News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Estonian parliamentary election, 44% of the votes were... by deogeo on Sunday March 10, 2019 @10:32PM (#19356237)
> a smartcard, secured and provided by state officials [..] The (state-provided) USB reader [..]

are not immune to attack either. Unless you go to the extraordinary lengths of making your own hardware in a facility you secure and keep secured for the duration of your democracy, there is no such thing as a 'secure device'. Not when the prize is something so hugely lucrative and advantageous as control over an entire country.

All assuming you trust your government. With opposition parties monitoring vote counts, that's easy. But what about when they have to look for dopant-level chip defects?

Re:In Estonian parliamentary election, 44% of the votes were... by Latteland on Sunday March 10, 2019 @10:58PM (#19356334)
In Washington state, all voting is via paper ballots mailed or dropped off at a voting location. You sign them. People end up having different ballots because your ballot is customized for the district you live in (unique city, school district, county, state combinations is a reasonable size). They verify your signature. You can track if you ballot was received (it's inside an inner envelope) and if your signature was confirmed or not.

This feels safe, and as they have the original paper, they can revote - but they have all the ones in the district in a box somehow.

Re:In Estonian parliamentary election, 44% of the votes were... by belorn on Monday March 11, 2019 @04:52AM (#19357536)
Who create the security tokens that banks use? I could see few things more lucrative and advantageous than a perfect backdoor into that hardware, especially since here in Sweden you can create electronic government ID from said token which can be used for everything except voting.

It is not without reason that most common fraud here in Sweden (around 80%) is someone calling under false pretense asking a victim to use the hardware token in order for the fraudsters to create a new electronic id which is then used to empty the bank account, create credit accounts, and so on. So far those security tokens has had a perfect track record from a hardware perspective, as much good that does. Maybe that is a bomb waiting to explode but it is hard to see a stronger incentives for criminals than what already exist.

When people here discuss electronic voting, security of the hardware tokens is not usually brought up. It is rather all the other elements which makes it a bad choice. There would be no physical ballots that can be verified, questionable anonymity, and a loss of a controlled voting environment. All the common solutions to those problems usually results in the conclusion that it then easier to just keep the current system as is.

Re:In Estonian parliamentary election, 44% of the votes were... by dbdjfjrjvebd on Monday March 11, 2019 @05:19AM (#19357642)
The thing is that bank security is at least theoretically possible. Banks and/or governments act as a central sources of trust in such systems and trust for can be derived from this source. I.e. a bank could build the hardware tokens from scratch themselves. With an election the trust model is inverted. I'm not sure there is any practical way to allow the trust sources (every voter) to audit the hardware tokens.
Re:In Estonian parliamentary election, 44% of the votes were... by kosievdmerwe on Monday March 11, 2019 @06:55PM (#19363685)
Also importantly, banks don't have to be anonymous. Every transaction has the identities of the people involved.
Re:In Estonian parliamentary election, 44% of the votes were... by hopler on Monday March 11, 2019 @08:44AM (#19358501)
Electronic votes can be secured cryptographically. Votes can be counted per precinct instead of centrally, and then summed. The security factors of paper voting can be replicated electronically.

"The authority might just lie about the count or throw away or counterfeit votes, or coerce voters other vote a certain way" is not solved by paper voting either, as seen in Russia and many other places.