News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by simonh on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @04:07AM (#19309224)
>Easy. The Capitalism system is about predators and those who get eaten.

The primary ways people in capitalism get successful is by developing new technology or products, providing valuable services and employing people. The heroes of capitalism most celebrated here are people like Steve Jobs, Bill gates and Elon Musk. All of them have built fantastically successful companies, developing innovative and valuable new products and payed the wages of thousands or tens of thousands of people directly, and built ecosystems employing millions. All of those people benefited. Their customers benefited from useful products. Their suppliers benefited, their employees benefited otherwise why work for them? That is what capitalism is about.

But ok, you disagree, that's fine. I'm sure you must have good reasons. Please, tell me what non-capitalist system is better, how does it work and where has it been shown to be successful?

Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by KozmoNau7 on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @08:06AM (#19310226)
Are you just going to ignore the predatory business practices, competitor strongarming and buyouts, deliberate sabotage and every other unethical thing those people did, and still do to this day?
Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by simonh on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @08:31AM (#19310354)
No I'm not ignoring anything, that's why we have laws which by and large are actually enforced. Competition can be tough and so it should be, but we do have boundaries and when companies and individuals cross them they should be pushed back to face the consequences. Microsoft has been successfully prosecuted many times, for example. Google and Facebook are being reigned in by the EU. That's the sign of a system that works.

I'm genuinely interested in what you see as alternatives though. I'd love to turn this in a constructive direction. How do you see these weaknesses or failures of capitalism being addressed and what alternative system do you favour? How do you see innovations like those of Bill gates, Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak, Elon Musk, Page and Brin, etc being created and being successful, building new businesses without Capitalism?

Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by profalseidol on Monday March 18, 2019 @09:41PM (#19427309)
I hope my comment is not too late:

Have a look at Mondragon Cooperatives. It's a real life large scale implementation of Woker-owned Cooperatives. Not perfect but it does show a lot of the good possibilities.

Back in 2008 when the regular Capitalism crash happens where we plebs payed capitalists:

Mondragon: Spain's giant co-operative where times are hard but few go bust:

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/mar/07/mondragon-spai...

TL;DR of this article - Workers of Mondragon's Washing Machine factory got redundant due to recession lowering demand for their products. Instead of lay-offs, they compensated by lowering wages of managers (note that they have a rule where there is a max ratio of salary from lowest salary). Then offered these workers to retrain for free with commute allowance. Or offered early retirement with complete benefits and cash out their ownership.

---

In general, the Theory of Value makes sense to me:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_value_(economics)

Capitalism doesn't just take a huge cut in what we deserve. But has also stripped us of our humanity.

Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by KozmoNau7 on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @11:31AM (#19311664)
Considering the absolutely massive control corporate interests have over politics in the entire western world, I would say that the rules and laws have been ineffective at best, and downright harmful in a lot of cases.

The fact that MS have gotten a few slaps on the wrist, and that the EU rolled out GDPR to at least try to keep some semblance of privacy, is completely meaningless when you look at the massive profits MS gets from government contracts (through lobbying and favoritism), and the absolute havoc the latest EU copyright reform will cause for any internet-based business not big/rich enough to implement perfect automated upload filters. Funnily enough, Google and FB have the resources, so they're putting up a token protest, but in truth they know they will be benefitting from this legislation.

As for an alternative, you're arguing from a compromised starting point. You assume that we even need individual achievers like Bill Gates et. al., which is highly symptomatic of primarily American individualism and exceptionalism, and to a point also Ayn Randian objectivism. You see it everywhere, people put their heroes on pedestals, glorify them and attribute them great wisdom in all matters, due to their skills in one area.

It's the cult of celebrity, and there is a tendency to glorify the singular great achiever, while completely disregarding the foundations, all of the people who came before and laid the groundwork for progress. We are not standing on the shoulders of giants, we are standing on the shoulders of millions of ordinary people, who each did part of a greater collective whole. No man is an island, after all. No one came to where they are today purely through individual will and effort.

We don't need these massive businesses and we certainly don't need the people at the top, the rent-seekers who extract great wealth from the labor of others. Absolutely nothing created under the rule of Steve Jobs, Elon Musk et. al. created required their presence or even their existence. Innovation and progress doesn't happen on an individual level, it is a collective process.

So what I propose is to abolish to cult of imagined singular achievement, and realize that we can only achieve greatness by collective means, by working together. We may each be individuals with individualist streaks, but as a society we are a great collective of individuals.

What we need is to work together, to collectively own the values and value-creating constructs of our society. When people own a fair share, instead of a pittance, funnily enough their enthusiasm and loyalty goes way up.

Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by simonh on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @01:21PM (#19312766)
Ok, so how is this co-operation organised? Who sets the objectives, makes the decisions and how is success incentivised?
Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by KozmoNau7 on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @05:26PM (#19314850)
Organization would be via horizontal democracy, everyone on equal terms and footing. In the case of larger groups, delegates can be chosen (with no additional power or authority, they simply represent the decisions of their group).

You're still thinking from a capitalistic viewpoint, of individualism to the detriment of collective progress.

Objectives would be set collectively, decisions would be taken collectively, success would be collective and incentivized by the collectively progress that would be achieved.

If personal financial gain is your only motivator, you need to check your greed.

I'm not going to post long political discourses here. Read Peter Kropotkin's "The Conquest Of Bread" and Thomas Piketty's "Capital In The 21st Century". There's a lot more to read than just those, but they're a good start, to introduce you to how capitalism is wreaking havoc on the world.

Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by simonh on Thursday March 07, 2019 @08:37AM (#19327879)
Can you give an example of when or where a large scale political or organisational system like that has operated successfully?
Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by imtringued on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @06:45AM (#19309880)
When you look at the success of people like Bill Gates or Mark Rober (he didn't build the glitterbox but got the credit) or Elon Musk the first step is to already have money. Then the "hero" uses that money to get the new product from someone else and then do something the inventor couldn't do because the "hero" has better connections: sell the thing to a (big) customer.
Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by simonh on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @08:29AM (#19310341)
Bill did have a wealthy parent but didn't really leverage that in the early days. Anyway Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak founded Apple from a garage, but I notice you ignored my mention of them for the purposes of your response. Elon Musk stated with pretty much nothing, and has talked about how he lived off a dollar a day when he founded Zip2.

If you go looking for people from wealthy backgrounds you'll find them, although you actually failed even at that, but they aren't the only kind. As another example Zuckerberg and Saverin founded TheFacebook.com with $2,000 scraped together while they were students. Google was also founded out of a garage.

Anyway, what's wrong with people with money using it productively to found successful companies, and employ people and provide valuable services? Surely that's a good thing? It seems to have worked well for China over the last 30 years, certainly compared to the previous 30.

Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by cleong on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @10:38AM (#19311189)
I'm pretty sure Bill Gate's mom was friends with a IBM board member which is how he got that meeting to provide them with an OS in the first place
Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by simonh on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @01:19PM (#19312739)
IBM wanted to put CP/M on their computer, and mistakenly thought Microsoft owned CP/M because they produced a CP/M add-on card for the Apple II. Initially Bill actually referred them to Digital research, who actually did own CP/M, because at the time Microsoft didn't have an operating system to offer. It was only after the deal between IBM and DR fell through that Microsoft got a second shot at it.
Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by lolcat5e on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @08:36AM (#19310380)
It helps if you know how to leverage the legal system to get a good deal (and the personality which can negotiate a good deal). If you can exploit something which is scalable using new technology, that helps. And the IP and copyright laws are tilted against their stated aim - to benefit society. They almost always protect the IP owner to the detriment of society.
Re:Why People Don't Get Wealthy by simonh on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @08:52AM (#19310467)
I would agree that some IP regulations go too far nowadays. Software patents are a mistake and copyright terms too long, but the basic idea of protecting and encouraging creators and innovators is a good one. Society benefits when creation and innovation is protected and supported.

Anyway, beyond software patents and copyright terms do you content that IP protections in general are a mistake? How do you see an alternative system working?