News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by gigatexal on Monday March 11, 2019 @07:59AM (#19358245)
How bad is it that Intel didn't win?
Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by wallnuss on Monday March 11, 2019 @08:13AM (#19358326)
If Intel had one, they would have further consolidated their hold on the HPC/Supercomputer market. Summit is an interesting supercomputer because it's NVidia/Mellanox/IBM instead of the Intel hegemony that Cori II was, iirc the interconnect for Cori was from Cray.

Now NVidia only needs to buy Xilinx...

Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by novaRom on Monday March 11, 2019 @08:47AM (#19358525)
No way. Xilinx is way too expensive already.
Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by cure on Monday March 11, 2019 @09:20AM (#19358710)
There were only ever two major Infiniband vendors: QLogic and Mellanox. Intel already bought QLogic back in 2012.

I'm not sure it would be in anyone's interest for both to be acquired by Intel, even if IB isn't very relevant anymore outside of supercomputing.

Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by greglindahl on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:48PM (#19360436)
Intel bought QLogic's Infiniband assets in 2012, not everything.
Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by chx on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:25PM (#19360188)
> Intel already bought QLogic back in 2012.

Cavium bought QLogic in 2016, Marvell in turn bought Cavium in 2018.

Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by arcanus on Monday March 11, 2019 @08:05AM (#19358279)
It is remarkable they were outbid.

This acquisition has big implications for HPC in particular.

Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by gigatexal on Monday March 11, 2019 @09:08AM (#19358640)
Yeah, Intel is just a bit over 2x the size of Nvidia, and yet they were outbid... to me this is like Apple not being willing to buy Waze and letting them go to Google. Think of what improvement it could have made on Apple maps.
Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by arcaster on Monday March 11, 2019 @09:42AM (#19358870)
Not that bad - intel already has an arguably strong networking department and recently purchased Altera for their FPGA tech. This is why above comments mention the benefits of nVidia purchasing Xilinx - one of the only other serious producers of cutting edge FPGA hardware - which happens to be what makes or breaks most high-throughput networking tech.
Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by gigatexal on Monday March 11, 2019 @09:55AM (#19358970)
But now Nvidia is only a single HPC worthy Arm CPU away from owning all the juicy bits of a HPC: they have the GPUs, now the networking, all they need is the CPUs... vertical integration has its perks.
Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by _q1cj on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:23PM (#19360166)
Yeah - I think this potential next step for nVidia has both good and bad intentions for the world of HPC. However, it'll be interesting to see how they compete with the existing "NetFPGA" open source project. They've essentially been building purpose-built offerings analogous to Intel's recently announced "Intel FPGA Programmable Acceleration Card N3000".

IMO, more of the issues with these advanced networking protocols is latency - something that is usually more addressable via protocol dev than just hardware. Would be very interesting to see nVidia try to acquire Xilinx and supercharge their "Aurora" low overhead transfer protocol...

sources:

https://newsroom.intel.com/news/2019-mwc-intel-announces-nex...

https://netfpga.org/

Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by chx on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:28PM (#19360235)
Xilinx is badly overpriced, no matter how you look at it. You could compare its P/E to similar semiconductor companies, you could compare it to all US companies, you could even look at the predicted P/E growth and it's still overpriced. Every analyst I am aware of currently advises you stay away from XLNX.
Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by bsder on Monday March 11, 2019 @04:32PM (#19362541)
> Xilinx is badly overpriced, no matter how you look at it.

Is it, really?

FPGA's are now all over HPC, the 5G rollout is going to put a LOT of really expensive FPGA's in new towers, and high-end networking gear is about to get a bump due to PCI going up.

I don't know how much damage the Intel acquisition did to Altera, but if Altera has been AWOL with big customers due to the Intel acquisition, Xilinx may have a massive amount of customer wins locked in for a very long time.

I wish Xilinx would die in a hot flaming pit of Hell for many and various reasons, but they are the 500lb gorilla of FPGAs.

Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by chx on Monday March 11, 2019 @05:43PM (#19363131)
Well, let's look at numbers, shall we? XLNX P/E is 37, INTC P/E is 12, MRVL P/E is 22.8, AVGO is 23.19, the current S&P 500 PE is 21.34. Of course P/E is just one number but it's certainly one important number. Do you have a better comparison that makes XLNX at this price an alluring stock?

My original comment reacted to nVidia acquiring Xilinx and I am trying to explain why that won't happen: it's too expensive.

Re:Nvidia to Acquire Mellanox for $6.9B by arcaster on Monday March 11, 2019 @03:46PM (#19362132)
As someone on the sidelines I can confirm that dev boards / most Xilinx products seem to have markedly hire price tags than comparable products from competitors...