Re:Debunking piracy justifications
by Fargren on Sunday November 21, 2010 @03:53PM
(#1927849)
Theft is the substraction of goods. What you describe may be criminal behaviour, but it's not theft, the same way it's not breaking and entering.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Debunking piracy justifications
by fauigerzigerk on Sunday November 21, 2010 @04:12PM
(#1927885)
But in this case something is clearly subtracted, unlike in the case of piracy. Yet I'm not sure if industrial espionage is usually treated as theft.
The secret is subtracted, but is not taken by someone else, unlike with theft. Instead it is destroyed. If you want to equate it to a physical crime, vandalism or criminal damage would seem to be a better fit.
Re:Debunking piracy justifications
by fauigerzigerk on Sunday November 21, 2010 @04:56PM
(#1927992)
Yes, if the information is simply published vandalism or sabotage would be a fitting category. But if it is sold to a third party it is more similar to theft. In any event, it's probably much more useful to have a separate legal concept for "piracy" that does justice to the specifics of digital goods and the way they are used.