News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Re-entry to US without backscatter or pat-down by aperiodic on Monday November 22, 2010 @10:43PM (#1932431)
I work at a nuclear reactor, and for the type of dosimeters we wear on the job (thermoluminescent dosimeters), there's no chance of a false-positive, as far as I'm aware. The only thing that can cause the crystal to lose electrons is ionizing radiation in a certain energy range. As long as there were procedures to ensure that the badges are only worn on the job, false positives shouldn't be an issue.
Re:Re-entry to US without backscatter or pat-down by rmc on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @10:00AM (#1933863)
As long as there were procedures to ensure that the badges are only worn on the job, false positives shouldn't be an issue.

And that's how your false positives happen. How many people would have to wear dosimetres? Would they be mandatory? How many people per year will leave them at home and borrow their workmate's dosimeter so the boss doesn't give out? How many will drive home in their uniforms? Go to the shops in their uniforms? There are loads of ways for errors to happen.

Nuclear reactors are (I'm guessing) very strict on their policys, it's foolish to extrapolate that to airport workers.

Re:Re-entry to US without backscatter or pat-down by amanfredi on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @12:55PM (#1934627)
After all this, you don't think the TSA is strict on their policies?
Re:Re-entry to US without backscatter or pat-down by aperiodic on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @08:24PM (#1936121)
It's not very hard to solve this problem. At work, we just have a bunch of small cubbies where everyone keeps their dosimeters. When you come in, you take it out and put it on; when you leave, you take it off and put it in. Occasionally people forget to take their dosimetry off, but it's not a big deal–it's extremely unlikely you're going to receive a significant dose outside of the facility (although you are constantly receiving a low-level radiation dose from cosmic rays, and, if you're below ground, from radon gas). I should mention that I work at a test reactor where the typical dosage is so low that the Federal Government doesn't even require us to track employee dose. I get more dose from flying cross-country several times a year[1] than I do working at the reactor. So, I don't know how dosimetry policy differs at power reactors.

Regardless, I think it would be particularly illuminating if there <i>were</i> false positives. Why not have employees who are concerned wear dosimeters constantly, and at the same time stick reference dosimeters near where they usually stand while a scanner is in operation. If their dose is roughly the same as that of the reference dosimetry, there's not much room to complain about the scanners.

The fact is we are being constantly bombarded by low-level radiation from cosmic rays and radon gas simply by virtue of standing on the surface of the earth. The level of radiation these scanners output is much smaller than that. Wikipedia[2] cites an article in the European Journal of Radiology that gives a dose range for backscatter machines of between 0.07 and 6 micro-Sieverts. For reference, the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements reports that the annual radiation dose from naturally occurring radiation is on the order of several hundred micro-Sieverts [3].

TSA employees have a right to be concerned, because they are involuntarily being exposed to it as a course of their job, without this being made clear to them when they were hired. If you're a traveler, you should be much more concerned about the radiation dose you receive on the plane than the one you receive from the scanner.

[1] Health Physics Society page on radiation exposure on commercial airflights: http://hps.org/publicinformation/ate/faqs/commercialflights..... [2] https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Backscatter_X... [3] http://hps.org/documents/environmental_radiation_fact_sheet....

Re:Re-entry to US without backscatter or pat-down by stcredzero on Friday November 26, 2010 @05:55PM (#1943590)
If you're a traveler, you should be much more concerned about the radiation dose you receive on the plane than the one you receive from the scanner.

I dislike "spherical cow" assumptions when they are applied to my health. If you are a government agency, then applying "spherical cow" assumptions by imposition to large numbers of people is inexcusable.

http://compilerbitch.livejournal.com/218216.html

Backscatter X-rays are completely unlike the radiation you receive on a cross country flight. Natural high energy tends to deposit energy evenly throughout your body. The energies in backscatter are manipulated so that the majority of the energy is deposited near the surface of your body.

We don't have that much data on the effects of low energy X-rays, because we didn't have many applications for them until recently. We do not understand in complete detail the mechanisms by which radiation causes cancer. We have equations for predicting cancer rates for radiation doses, but these are entirely adhoc and empirical! We don't have a first-principles understanding of this stuff yet. We don't know enough to say for sure that this application of X-rays is safe. I'd only feel safe if there were experiments on a bunch of lab animals.

Re:Re-entry to US without backscatter or pat-down by AngryParsley on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @06:58AM (#1933419)
Yes, with standardized work-issued dosimeters, training, and strict obedience to policies, you will reduce false positives. They'll still happen, though. Some types of dosimeters will read positive if exposed to heat or sunlight. Some are sensitive to oils or dirt. One nuclear waste disposal facility had false positive rates around 5% per quarter (http://www.osti.gov/bridge/product.biblio.jsp?osti_id=515496). They eventually found the lights in their building to be a major cause.

Now take that information and extrapolate it to using dosimeters in every airport in the nation. Even if the TSA deployed dosimeters as competently as a nuclear waste disposal facility, they would still get so many false positives that the dosimeters would be useless.

Re:Re-entry to US without backscatter or pat-down by jballanc on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @02:37AM (#1932926)
You'll get false positives if anyone goes for a cardiac stress test...
Re:Re-entry to US without backscatter or pat-down by aperiodic on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @05:00AM (#1933202)
That's why you only wear your dosimetry when you're at work.
Re:Re-entry to US without backscatter or pat-down by jballanc on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @12:54AM (#1936633)
Wouldn't matter. Cardiac stress tests usually use technetium or some other radioactive tracer which remains in the body for a day or two after the test. That means that, for the next day or so, you are a "radiation hazard" (not really, but the dosimeters don't know the difference, or at least that's what I was told by the radiation control officer).
Re:Re-entry to US without backscatter or pat-down by Vivtek on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @08:49AM (#1933619)
From all this uproar lately, sounds like work is a cardiac stress test for the TSA.
Re:Re-entry to US without backscatter or pat-down by shpxnvz on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @09:30AM (#1933748)
Not nearly as much as it is for the passengers.

For all the uproar, as of the last time I went through TSA security (about a week before the new "sexual assault" procedures started), the screeners seemed to be perfectly happy in their roles.