News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swastikas and context by train_robber on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @12:31PM (#1937952)
I don't know, the article seemed so badly reasoned from my perspective - a very narrow Western view. In my country (and in my religion) the Swastika is seen everywhere and it is no way used in relation to the Nazis at all. Ironically, the fact that it is such a hated symbol, I learned from the Internet. Maybe he's being reasonable because the target audience is indeed Western. Hmm. But from my seat, I find this really lame.
Re:Swastikas and context by thwarted on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @12:40PM (#1937972)
He really should have put the TL;DR at the top. He could have worded the entire piece as "You may think our policy is capricious and arbitrary but the internet is filled with a lot of jerks. We hope to be consistent in our rulings; you'll just have to deal with it, as we don't want to spend our time dealing with lame issues. And this is a lame issue."
Re:Swastikas and context by akkartik on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @12:45PM (#1937990)
What is the point of putting the tl;dr at the bottom, or the middle, or anywhere but the very top?
Re:Swastikas and context by thwarted on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @12:50PM (#1938008)
I assume to get people to read the piece. TL;DR at the top is kind of like an Executive Summary, and if I saw something labeled an Executive Summary at the top, or even looked like one, I'd skip the whole thing.

I think the key is to make the entire piece short enough but not too long so that it's quick to read and the TL;DR can be used as a good way to describe the entire piece in other contexts.

Re:Swastikas and context by akkartik on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @01:33PM (#1938131)
"TL;DR can be used as a good way to describe the entire piece in other contexts."

Absolutely. Perhaps we just shouldn't be using tl;dr within a piece. There's other words for short forms: abstract, summary, conclusion.

Signed, your friendly tl;dr nazi

Re:Swastikas and context by thwarted on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @05:57PM (#1938772)
Yeah, but I think tl;dr has a certain, not necessarily all negative, connotation. Labeling it as "abstract", "summary" or even "conclusion" maybe would lessen the chances of it being quoted.
Re:Swastikas and context by deadsy on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @12:40PM (#1937971)
Right - In India and in many parts of Asia the symbol is considered as a positive, being used for religious adornment, political parties and product advertising. It's a great piece of graphic art and it's a real pity the Nazis screwed it up with bad associations for the western world. Most Americans aren't aware of the Symbol being used in other contexts (my wife expressed surprise when she saw it on a Balinese temple earlier this year). Perhaps as the USA becomes more multi-cultural the symbol can get rehabilitated.
Re:Swastikas and context by thwarted on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @12:47PM (#1938000)
In India and in many parts of Asia the symbol is considered as a positive, being used for religious adornment, political parties and product advertising.

Heh, as I was reading the above, I was thinking I wouldn't want to see the stereotypical Republican Elephant or Democrat Donkey used by other players in these games either -- it does distract (in some way, it's sad that people have such strong identification with groups and their symbols like that, it reeks of being proud of groupthink). As the author points out: the game isn't a forum to discuss these things, and symbols like those have meanings that are not part of the core intent of the game or why people are there. Presumably trademarks are out too, but that may be more of a civil legal issue than just having to deal with misinterpretation of intent.

Re:Swastikas and context by Avshalom on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @03:39PM (#1938475)
"a very narrow Western view"

Claiming that the swastika is associated with Nazis isn't a "narrow view" if it IS associated with Nazis for half the fucking planet.

Re:Swastikas and context by train_robber on Thursday November 25, 2010 @04:54AM (#1939854)
Half the population of the world? You might need to think about that, not many in Asia or Africa is that concerned about Nazis. That makes it a non-issue for around 75% of the world.