News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by chipperyman573 on Monday March 04, 2019 @07:25PM (#19307067)
A bug by the same author (referenced in the article) that allowed anyone to undetectably upload a sitemap to any other person's website (and appear at the top of search results by claiming to be associated with the website) only got $5000, when it could have easily been sold for tens of thousands to blackhat SEO companies. So the answer is probably "way less than street value but still nonzero"

http://www.tomanthony.co.uk/blog/google-xml-sitemap-auth-byp...

Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by tptacek on Monday March 04, 2019 @07:50PM (#19307186)
That's a really good bug! But $5k sounds pretty reasonable, since the only alternative market for it comes with pretty obscene legal risk (unlike an RCE, which will have a whole variety of white- and grey- market buyers, an SEO bug seller knows exactly what their buyer is doing with their work).
Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by CPLX on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @06:53AM (#19309918)
Just curious as an academic matter here. What’s the legal risk from an exploit like this?

Is the idea that manipulating URL’s like that for the victim site amounts to unauthorized use of their computer, hence CFAA stuff?

Just curious how an expert would draw the line between black hat SEO and TOS violations and actual illegal acts.

Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by TomAnthony on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @03:36AM (#19309091)
OP here. Really interesting to get your take on that. From my (far less security educated) POV the Google XML bug felt less risky from a monetisation angle.

I guess the difference is between exploiting it yourself vs selling it. There was a clear path to monetisation that didn't require selling the exploit on the black market, and which could well fly under the radar (from my reasonably well educated SEO POV).

However, I don't think bug bounties necessarily need to equal the 'market value' of the bug, whatever that means.

Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by chipperyman573 on Friday March 15, 2019 @12:22AM (#19396515)
Just to clarify, when I said market value I was referring to the highest price you would get if you sold it on the open market (of course in this case you wouldn't just list it on ebay). Which is different from Google's bug bounty program as they are the only buyers in that system and could offer you as little as they wanted (or nothing at all), and you would have no recourse.
Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by tptacek on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @04:13PM (#19314305)
The logic I'd use is that selling a bug with full knowledge of the specific criminal or tortious activity it will be put to use in is more dangerous than selling a bug that has a relatively diverse market of buyers and for which you'd have strong plausible deniability (not to mention a network of gray-market middlemen insulating you from any actual knowledge of offenses). My mental model of this is Stephen Watt --- but I only know the surface level of what was reported in that case.

Generally just my logic would be: selling bugs for which there's an established market is safer than selling one-off bugs to idiosyncratic buyers.

Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by TomAnthony on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @05:00PM (#19314661)
That makes absolute sense to me, and I agree.

However, it doesn't cover the aspect that some bugs are directly monetizable without needing to be sold (as was the case with my Google XML Sitemap exploit).

Of course, there is a risk to directly monetizing such a bug too, but the risk calculation is then different.

Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by wolco on Monday March 04, 2019 @08:56PM (#19307477)
If you are in this business you are already connected with grey/black elements. Probably less risky than initially seems.
Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by Izmaki on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @02:14AM (#19308708)
Plus I think it's safe to assume that they can handle themselves, anonymity wise. Tor and bitcoin is not rocket science
Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by paxys on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @02:50AM (#19308905)
Bug bounties don't exist to prevent people from selling exploits on the black market. Those who were going to do so will do it anyways, and companies don't want a scenario where they have to bid against other buyers for such reports.

They simply exist as a small incentive for folks who would have otherwise done nothing.

Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by comboy on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @07:06AM (#19309975)
I don't understand your reasoning. If you are a black hat and you can get more money for the bug from the company than from selling it on the black market, why would you sell it on the black market?
Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by paxys on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @04:34PM (#19314457)
That's not what I said. A black hat can still try and sell it to the company, but (1) it won't be through the bug bounty process and (2) they are likely not going to pay "market price", whatever that is.
Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by notamy on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @07:37AM (#19310112)
Because maybe I can report it once to the company and make X amount of money, but if the black market price is X / 2, I can potentially sell it many times and make significantly more than X.
Re:Facebook exploit – Confirm website visitor identities by comboy on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @07:47AM (#19310151)
What I mean by black market price is total amount of money that you can make on that bug selling it on the black market.