News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by sodosopa on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:28AM (#19339017)
It didn’t matter who gave them the news, that’s a helluva impact. A doctor could be in the room and give the same message in a cold manner as many do each day and the family would have felt the same. The blame on reading the screen is more technophobic and sensationalized.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by potta_coffee on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:32AM (#19339071)
Or the doctor could be in the room and act like somewhat of a human being and break the difficult news in a professional and socially accepted way.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by sodosopa on Friday March 08, 2019 @02:21PM (#19341167)
But that’s also a problem with a lot of physicians, from my experience they provide vague answers and hint around. For one of my recent family members, I pulled her social worker aside and said this is a binary yes or no, Should we call hospice? And even then after much handwringing, the physician blurted it out to my family member despite having health care PoA

In a perfect scenario as it is on television a scholarly physician sits on the bedside, pats the patient’s knee and looks them in the eye and says, “we’ve done all we could”.

I worked in health care for decades, while not in a care role, I went through and managed some of the training programs to improve bedside manner/customer service. I had to document each physician as they spoke with my family member. Because of two of the three experiences they were eager to turn over the bed instead of providing compassionate care

Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by rthomas6 on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:43AM (#19339208)
Do you think it would be possible to deliver the news well via robot? I don't believe so. The news could be delivered well or poorly in person, but it could only be delivered poorly via robot.

But it really doesn't matter what we think about the robot. It matters what that family thought, and they had a problem with it. To say it's okay is to ignore their voice, because in their specific case, they weren't okay with it. It seems cold and lacking in compassion to not allow even such a simple request for the sake of comfort for someone in such a difficult place.

Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by sodosopa on Friday March 08, 2019 @02:22PM (#19341183)
I believe it could be delivered good or bad by both. It depends on so many factors.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by plants on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:36AM (#19339128)
Is "technophobic" really a bad word now? If so, I'm an outright technophobe. If you're going to break hard news to anyone (whether it be a breakup, telling someone their loved one has died, or telling someone they are dying) you might as well give them the benefit of being there in person. You can hug a person, you can't hug a screen.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by pas on Friday March 08, 2019 @03:14PM (#19341731)
People are in general have a very bad handle on fundamental parts of life, like death. (And personal finances, metacognition and so on.) And sure, doctors can play the emergency psychologist while delivering the news, but people don't just go to the hospital and get a random death sentence. They knew there was a very significant chance that the news will be bad. Yes, when the uncertainty evaporates together with the favorable outcome, that's fucking harsh, and there's a process for dealing with that (the good old Kübler-Ross stages come to mind). People should be better prepared for these eventualities. (And I'm not saying it's easy, and people must be perfect stoics, but these theatrics we assign to conveying a few bits of information coupled with the human touch is just a psychology theater.)
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by ripsawridge on Saturday March 09, 2019 @01:01PM (#19347430)
"these theatrics we assign to conveying a few bits of information..."

Really? You really are of the opinion that news about death is just "a few bits of information?" And you are capable of describing the ways humans attempt to be empathic with each other as "these theatrics?"

I'm not sure I want to live in this world. :(

Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by pas on Saturday March 09, 2019 @05:04PM (#19348794)
Yes. You already have an expected lifespan. Getting sick, makes you reevaluate that, and getting a concrete diagnosis with an expert opinion should not be a big change.

Of course, we can do the be positive, be optimistic, you can fight it, you can do it mantra, and then watch as their heart breaks when they get the diagnosis. Empathy shouldn't mean helping people to delay facing the hard problems and truths.

This is the same world that largely considers suicide a crime, and denies a dignified and conscious end of life to a lot of suffering people. I watched as a family member went through the stages of physiological and mental decline, dementia, muscle atrophy, and eventually even breathing was a full time job, and it became too much. And it was a relatively painless end. (And there were others with different, faster ends. Recently one with cancer.) And taking it for what it is seemed the healthier mindset and approach.

Accepting the inevitable led to those last days and months better spent. And preparing for it is just as important.

We already drag doctors into enough futile quarrels of our own. At least that's my opinion.

Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by ripsawridge on Thursday March 21, 2019 @06:18AM (#19450601)
Sorry for the long delay, I just saw your reply. I agree with you more than I disagree. That is -- facing truths is important. Suicide should not be a crime. A dignified death is often about knowing when to go, and that choice is the final sentence of the long book that is a life.

I don't want to drag doctors into "futile quarrels." I just think that the occasion of death is special, and deserves to be communicated face to face, not with robots (oh sorry, with iRobots).

Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by potta_coffee on Friday March 08, 2019 @12:04PM (#19339425)
It's just an ad hominem attack. I don't agree with you, so you're a "phobe". Technology isn't really the issue here.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by eli on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:32AM (#19339064)
That telepresence robot looks ridiculous. I would absolutely not want to have a serious conversation through it.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by ergothus on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:37AM (#19339137)
Agreed - While I have HUGE sympathy for doctors that have to deliver this kind of news, I have numerous complaints about the care and attention I get from my doctors today when they AREN'T remote - I don't see remote as really being relevant here: Attitude and behavior count for a lot more.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by sp0rk on Friday March 08, 2019 @01:24PM (#19340426)
> A doctor could be in the room and give the same message in a cold manner as many do each day and the family would have felt the same.

So you think we should systematically bring this poor experience to everyone via robots because some human doctors perform the same task poorly?

Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by sodosopa on Friday March 08, 2019 @02:23PM (#19341205)
I think we should make it agnostic to where it doesn’t matter how the person gets the message. Couple either experience with support groups.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by vividtulips on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:37AM (#19339139)
"Daughter Catherine Quintana says the family is also upset because her father had trouble hearing the doctor through the robot's speaker forcing Wilharm to relay the terrible news."

The blame is on the full device, not just the screen.

Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by mc32 on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:36AM (#19339123)
I don’t think so. While the results don’t change, a lot of human sociability is about doing the nothings in life. Like going through the motions of offering to pay yet knowing it’s the other person who’s going to pay (maybe they invited you, have more money, etc.,) still it’s consideted bad manners not to at least feign an offer.

Same here. The doctor and hospital should strive to be as human and empathetic as possible given the bad news. Adding an electronic intermediary created distance and adds coldness and the artifice of bureaucracy to the event.

Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by sodosopa on Friday March 08, 2019 @02:28PM (#19341260)
Couple each experience with social workers, religious staff and the patient’s care team. While a physician isn’t physically in the room, a caring influence over the discussion could help despite being a cold doc or a cold robot.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by Darkstack on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:51AM (#19339279)
It's true that it didn't matter who gave them the news, but a lot of what we call "communication" is non verbal, so I think the screen did not help. You can forgive someone for something if he's in front of you, i doubt you would forgive him the same way by SMS/Phone call.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by danso on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:36AM (#19339120)
The point of having a doctor in the room versus a video screen is that the presence of the human is generally less "cold". Besides the audio quality problems the family describes, the manner of delivery has connotations of mass-produced automated service, which also feels cold.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by plants on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:40AM (#19339169)
"We're sorry, you have termin -kshhhh- cer. Our models estimate you have -kshhhh- to live. Have a nice day!"
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by Mizza on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:31AM (#19339051)
> technophobic

Welcome to 2019, everybody!

Won't somebody _please_ think of the robots!

Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by whymauri on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:35AM (#19339109)
This is a weird comment. When people are claustrophobic the implication is not that we need to sympathize with closed-spaces. You're injecting a meaning that was almost surely unintended to make a shaky ironic point.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by presscast on Friday March 08, 2019 @11:39AM (#19339166)
You're feeding a troll.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by Mizza on Friday March 08, 2019 @12:32PM (#19339779)
I'm not a troll, I'm seriously objecting to the idea that we should reject the concerns of a dying person as "technophobic", as if that's some kind of silver bullet in an argument in favor of technology. I've never heard anybody seriously say "technophobic" before and I found it rather shocking and naive.
Re:Doctor tells patient he doesn't have long to live through... by presscast on Friday March 08, 2019 @05:26PM (#19342809)
Ah, I do apologize then. I misinterpreted your post.