Re:Unconscious brain activity predicts decisions 11 seconds ...
by geofft on Sunday March 10, 2019 @10:34AM
(#19352137)
The researchers did not decode it with 100% accuracy, so one interpretation is that the unconscious mind says "Instinctively, this seems like the right decision," 11 seconds later the conscious mind says either "Oh, yes, I agree with that" or less frequently "Actually I'll do something else", and the researchers are only tracking intuition.
Re:Unconscious brain activity predicts decisions 11 seconds ...
by gus_massa on Sunday March 10, 2019 @12:04PM
(#19352514)
If I understand correctly, the part that says
> up to 11 seconds before they consciously made the decision
should be interpreted as
> up to 11 seconds before they pressed one of the buttons
I can't imagine how they measure the time when the conscious decision was made but they definitively measure when the button was pressed.
Re:Unconscious brain activity predicts decisions 11 seconds ...
by TaupeRanger on Sunday March 10, 2019 @09:52AM
(#19351982)
It doesn't tell us anything about free will other than the fact that the process of decision making happens prior to our conscious awareness, which we already knew.
Re:Unconscious brain activity predicts decisions 11 seconds ...
by rightbyte on Sunday March 10, 2019 @09:55AM
(#19351991)
Ye, it's is kinda obvious that the decision is made before you "know it". How would it otherwise work.
Re:Unconscious brain activity predicts decisions 11 seconds ...
by benj111 on Sunday March 10, 2019 @01:31PM
(#19353056)
I suppose the problem for me is, there isn't really a decision for the conscious mind to work on, the question is trivial without a right or wrong answer, free will doesn't enter into it.
This was choosing horizontal or vertical stripes, there isn't a rational reason not to go with my gut, although I could if I wanted to demonstrate free will.
Re:Unconscious brain activity predicts decisions 11 seconds ...
by nindwen on Sunday March 10, 2019 @09:48AM
(#19351972)
Is the assumption then that "you" means only the conscious part of your brain?
Re:Unconscious brain activity predicts decisions 11 seconds ...
by amelius on Sunday March 10, 2019 @10:01AM
(#19352011)
What happens 11 seconds before the conscious decision can be part of free will, I guess.
So this goes into the question of "free will". Is your conscious mind making the decisions or is just trying to justify the decisions made by the unconscious mind.