News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coding Horror: Your Internet Driver's License by lmkg on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @12:22PM (#1937929)
Personally, the idea I have in my mind of a (US) driver's license is a universally-accepted form of ID that anyone can get. The facts that it has a test, or that it can be revoked, or that some people don't have one, don't actually register in my head until someone points it out. If it weren't in the name, I wouldn't even connect it with driving. Furthermore, it's the only abstraction I have in my head for a universal ID. Passport's aren't universal (at least in the US) because they're bigger and therefore less convenient, and international travel is somewhat rare. We don't have a universal government-issued ID that's just an ID, so the idea of a national ID card sounds scary and government-intrusive to me. A driver's license is literally the most innocuous and least threatening analogy to make. Until you point out the ways in which it doesn't work the way I think it works.

When most people think of driver's licenses, do they really think government certification, or do they think universal ID? I would be honestly interested in the answer.

Re:Coding Horror: Your Internet Driver's License by alextgordon on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @03:49PM (#1938502)
Personally, the idea I have in my mind of a (US) driver's license is a universally-accepted form of ID that anyone can get.

Don't you have to take a test to obtain a licence? Here in the UK the test is relatively difficult and expensive, so not everybody has a licence. Passports are much cheaper, easier to obtain and don't come with age limits, so they are a more universal form of ID (though they are also bulky and hardly something you would carry around on you).

When most people think of driver's licenses, do they really think government certification, or do they think universal ID? I would be honestly interested in the answer.

When I think of driver's licences, I think of driving a car. Universal ID doesn't occur.

Re:Coding Horror: Your Internet Driver's License by masklinn on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @04:37PM (#1938615)
See his next phrase.
Re:Coding Horror: Your Internet Driver's License by URSpider94 on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @04:05PM (#1938545)
I agree with you that a driver's license is more a form of ID than a public safety credential, if you live in the USA.

Why?

-- You have to take a test to get it, but you do that when you are 16 or 17, and never again. In most states, the test is ridiculously easy.

-- In an average year, you probably use it hundreds of times for its ID value (to buy beer at the grocery store or drinks at a bar, to cash a check, to check in for an airline flight), and (hopefully) zero times for the public safety function (showing it to a police officer after being pulled over).

-- Outside of NYC, the fraction of people over the legal driving age who don't have a license has to be less than 10%