Re:Canada grounds Boeing 737 Max 8
by mikeash on Wednesday March 13, 2019 @01:13PM
(#19380920)
Maybe from the fact that the last fatality in a US airline crash was over ten years ago?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Unfortunately I think Southwest Airlines Flight 1380 in 2018 counts as resetting that streak. It wasn't a crash but it did result in a death. I think your point still stands though. Very few of the incidents on this list are US airlines: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_incident...
That's hardly a unique thing about US airline safety. You're building one heck of a fragile claim there to superiority, a number of other countries can make similar claims, including countries that have similar or better safety records.
Just out of a quick wiki trawl over the last ten years:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UPS_Airlines_Flight_1354 UPS airline plane crashed in 2013, killing all onboard.
In the same year, a commercial flight by Rediske Air crashed in Alaska, all 10 people on-board died.
While not technically a crash, there was a fatality involving US airline just last year, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southwest_Airlines_Flight_1380, making the US airline safety record worse than a good number of countries.
Are you really going to use a UPS crash as an argument here? You actually raise some good points but I can’t get past that one.
"UPS Airlines Flight 1354 was a scheduled cargo flight from Louisville, Kentucky, to Birmingham, Alabama"
U.S. Airline
U.S. origin
U.S. destination
European aircraft (A320)
Seems that the cause was problems with American trained pilots, so it's a strong refutation to the assertion "Maybe from the fact that the last fatality in a US airline crash was over ten years ago? "Despite the name, UPS Airlines is a cargo company, not an airline. If you want to quibble over semantics, just pretend I specified “passenger airline” since that’s what I was talking about and that’s the relevant category.
Cargo companies come under the same regulations. You can't ignore them just because it's detrimental to your narrative.
The regulations are considerably less strict for cargo flights, and they’re notorious for being significantly more dangerous. I’m ignoring them because cargo safety is irrelevant, not because it’s inconvenient.
As far as I could find, there were no Canadian airline crashes in the same time frame. Unless you include small charter-airline type crashes, which would mean some american crashes would be counted too (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_Rediske_Air_DHC-3_Otter_c... )
With less than 1/10th the number of passengers, that’s significantly less meaningful. It does indicate they’re about on an equal footing, though.
That means nothing. All airlines based out of France and Germany are ISOA certified, never had a fatality, and are rated 7/7 by AirlineRatings [0] (industry leader on airline safety ratings), for example.
Sure, because extended suicide by pilot was excluded, but as a passenger I don't care much whether I die because there was a mistake somewhere or because the pilot was criminally insane.
It's downright comical to list Germanwings as "Fatality Free".
Re:Canada grounds Boeing 737 Max 8
by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 13, 2019 @03:07PM
(#19382347)
That web site is nice but it does not correctly rate US-only carriers.
Also, Air France 447 was less than ten years ago. So your data may be suspect.
I assume you mean they haven’t had a fatality in the last ten years, not that they’ve never had a fatality?
Re:Canada grounds Boeing 737 Max 8
by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 13, 2019 @03:08PM
(#19382360)
AF447 was less than ten years ago. So OP is mistaken either way.