In other words, to add a cost (the possibility of being dismissed/sneered back) to such dismissals.
I find facile dismissals irritating as well, and lord knows this site gets a lot of them. But the way to push back is with a clear, positive defense of whatever was unfairly dismissed. Venting doesn't help; it only invites more venting.
> to add a cost (the possibility of being dismissed/sneered back) to such dismissals.
Given the fact that this is a conversation among strangers, I would assert that it isn't really that effective to just add costs by making discourse less pleasant.
--
In general, I think a community is healthier when we treat people 25% better than you expect to be treated, to account for the Fundamental Attribution Error and other misinterpretations.
I guess so. Sometimes I'm just pissed from the easy dismissal, as in "This 5 second basic retort is all you've came up with, and you think you've taken down TFA?".