News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To end poverty, guarantee everyone in Canada $20,000 a year. by LostInTheWoods2 on Saturday November 20, 2010 @09:24PM (#1926008)
This is the dumbest and most dangerous idea I've heard in a while. Go ahead and vote me down, but I hope some on this site have the common sense to see how bad this idea is. This is essentially welfare, and in the US, we've been down that road and we know exactly where it leads.
Re:To end poverty, guarantee everyone in Canada $20,000 a year. by orangecat on Saturday November 20, 2010 @10:00PM (#1926112)
This is essentially welfare

Yes, and? The point is that we're already providing welfare, just often in a convoluted, inefficient, and counterproductive manner. The unfortunate fact is that some people can't provide for themselves. We can either ignore them, establish fifty government agencies to "help" them, or give them money. Option 1 isn't on the table, and 3 makes a lot more sense than 2.

Re:To end poverty, guarantee everyone in Canada $20,000 a year. by gorbachev on Sunday November 21, 2010 @09:59AM (#1927137)
You're not seeing the forest from the trees.

I often wonder about the true motivation of some conservatives opposing any programs such as the one described in this article. If your agenda is to cut Government spending, shouldn't you think about ways to do that? It's well understood that preventive programs (such as the one described in the article) cost less than programs that deal with the consequences, e.g. prisons, hospitals to name two. So if your agenda is to cut Government spending, shouldn't you advocate for programs such as this?

So when on the other hand these people speak about cutting spending, and then cutting every preventive program in the books, they're not only failing to achieve what they advocate for (in the long run), but also causing real harm for people affected by these program cuts.

So to answer the comment I'm responding to. The goal of programs like this is not to "be nice", but to actually reduce to overall spending. I don't understand why it's dumb or dangerous at all.

Re:To end poverty, guarantee everyone in Canada $20,000 a year. by pessimizer on Sunday November 21, 2010 @02:12AM (#1926582)
It'd be nice if you could fit an argument or non-vacuous statement between your insults, defiance, and vague innuendo.

Things to try:

1) This idea is dumb because... 2) This idea is dangerous because... 3) Welfare leads to...

Re:To end poverty, guarantee everyone in Canada $20,000 a year. by smhinsey on Saturday November 20, 2010 @10:11PM (#1926145)
Where does it lead? It seems to me that the only thing we can say for certain is that it leads to a lot of partisan hand wringing and rancor. That's a problem with our dysfunctional American system, not a universal constant.
Re:To end poverty, guarantee everyone in Canada $20,000 a year. by InclinedPlane on Saturday November 20, 2010 @09:37PM (#1926038)
I won't downvote you, could you explain why you think this is worse than the existing system?
Re:To end poverty, guarantee everyone in Canada $20,000 a year. by davidj on Monday November 22, 2010 @01:00PM (#1930673)
search for my comment and I explain why it is wrong. Thanks for asking:)
Re:To end poverty, guarantee everyone in Canada $20,000 a year. by maxharris on Saturday November 20, 2010 @09:37PM (#1926040)
> common sense

That's precisely the trouble here. Following today's common sense, this seems like a great idea. To argue against it in a meaningful way, you have to attack the ethical root beneath it: altruism. To this end, I recommend reading The Virtue of Selfishness (google for it, if you haven't heard of it already.)