskind on Thursday November 25, 2010 @10:11AM (#1940364)
My point was that the parents comment was completely unfounded. Did humans always have super fast gestation periods and then right before we gained intelligence it suddenly took the better part of a year and produced a child that isn't self sufficient for at least a decade?

When the evolution subject comes up it always seems to inspire a bunch of would-be scifi writers to come out and explain "how it all works" based on, as near as I can tell, pure fantasy.

Re:The Insanity Virus by eru on Thursday November 25, 2010 @10:25AM (#1940382)
Depends on how you interpret `reproduction' in the comment you're talking about.

Reproduction trumps everything in evolution. It's everything, actually. But for that to be true you can't define it as `number of offspring born', but in a more long-term sense. And e.g. Elephants seem to have more long-term off-spring by investing more in fewer births.

Re:The Insanity Virus by InclinedPlane on Thursday November 25, 2010 @02:07AM (#1939583)
Organisms don't evolve, populations do. Death of individuals is beneficial for most populations. For one, it's easier to build something that lasts a while and reproduces than it is to build something that lasts indefinitely. For another, as mentioned, populations with significant generational turnover bounce back faster after catastrophic environmental or other stresses (because they reproduce faster, among other dynamic effects).
Re:The Insanity Virus by rue on Thursday November 25, 2010 @04:21AM (#1939806)
Evolution is not about optimization.
Re:The Insanity Virus by araneae on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @11:19PM (#1939353)
Death is an evolved trait, but it has to do with life history trade-offs, see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_history_theory

In some cases life history trade-offs differ between the sexes leading to longevity differences. In general, females live longer than males, although in humans the difference is pretty small. There are some extreme examples of this in spiders, such as the tarantula, where the male lives about 2 years and the female 8.

Re:The Insanity Virus by DavidSJ on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @11:00PM (#1939327)
Evolution doesn't cause individuals to perform selfless acts for the good of the species. Where possible, it will select for selfish acts at the expense of the species.
Re:The Insanity Virus by eru on Thursday November 25, 2010 @09:07AM (#1940252)
How about acts that that promote your selfish genes? Your relatives share a lot of your genes.
Re:The Insanity Virus by DavidSJ on Tuesday November 30, 2010 @03:45AM (#1953561)
Very close relatives, yes. But not the entire species.

It strikes me as highly implausible that suicide would benefit your close genetic kin more so than staying alive in order to find food and care for offspring, for example.

Re:The Insanity Virus by rsheridan6 on Thursday November 25, 2010 @08:12AM (#1940161)
Cochran collaborator Paul Ewald (they wrote an article hypothesizing that homosexuality is also caused by a pathogen) wrote a book about that subject 10 years ago. This article reminded me about that too, probably because it mentioned the same researcher: http://books.google.com/books?id=HlmxmE6TMCwC&lpg=PP1...
Re:The Insanity Virus by run4yourlives on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @09:07PM (#1939120)
That thesis would assume that we all live in some sort of bubble were the environment we live in and the foods we consume don't impact our bodies...

Heart Disease is mainly caused by a lifetime of poor behaviour in this regard, for example.

Re:The Insanity Virus by defen on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @10:52PM (#1939309)
Yep. But as an example, there is currently research looking into the connection between dental hygiene and heart disease. It's all hypothesis at this point, but a lifetime of eating sugary/starchy foods and poor dental hygiene can lead to gums the inflame/bleed easily, which can lead to bacteria more easily getting into your bloodstream, which may contribute to atherosclerosis.

http://www.webmd.com/heart-disease/features/periodontal-dise...

Re:The Insanity Virus by carbocation on Thursday November 25, 2010 @02:45AM (#1939651)
From that article: "And one study found that the presence of common problems in the mouth, including gum disease (gingivitis), cavities, and missing teeth, were as good at predicting heart disease as cholesterol levels."

From the cardiovascular perspective, it's far simpler to conclude that poor vascular perfusion of the mouth can amplify oral disease than it is to postulate an entirely new paradigm upending decades of established research. Vascular disease predisposes you to infections of the limbs; why would we not expect the same in the mouth?

If offered the ability to bet on one vs the other, this is the situation where I'd use my assets as collateral so I could put the maximum possible wager on the line in favor of vascular disease being the causal entity here, not periodontal disease.

Re:The Insanity Virus by defen on Thursday November 25, 2010 @04:11AM (#1939788)
That was just an example - another potential bad guy could be Chlamydophila pneumoniae. Of course something like heart disease is probably caused by a myriad of interacting factors, so I wouldn't want to take your wager. I definitely don't assign a lot of confidence to the established research in health and nutrition though - for example, I think the food guide pyramid is bad advice and based on bad science, but it's been officially promulgated by the U.S. government for close to two decades now.
Re:The Insanity Virus by AnthonBerg on Thursday November 25, 2010 @06:08AM (#1939953)
That's interesting, can you throw me a link or two about the food guide pyramid and fixes thereto?
Re:The Insanity Virus by defen on Thursday November 25, 2010 @02:48PM (#1940887)
I thought Good Calories, Bad Calories was very good. It's about the bad science behind the high-carb, low-fat diet advice. From there you can get into things like paleo diet etc. I'm not recommending any particular diet - there are plenty of people who think Taubes is full of it (http://reason.com/archives/2003/03/01/big-fat-fake http://www.proteinpower.com/drmike/wp-content/uploads/2008/0...), and I'm not a doctor and have no training in the field. Just an interested observer, since diet, nutrition, and exercise is the base for anything else you're going to do in your life.

Amazon link - http://www.amazon.com/Good-Calories-Bad-Gary-Taubes/dp/14000... Google Books preview - http://books.google.com/books?id=Xdm40JUD9HwC&printsec=f...

Re:The Insanity Virus by rsheridan6 on Thursday November 25, 2010 @08:07AM (#1940150)
Are inflamed, bleeding gums really poorly perfused?