News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by towaway1138 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:49AM (#19292968)
When headhunters contact me about SF (or even Bay Area) jobs, I just scoff and shut them down. If you're fresh out of school, no family, and willing to live in a hovel for some interesting life experience, sure. But if you're an adult, it's no way to live. And putting kids through it is frankly unethical.
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by stale2002 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:57AM (#19292986)
Well it depends.

I'll agree with you that if you work at a rando tech startup, the costs of living are going to be quite high, and make it probably not worth it.

But, the whole equation changes if you are working for a big 5 tech company, or hot unicorn company.

These companies will pay you double what the rando startups pay. Who really cares if you are paying 40k a year on rent, if your total compensation breaks 250K.

And getting 250k+ as an engineer, with a couple years experience, is only really possible in the Bay area.

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by mrep on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:45AM (#19293120)
> And getting 250k+ as an engineer, with a couple years experience, is only really possible in the Bay area.

Seattle and NYC can also easily reach that.

Source: I'm in Seattle making 210k 3 years out of college.

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by moftz on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:23AM (#19293062)
But the cost of living is so high there that the inflated salaries are pretty much required to bring anyone out there. A company wants to have competitive hiring so they offer a little bit more than competition so what was a $200k job is now $220k. Prices increase to what these inflated salaried workers can afford and the cycle continues. It will be incredible to watch when SF finally starts to allow for more high density housing. Housing prices will fall and the salary bubble will pop. A lot of companies will start cutting back on starting salaries and as a result, experienced workers will start either taking paycuts to switch jobs or be first in line for layoffs because they cost the company too much.
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by nostrademons on Sunday March 03, 2019 @02:32AM (#19293260)
This gets causality backwards. Employers don't give a shit about whether employees can afford housing - if they did, we wouldn't have such a big homelessness problem, and our teachers/firefighters/policemen wouldn't live over the mountains in Pleasanton. Employers pay enough to prevent employees from going to a competitor. The reason FANG salaries now hit $300-400K is because Facebook refused to play ball with the wage-fixing cartel that Schmidt/Jobs/et al had worked out, then the DoJ cracked down, and so now that's what you need to pay to keep your software engineers from working for someone else. Then you have a lot of tech workers with extremely fat salaries and not enough housing for everyone who wants to live here, so they bid up rents & housing prices until they're unaffordable for all the middle-income folks who used to live here.

If more high-density housing was built, then rents would fall, middle-income people could live here again, and tech workers could pocket their fat salaries as savings (or live extremely lavish lifestyles). They would still be paid a lot, because there'd always be another tech company around the corner willing to bid up wages to their current level. For the salary "bubble" to pop, a lot of these companies would have to go out of business at once. This was exactly what happened in 2001 and 2009, and it had the predicted results: unemployment spiked, wages fell, rents fell, and people moved out of the Bay Area back to wherever they came from.

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by ascar on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:02AM (#19293330)
If that would actually be the case you would have these salaries all around the world, but you don't. Because it's mainly a few big highly profitable companies (FAANG) that can afford these salaries and a big VC and stock market funded bubble around them. And even FAANG pays much lower salaries in cheaper regions, because hightech employers have to give a shit about housing. You can't compare it to teachers.

I think it's a dangerous attitude to think the salaries in CA are the actual worth of a software developer's work. It's just what FAANG can afford to pay. For many companies devs at that price point are not economically sustainable.

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by nostrademons on Sunday March 03, 2019 @11:25AM (#19295202)
It absolutely is what FAANG (and newer companies like AirBnB/Uber/Lyft/Stripe/DropBox etc) can afford to pay. And what FAANG can afford to pay is not going to change if more housing gets built in the Bay Area. And yes, for many companies devs at that price point are not economically sustainable, but that's why FAANG are sucking all the oxygen out of the startup developers market and maintaining their oligopsony.

(Also, while there's some variance for cost-of-living in FAANG salaries in different regions, it's not that much. Google developers make less in Beijing than they do in Mountain View, but their salary still looks much more like a Google salary than a Beijing salary.)

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by modwilliam on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:10AM (#19293023)
Why "just scoff"? There's a salary that would allow you to live comfortably and get more net income in the Bay Area - you'd want to see if the jobs can pay that salary
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by Cyclone_ on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:34AM (#19293089)
Looking at salary data from several places, even a $200k base seems pretty rare, most developers are not making that much in the bay area. People in the bay area are going to have less purchasing power than developers in most other places around the country.
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by nostrademons on Sunday March 03, 2019 @02:17AM (#19293214)
$3690/month * 12 months = $44280. If you're making ($44280 - current rent in your city) more for a SF job, you net out ahead, even without considering stock options.

(It's also significantly more reasonable in the South Bay - my family pays about $2650/month for a 2BR, and most of the fat Facebook/Apple/Netflix/Google salaries are in Silicon Valley proper.)

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday March 03, 2019 @02:35AM (#19293270)
That's if you only consider the housing cost. But if housing costs more then so does everything else, because everyone providing everything else has to pay the housing cost too, both for commercial real estate and higher costs per employee. Then you have the tax implications, i.e. all the extra money required should be calculated as after-tax at your marginal tax rate, both federal and state, and California has the highest income tax rate in the nation.
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by nostrademons on Sunday March 03, 2019 @02:49AM (#19293300)
"But if housing costs more then so does everything else"

That's not really true. Restaurants are more expensive in the Bay Area. Fresh produce is not, if you know where to shop - actually, when I go basically anywhere else in the world, one of the things I miss is the ability to fill a whole shopping bag with 10-15 lbs. of vegetables for < $10. Gas is more expensive, largely because of taxes. Cars are not. Durable goods cost the same as everywhere else. Amazon charges the same (modulo taxes) regardless of where you live. Airline tickets don't have appreciable differences. Baby things (modulo housing and childcare) are cheaper, because the Bay Area is dense enough and tech savvy enough that you can get a lot of toys/cribs/strollers/mats/gates/playthings for free or cheap on NextDoor/Craigslist. A dollar of savings is the same in SF as in Alabama.

The point about tax rates is true for rentals. You can do the math yourself on whatever offer you happen to get - figure on housing in SF being ~$40K/year, meals out costing about $20/person, grocery food being about the same, public transportation being a few dollars a trip, and gas being negligible because you'd have to be pretty crazy to want to drive (and park) in SF.

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by closeparen on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:26PM (#19296617)
A dollar of savings is not the same, because your savings needs are proportional to housing costs. Whether it is to make a down payment, pay rent while laid off, or maintain your lifestyle in retirement, you need a much larger savings balance to buy the same capability. Even if it’s a kid’s college fund, as an upper middle income worker in a flyover state you will probably qualify for financial aid; even with the same take home budget, in a high wage high cost scenario you will not.
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by nostrademons on Sunday March 03, 2019 @07:30PM (#19297906)
There's nothing stopping you from moving to a lower cost-of-living area when you need to dip into savings. If you save up a million dollars in the Bay Area, you always have the option of moving to Chicago and buying 4 houses, if you're willing to put up with the cold. The reverse does not necessarily hold: if you save up $100K in Chicago and then need to come up with a down payment for a home in the Bay Area, you're screwed.

For that matter, the higher home prices also come back to you if you choose to move elsewhere (as long as Bay Area real estate doesn't crash). A number of the homes I've been looking at are on the market because the kids are grown, the owners are retired, and now they want to take their $1.3-$2.4M and move to Nevada/Florida/Arizona or some other low-COL area.

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by closeparen on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:23PM (#19298541)
Besides the life you and your family have built.

If saving $30k in Chicago lets you sustain your lifestyle for 12 months of unemployment, and saving $30k in San Francisco gives you the option to leave everyone you know and move 2200 miles to Chicago for 12 months of unemployment, those dollars of savings are not at all the same in terms of the protection they offer.

Living in the Bay Area can be a good deal, but to figure out whether that's the case, you need to set savings targets in terms of equivalent capabilities. Different people can place higher and lower value on location stability, but in any case the value is not $0; moving trucks and realtors are not free.

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by ericd on Sunday March 03, 2019 @02:35AM (#19293269)
I'd definitely keep in mind that those are after-tax figures, though. At the higher income levels, CA+Federal taxes hover around 50%. So, roughly double that rent difference to get the salary offset needed.
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by wankerrific on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:37AM (#19293428)
Really? At what income level in California are you paying half your income in taxes?
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by closeparen on Sunday March 03, 2019 @04:54AM (#19293674)
When comparing alternatives you want to look at marginal rate. Above $82k, your marginal tax rate is: 24% federal income + 6.3% social security + 1.45% medicare + 9.3% California + 1.5% San Francisco for a total of 43%. This is not the same thing as paying half your income in taxes, but it is paying (nearly) half the additional income in taxes.
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by lotsofpulp on Sunday March 03, 2019 @05:53AM (#19293840)
6.2% social security drops off after $132,900.

https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc751

50% is a high estimate, good for budgeting though. With property taxes, vehicle registration fees (aka taxes), school fundraising (aka taxes), tolls (also tax), health insurance (a tax if it’s mandatory), and other fees for dealing with government, you get pretty close to 50%.

The only way to beat this is to make a significant portion of your income via capital gains, that’s one big advantage of the real estate business, various loopholes exist to let you minimize taxes (like 1031 exchanges) on increases in your net worth.

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by dmode on Sunday March 03, 2019 @06:39AM (#19293990)
What’s the 1.5% SF tax here ? Never heard of it. Isn’t SSN and Medicare only apply to 100k of income ? Also, you have deductions for mortgage, state taxes, property taxes that lower your tax liability quite a bit. I would be surprised if anyone paid more than 30% effective tax rate on their income
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by ericd on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:58PM (#19295741)
Sorry, I meant marginal tax rate, since we’re looking at the diff. At the $300k level, that’s around 35% Federal, and 11.3% CA. CA also has a relatively high 9% sales tax, and I believe SF proper has some special taxes as well.
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by jjjensen90 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @04:22AM (#19293565)
From what I've seen I think it's around 38-40% state+federal when you reach about $200-300k then about 50% by $1m annual income... Might be better or worse this year with the new tax bill, not sure.
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by speedplane on Sunday March 03, 2019 @05:59AM (#19293856)
> Might be better or worse this year with the new tax bill, not sure.

Much better for those who can arguably restructure their salary as business income (e.g., real estate developers, some contractors), then they only get a 15% tax. Far worse for those who cant make that argument and live in high tax states like NY, CA, and many others.

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by towaway1138 on Thursday March 07, 2019 @05:29PM (#19333224)
Because I've done my research. I generally quote salary requirements in terms of living in a modest house in a pretty good school district, on a single salary (since my wife wants to stay at home and raise the kids).

Not surprisingly, this makes recruiter jaws drop. We're not even on the same page.

In most parts of the country, though, those requirements work just fine.

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by modwilliam on Thursday March 07, 2019 @05:44PM (#19333365)
Do you mind saying what your requirement is or the general range?
Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by towaway1138 on Friday March 08, 2019 @01:34AM (#19335589)
My most serious foray was around 2012, and back then such a house seemed to go for $800K. Given the mortgage ratios, that corresponds to a PI payment of around $3800/mo. Kind of hard to match this to current offerings, but it looks like maybe $1.3M now, so theoretically $6200/mo. So maybe $100-120K/y in mortgage payments? Not sure.

Can't recall the specifics, but my offer from a FAANG back then was a bit over $200K gross. But a lot of that isn't really liquid cash that you could use to pay the mortgage. It doesn't really fly.

These days, for the scenario above, even $300K/y cash seems marginal. And AFAIK, no one in the BA would seriously consider offering me that.

Lest someone complain that I seem entitled, let me say that I in no way consider that I somehow deserve such an offer. But at the same time, no BA employer deserves someone like me when I can get equivalent comp elsewhere.

IMO, the way BA comp works is you engage in raids for five to ten years when you're in your late 20s or early 30s. Live in squalor, three or five roommates, and bank it all. Do not marry. Then take your winnings back to the real world and retire, or at least, live an easy life.

But if you want a traditional life, thar be dragons...

Re:San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a ne... by modwilliam on Friday March 08, 2019 @01:05PM (#19340218)
Fair enough. Looks well thought out!