For more information on this, you should probably look at what Seymour Papert has been doing in Maine lately.
In other words, he's saying Y follows from X, so if you don't accept Y then you don't believe X. It's the same rhetorical device as saying, "Nobody cares about civil liberties anymore [because George Bush got re-elected]," or "I guess nobody else here loves his country [because I'm the only one who went to the Tea Party rally last weekend]."
It's always easier to stick up for a vague but popular concept (such as liberty, love of country, or active, engaged learning) than to argue in favor of the controversial concrete policies you think follow from it.
"Education involves a transmission of knowledge/information from someone who is bigger and older"
These seem mostly orthogonal to me... the latter just being a generalization of (anecdotal) experience.
"Among cognitive psychologists, there is widespread agreement that people learn best when they are actively engaged with a topic, have to actively problem solve, as we would put it 'construct meaning.' Yet, among individuals young and old, all over the world, there is a view that is incredibly difficult to dislodge. To wit: Education involves a transmission of knowledge/information from someone who is bigger and older (often called 'the sage on the stage') to someone who is shorter, younger, and lacks that knowledge/information. No matter how many constructivist examples and arguments are marshaled, this view — which I consider a misconception — bounces back. And it seems to be held equally by young and old, by individuals who succeeded in school as well as by individuals who failed miserably.
Now this is not a scientific misconception in the sense of flat earth or six days of creation, but it is an example of a conception that is extraordinarily robust, even though almost no one who has studied cognition seriously believes it hold water.
Let me take this opportunity to express my appreciation for your many contributions to our current thinking."