Re:Let over Lambda – Common Lisp Book (2008)
by varjag on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @05:43AM
(#19317903)
There are numerous great Lisp books by knowledgeable authors which have none of that attitude. Life is too short to read printouts of Usenet rants.
Re:Let over Lambda – Common Lisp Book (2008)
by coldtea on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @07:32AM
(#19318377)
Well, to each their own. For me life's too short to read authors walking on eggshells.
Of course for a technical book it's the technical content that matters -- whether it's presented politely or not.
Re:Let over Lambda – Common Lisp Book (2008)
by varjag on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @10:45AM
(#19319713)
In which way for example Siebel's PCL is "walking on eggshells"? On Lisp? PAIP? Am I super obtuse and missing some very obvious and important point they are tiptoeing around?
Even if one does really think it's important to convey they are presenting superior technology, it can be stated clearly and concisely without sounding corrosive.
Re:Let over Lambda – Common Lisp Book (2008)
by letoverkappa on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @06:53AM
(#19318203)
"Deservedly condescending" is not an actual thing that exists in the world.
The words you're looking for are "writes poorly."
Re:Let over Lambda – Common Lisp Book (2008)
by coldtea on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @07:31AM
(#19318373)
>"Deservedly condescending" is not an actual thing that exists in the world.
There's absolutely no rational reason for it not to be a thing.
"Politely condescending" might be a contradiction in terms, but some people just lend themselves to being treated condescendingly.
Same thing with how some people might deserve a sarcastic response -- sarcasm is not that remote from condescension.
As in arts and politics, some curmudgeons are needed in every field, if not for anything else, to show that there's another way than the mainstream.
(They don't have to be perfectly right either -- it's having a strong perspective that counts, nobody is 100% right anyway).