News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:14AM (#19294788)
Is an ethical hammer even possible?
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by coldtea on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:21AM (#19294824)
A, the old "it's how you use the tool" chestnut.

Only some tools are inherently abusable -- something that has been expressed in lots of forms, from "the medium is the message" critique of TV/internet/etc, to the gun control debate ("guns don't kill people, people kill people" etc).

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by mcguire on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:24AM (#19294838)
Could you provide some examples of tools which are not inherently abusable? I can't think of any.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by coldtea on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:08PM (#19296510)
You can't very much abuse a shoe to cause harm.

Or a fax machine.

Or broccoli.

Or a pencil.

(Yeah, you could stab someone in the eye with the latter, but it's not something inherently violent about a pencil more than 2000 other things you could do it with, and most people would never do anything like that despite having used one).

Other things however, are either precisely made for harm and profit (e.g. a grenade, or "Hot Pockets"), or lend themselves very well to it (e.g. dynamite, internet cookies, etc.).

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by jakelazaroff on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:48AM (#19294984)
I think the point is more like: consider how often a gun is abused vs. a blanket. Surely it's not a stretch to conclude that the former enables unethical acts far more than the latter.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by mindslight on Sunday March 03, 2019 @11:57AM (#19295394)
That framing only captures half of the truth though. The quality a gun has that a blanket does not is to enable adversarial actions. So yes, the technology of the gun does enable unethical actions like point-and-click murder. But it also enables individuals and smaller groups to defend themselves against aggressors, which most people would consider ethical.

I'm not disagreeing with the idea that "artifacts have politics" [0], but rather pointing out that focusing solely on the negative actions enabled by guns is fallacious. In fact, the development of firearms is historically seen as having democratized power. It's just that most of what we consider the positive effects have been incorporated into the framework of our society, while we continue trying to diminish the negative ones.

Now having said that, so far "AI" (really ML) is primarily being wielded by large centralized entities against individuals. A less-equipped defending army does not particularly benefit from having a few drones with facial recognition, as their human soldiers are under attack regardless. Whereas it does enable a much larger conquering army to further insulate itself from the results of war.

Even relatively benign uses like voice recognition or recommendations have become excuses to retain large surveillance datasets on our entire society, and to shape the development so results favor large centralizing entities rather than their supposed users - eg the common engagement metric of "human time wasted".

But are the ethical issues the result of "AI" technology itself, or better attributed to the larger system its deployed upon? On the consumer side, I would say that the fundamental ethical problem is that software is not under its users control. If the majority of training sets were being accumulated voluntarily, with the goal of developing applications that actually helped users, then I think the ethical landscape would look quite different.

[0] If you don't recognize the reference, search it.

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by sgt101 on Monday March 04, 2019 @03:08AM (#19299597)
Firearms didn't democratise power in the soviet States, revolutionary China or Africa.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:30AM (#19294867)
I think you are missing the point, the argument is AI ethical isn’t the same as can AI be ethical.

AI is a tool, and while you can say some tools are easier to abuse than others it has not baring on their ethics since tools have no ethics to begin with.

And the leverage or force multiplication you get from a tool is directly tied to how easily it can be abused but also to how useful it is to you in general.

Is a gun less ethical than a siringe because it can be used for violence? How about siginges fuling the drug epidemic?

Are nukes less ethical than conventional weapons?

Were the looms that the luddites seek the destroy unethical because they put people out of work?

Should we consider combines and modern agriculture unethical because they drastically changed the balance of power of various nations?

Ofc not as all of these arguments are silly and flawed once you actually begin to deconstruct them.

This has nothing to do about gun control I have no problem controlling guns because I don’t want to get shot and if someone does break into my house I prefer them not to be armed.

I also prefer the police not to be armed at all times because I think that it’s just as important not to bring a gun to a knife fight as it is the other way around if you don’t want to escalate things.

I have no problem of regulating the application of AI when necessary.

However it does not mean that I think that it has anything to do with its ethics but with ours.

Some uses of AI could be deemed by society to be unethical for the same reason that society deemed that harvesting the organs of a random person to save 5 people is unethical because people wouldn’t be able to function knowing that they might be harvested at any moment.

So if we bring this back to AI it’s not that I would think that say an AI run mass surveillance system is unethical because I’m not sure if the AI can make ethical decisions I would consider it unethical if society wouldn’t be able to function well under it.

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by lukifer on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:54AM (#19295022)
Though I agree in principle, I think tools can’t be considered in isolation, but rather in the context of iterated game theory.

Is Instagram inherently evil? Obviously not; but through the lens of pre-existing human social dynamics, including status competition, mating drives, social signaling, etc, the capabilities introduced by that particular tool almost inevitably lead to the perverse incentives of lifestyle facades, “influencers”, Fyre Festival, etc. Do we have to do these things? Of course not. But it’s naive to not think about the “realpolitik” scenarios, and what could be done to mitigate them, rather than assuming perfectly ethical and rational actors.

What makes AI even more complicated than previous technological changes to our game landscape, is the potential not for new tools, but for new players: at best, these artificial players are proxies for each of our interests (though see the side effects of “flash crashes” from high-frequency trading bots); at worst, we may have to contend with vastly intelligent new players with emergent interests of their own, which we can’t necessarily predict. While I don’t think it’s inconceivable that A.I. will always be subject to human understanding and control, we’re in such new territory that that’s fundamentally an assumption (see the arguments from Bostrom, etc).

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:30PM (#19295937)
AI isn’t s player it’s as dumb as a rock. The players are still humans that build, maintain, operate and can switch it off.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by adjkant on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:51PM (#19296058)
AI today is that dumb, but I think the parent comment is discussing a theoretical AGI nearing or possessing consciousness. A bit irrelevant for today's moral conversation on AI but a very interesting one down the line if we ever do get to that point.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:23PM (#19296600)
Let’s have this talk in 3 centuries then.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by coldtea on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:13PM (#19296544)
>AI isn’t s player it’s as dumb as a rock.

That's a religious view of AI and humans, where humans have special qualities (like soul and consciousness) perhaps evolved "magically" or "god given", that a machine can't have.

There are no serious arguments why an AI can't have perfect human-like consciousness, feelings and everything.

Inversely, there are no serious arguments why humans are special in any way, and their brain mappings can't be replicated by technical AI (eg. artificial neurons) or emulated by software.

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:23PM (#19296598)
Humans aren’t special but what we have as an AI today and for foreseeable future is capable making as many decisions as your microwave.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by coldtea on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:48PM (#19296753)
We already have AI that can make the decision or not to step on a kid passing the street in self driving cars.

The ethical/conscious part is a matter of degree, not necessarily of quality.

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:52PM (#19296783)
No we don’t, the “AI” didn’t made any decisions it only follows its programming.

It also doesn’t know what a kid is nor does it makes any decisions based on the info even if it did. It is tasked with avoiding collisions it does not make ethical decisions any more than my microwave makes an ethical decision of not to burn my food when I use a fixed program to defrost chicken.

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by adjkant on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:43AM (#19294959)
> Is a gun less ethical than a syringe because it can be used for violence?

A gun's purpose is to shoot bullets. A syringe has the purpose of delivering fluid into the human body. It's not hard to evaluate the ethics of the most common actions for each of those. While the tool itself technically has no ethics, owning or using the tool tends to have ethical implications. In a practical world, it is very fair to evaluate those implications, at least at an estimation level.

Don't get me wrong, there's a ton of complexity when it comes to tools and ethics and no easy answers, and with the luddite example it brings in questions of work ethics and societal structure, so the loom doesn't exist in a vacuum. But not all tools bring in the entirety of ethics into consideration. There are ethical estimations of tools (think of them as potential ethical energy) that we can try to estimate. Syringe > Gun seems like one we can make. Gun vs Nuke, a bit harder due to the consideration of use vs threat of use. The loom alone is pretty neutral and is far more reflective of direct context, where the context of a gun or syringe generalizes easier. And of course these are all my calculations, and you and others can have different ones, but I think if we really decided to spend 8 hours nailing down this discussion, you would indeed see a loose tiering/ranking of tools and "potential ethical energy". I wouldn't be surprised to see other measures/categories emerge either such as severity, risk, and commonality of use case.

The question becomes this: what is the "potential ethical energy" of AI. IMO it's very close to the loom in that the context matters the most, but there's also a severity of effect factor in play that makes it more dangerous. Still, I would say AI has an overall positive potential ethical energy.

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:29PM (#19295932)
There is no such thing as an ethical potential energy it’s not even a useful thought experiment.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by adjkant on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:47PM (#19296033)
> There is no such thing as an ethical potential energy

Yes there is, I just made it up on the spot and defined it! If you mean that it is not a commonly discussed philosophical term then yes, you'd be correct.

> It’s not even a useful thought experiment

Now that's a discussion to bad had that you gave no evidence for its lack of use, while I used it to describe tools that humans use and how an "ethical potential energy" calculation can correlate to the practical effects of a tool, and perhaps how we should view/regulate/restrict said items in the context of humans. You could easily derive firearm laws from such a base if you chose to do so, for example. If that derivation is valid then depends on if the concept has the proper grounding in relation to ethics, which is again a discussion to be had.

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by pjc50 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:43AM (#19294963)
This approach presumes that the ethical responsibility falls on the user of the tool, including the responsibility to see what the effects of use are. Where this starts to break down is autonomous systems - when the system itself makes decisions that could be considered to be ethical, or have significant social effects. Autonomous weapons are the usual example, from landmines to drones, but this also applies to systems making economic decisions.

A gun is not something that can be held ethically responsible itself because it does not make decisions. An autonomous gun turret would be.

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:29PM (#19295929)
Because they do as these systems are designed and put into operation by humans and come with an off switch.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by wallace_f on Sunday March 03, 2019 @11:44AM (#19295308)
How do you not see the contradiction in writing about how no tools are inherently unethical, then say that one tool is inherently unethical because you are scared of it in particular?
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:28PM (#19295927)
I’m not scared of any of it, I don’t think that neither guns nor AI are unethical, nor ethical I don’t anthropomorphize objects.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by coldtea on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:55PM (#19296807)
OK, so you wouldn't be scared if we gave guns to everybody in your city except you.

There are mere guns, they are not problematic in themselves, it's how people use them.

No reason to think giving everybody in your city a gun would be any different in its outcome to you (and the city's wellbeing) than giving everybody a banana...

/s

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by wallace_f on Sunday March 03, 2019 @02:25PM (#19296271)
Sugar, pollution and cars are much more likely to kill you.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by coldtea on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:11PM (#19296527)
>AI is a tool, and while you can say some tools are easier to abuse than others it has not baring on their ethics since tools have no ethics to begin with.

For one, that argument only holds for tools without conscience (e.g. a hammer or a headphone). AI, though, is precisely the kind of tool that can be capable to have ethics.

Second, even dumb tools without ethics of their own, can be ethically problematic (e.g. a bomb).

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:48PM (#19296751)
Tools cannot have ethics since tools do not define ethics, society does and ethics aren’t universal or static.

We are barely capable of defining and arguing ethics as a society claiming that a microwave would be able to make ethical decisions is laughable.

P.S. A bomb is no more ethically problematic than a bottle coke.

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by coldtea on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:53PM (#19296794)
>Tools cannot have ethics since tools do not define ethics, society does and ethics aren’t universal or static.

Which is still beside the point.

As I already wrote, an advanced AI is a tool that can precisely define ethics for itself or adopt ones.

Plus, as I also already wrote, even if a tool has no ethics, it can be ethically problematic (to society), so that is something we should discuss too.

>We are barely capable of defining and arguing ethics as a society claiming that a microwave would be able to make ethical decisions is laughable.

Which is again irrelevant, as an AI is not a microwave -- and future AI even less so. We are capable of seeing/discussing even things that are not immediately in front of us...

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by _rpd on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:35PM (#19295626)
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by klyrs on Sunday March 03, 2019 @11:20AM (#19295179)
Does a hammer make decisions?
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by mLuby on Sunday March 03, 2019 @11:51AM (#19295367)
Does an AI (as we have them now)? If I give someone a paper and say "wait a day then follow these instructions", I'm making the decisions, not them, even if the paper has branching logic like "if it's morning, call Alice but if it's afternoon call Bob."
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by nkozyra on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:04PM (#19295444)
Isn't that the point? Ethics is in the execution, if I make "ethical" instructions and someone follows them, they're operating by the constraints of said ethics.

The point is that agents that operate ethically need not be sentient, they just need to play faithfully in our rule sets.

Which will sometimes mean eschewing maxima when doing so violates them. It will sometimes mean losses or ties in zero sum games.

Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:31PM (#19295944)
Does a bomb makes a decision to explode? What we define and can construct as an AI is no more capable of making a decision than your microwave.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by nkozyra on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:00PM (#19295420)
If the hammer is trained to operate autonomously, yes.
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by dogma1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:34PM (#19295955)
My dishwasher is autonomous should I it be concerned about it’s ethics?
Re:Is Ethical A.I. Even Possible? by nkozyra on Sunday March 03, 2019 @06:42PM (#19297682)
Your dishwasher makes no autonomous decisions. AI takes training data and uses algorithms to make choices. Aware of the protocols of ethics, it can reject those choices. Without ethics, it will aim for global maxima and victory in zero sum games.

So ... no.