I'd be disinclined to throw out the huge volume of research on the subject of what actually causes heart disease and cancer due to a pithy slogan.
When the evolution subject comes up it always seems to inspire a bunch of would-be scifi writers to come out and explain "how it all works" based on, as near as I can tell, pure fantasy.
Reproduction trumps everything in evolution. It's everything, actually. But for that to be true you can't define it as `number of offspring born', but in a more long-term sense. And e.g. Elephants seem to have more long-term off-spring by investing more in fewer births.
In some cases life history trade-offs differ between the sexes leading to longevity differences. In general, females live longer than males, although in humans the difference is pretty small. There are some extreme examples of this in spiders, such as the tarantula, where the male lives about 2 years and the female 8.
It strikes me as highly implausible that suicide would benefit your close genetic kin more so than staying alive in order to find food and care for offspring, for example.
Heart Disease is mainly caused by a lifetime of poor behaviour in this regard, for example.
http://www.webmd.com/heart-disease/features/periodontal-dise...
From the cardiovascular perspective, it's far simpler to conclude that poor vascular perfusion of the mouth can amplify oral disease than it is to postulate an entirely new paradigm upending decades of established research. Vascular disease predisposes you to infections of the limbs; why would we not expect the same in the mouth?
If offered the ability to bet on one vs the other, this is the situation where I'd use my assets as collateral so I could put the maximum possible wager on the line in favor of vascular disease being the causal entity here, not periodontal disease.
Amazon link - http://www.amazon.com/Good-Calories-Bad-Gary-Taubes/dp/14000... Google Books preview - http://books.google.com/books?id=Xdm40JUD9HwC&printsec=f...