News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by danudey on Monday March 04, 2019 @02:04PM (#19304193)
The problems are:

1. Society expects women to do this work, and devalues men who do it. This means that mothers are often left responsible for children, and thus they lose out compared to men (or women who choose not to have children, or haven't yet). We're effectively punishing women for continuing our species.

2. Without these sort of support structures in place, managers will look at women as a liability; "but what if she has a kid and then she has to miss work all the time?"

Your argument is basically "these women aren't as dedicated, or otherwise they wouldn't have had kids". The reality is that having children is important, and women specifically shouldn't have to look at having children as the end of their career, or at least their career advancement, because Amazon refuses to provide something which other companies already do.

Essentially this is an Amazon problem because it's only a liability at companies who don't provide this sort of opportunity, which other companies do. Amazon is basically saying "We don't care about what women have to deal with, that's your problem not ours" and talented women are going to learn that lesson and go elsewhere where neither they nor their spouses have to make those sacrifices.

Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by tomp on Monday March 04, 2019 @03:14PM (#19304902)
> Society expects women to do this work, and devalues men who do it

By "society", you men "women", right? The reality is that as much as men like young, fertile, nurturing women, women as well like dominant, successful men (speaking of heterosexuals at least). The so called "choreplay" doesn't lead to more sex, as it turns out. [1] (With the obvious disclaimer that it's just one not-the-most-scientific study, and there's also the other perspective of men now wanting women who earn more... my point is though, that it's not some oppressive "society" boogeyman, but pretty clear (average hetero-)sexual preferences of actual people.)

> The reality is that having children is important

Is it? For whom? Maybe for society, but probably not for Amazon. Why should then Amazon pay for it. As it turns out, Amazon can afford it, but your run-of-the-mill garage startup can't. I think that if the government/society wants to support people having children (which I think is a good idea, at least as long as we claim immigration to be a good idea), then they should also structure incentives appropriately. For example, they could pay for maternity/parental leave, and even reward companies whose employees have newborns (that would also neatly take care of the problem where incentivizing childbirth has the least effect on the smartest cohorts of the population; if the benefits are proportional to salary, you'll incentivize smart ambitious hard-working people to procreate).

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/09/magazine/does-a-more-equa...

Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by ams6110 on Monday March 04, 2019 @02:34PM (#19304483)
(1) was certainly true even fairly recently. I think it is less true in the past 10 years at least.

> women specifically shouldn't have to look at having children as the end of their career, or at least their career advancement

Why not? All choices have consequences. Nobody can really "have it all." I (a male) have definitely made work choices that limited my income and advancement so I could have more time to spend on things involving kids and family.

Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by ep103 on Monday March 04, 2019 @02:56PM (#19304706)
Its badly worded. The idea is that men and women should both be affected by having kids, and if that means less career advancement, then so be it. But the assertions is that a choice between a man and a woman to have kids shouldn't result in only the woman seeing less career advancement.

You can make this argument for and against pretty easily, I think. But I would prefer to live in a world where a woman gets months off to have and start raising a kid, and a man gets the same amount of time off to bond with their new born child. Thereby spreading the impact of having children equally across both sexes, and creating what I think would be a better world.

Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by tomp on Monday March 04, 2019 @03:18PM (#19304947)
> Thereby spreading the impact of having children equally across both sexes, and creating what I think would be a better world.

What makes you think that both sexes (on average) want the same things? Is it possible that women want to spend more time with children, and men want to spend more time competing? (If "no", what would make you change your mind?)

Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by ep103 on Monday March 04, 2019 @04:35PM (#19305804)
Sure, so give both the option of maternity leave, and let the ones who want to take it do so, and others who don't, won't.
Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by tomp on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @03:31AM (#19309077)
I support that. But: (i) that won't address the advantage non-parents have, (ii) different choices will still result in different/unequal "impact", if you measure it by outcomes, and (iii) women will always be hit harder, because (most) literally have to take time off (giving birth is physically harms the body) whereas men don't.

Personally, I think the best solution is (1) have generic parenthood leave (but not forced), (2) have the government pay for it, and (3) reward new parents and companies who's employees have new kids.

(1) makes it (roughly) gender-equal, (2) encourages small businesses/startups (who otherwise won't be able to afford Amazon-like benefits - a paid one-year absence is extremely impactful for a 5-person company, whereas Amazon can just statistically assume that a certain % of its workforce will be out of work at any moment), (3) equalizes the economic value of mothers, fathers and non-parents, and also incentivizes high-income, well educated, smarter and more ambitious people to have kids (assuming the rewards are proportional to taxes/salary), which most "kid-having incentive programs" fail to do (e.g. strong social security will encourage low-income families to have more kids).

Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by ep103 on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @11:40AM (#19311746)
I'm not sure I'm okay with the measuring by outcome. So I like #s 1 and 2, but not so sure about #3.

By rewarding a couple for having children, you are also punishing couples who choose not to have children and focus on their career. A couple shouldn't be punished because they choose to have a child, having children is human and our system should support that. But if a couple chooses to have children, they shouldn't expect to be rewarded with benefits that bring them back up to the level of a person who forwent that experience to focus on continuing to work.

If you're worried that by only offering the opportunity to benefits, that men will disproportionately turn them down while women will need to take them (because giving birth physically harms the body), then 1) that just means the benefits involved should be made to be more appealing to men as well, and 2) I'm not completely convinced that's a bad thing

Equality of opportunity, not equality of outcome.

Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by tomp on Thursday March 07, 2019 @07:29AM (#19327454)
> you are also punishing couples who choose not to have children and focus on their career

If the society values children, that's what it should do. In particular, it should find ways to specifically reward/incentivise particularly the smart, productive, capable people who the society most wants to procreate (assuming those traits are somewhat heritable, by genes, culture or both), and who are most likely to focus on their career otherwise (because the expected opportunity cost of not focusing on career is the biggest for them).

You get what you incentivise.

I think I agree with the second part of your comment (men/women), although I'm not sure I exactly get what you're trying to say - looks like you're addressing my point (1), not (3).

Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by EpicEng on Monday March 04, 2019 @03:04PM (#19304809)
But what about biology? Biologically, men and women are _not_ equal in terms of giving birth and caring for a child. They're just not, and there's no changing that.
Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by TheHypnotist on Monday March 04, 2019 @02:53PM (#19304681)
"Women specifically"

Childcare doesn't just affect women.

Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by jumpman500 on Monday March 04, 2019 @03:06PM (#19304818)
I don't think his argument was directed at women. It was comparing the person who throws their life away to work against someone that chooses to have a life outside of work.

Yes there's cultural context that puts more pressure on women to have a life outside of work, but anyone can choose to have a life outside of work. Shouldn't the company give the most compensation to the person that gives most of their time and energy to their work? I don't want to defend that way of life. I think having a family and life is a good thing, but some people do nothing except work and should probably get more compensation for it.

To me the problem is just that people wrap their entire self worth up into the dollar amount they make. Having a family is usually much more fulfilling than a successful career. I know lots of men and women that have made that chosen family over work and are way happier for it.

Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by rebuilder on Monday March 04, 2019 @03:01PM (#19304757)
It's a family issue and an economy issue. A society where only women are expected to bear the career cost of having children is a societh where half the workforce has their career growth stunted. The age where you have kids is very important careerwise. I think if you can improve women's career prospects, the effects for family income and overall economic output can be quite significant.
Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by hnaccy on Monday March 04, 2019 @02:10PM (#19304240)
>The reality is that having children is important, and women specifically shouldn't have to look at having children as the end of their career, or at least their career advancement

Why?

Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by jjeaff on Monday March 04, 2019 @02:16PM (#19304304)
You seriously don't see why having children is important? How about the total extinction of the human race in a single generation?
Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by jakelazaroff on Monday March 04, 2019 @02:25PM (#19304393)
Are you asking why having children is important, or why it's bad that women (and not men) often have to choose between children and career advancement?
Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by keiferski on Monday March 04, 2019 @02:11PM (#19304256)
Because sacrificing the family unit at the altar of corporate capitalism probably isn't the right thing to do?
Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by hnaccy on Monday March 04, 2019 @02:16PM (#19304302)
Daycare while both parents work on their careers all year is the family unit?
Re:Holdout Jeff Bezos Confronted by Amazon Moms Demanding Da... by AndrewGaspar on Monday March 04, 2019 @02:24PM (#19304384)
Yeah, honestly amazed that somebody would straight faced make the argument that not taking time off to raise your children in order to spend more time at work (which is a perfectly fine choice, I'm not arguing it's not!) is somehow sticking it to the man.