Re:U.S. Is a Rich Country with Symptoms of a Developing Nation
by mikeq101101 on Saturday February 23, 2019 @12:51PM
(#19234494)
You are forced to pay taxes under the threat of violence.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:U.S. Is a Rich Country with Symptoms of a Developing Nation
by dmode on Saturday February 23, 2019 @01:21PM
(#19234661)
I don’t understand this argument. We comply to every law “under the threat of violence”. Are you advocating for a lawless society ?
Re:U.S. Is a Rich Country with Symptoms of a Developing Nation
by whatislovecraft on Saturday February 23, 2019 @12:54PM
(#19234514)
Wait, in what country? Not in the USA! You ain't forced to pay shit here if you don't want. Don't want to pay taxes? Go work minimum wage job then, don't pay taxes okay? Or be megarich and still don't pay taxes. Nobody's forcing you by threat of violence to make a ton of money in your salary and pay taxes on it.
The laws are clear, and you agree to them by living here. A taxation-related arrest will be done non-violently anyway, what on Earth are you talking about here?
Where is this threat of violence coming from?
Re:U.S. Is a Rich Country with Symptoms of a Developing Nation
by krapp on Saturday February 23, 2019 @01:29PM
(#19234729)
What's being referred to here is the premise of the monopoly on violence[0]. Essentially that a state can be defined as an entity which claims for itself a monopoly on the legitimate use of force, often violent force, denying the same right to the public. That legitimacy, in free societies is granted by the people, while in nonfree societies, it's often simply taken though further violence. The enforcement of laws and collecting of taxes are backed up by the threat of the state executing on its monopoly on violence against its citizens.
The opposite of the monopoly on violence would be anarchy, which could be interpreted as a free market of violence.
Re:U.S. Is a Rich Country with Symptoms of a Developing Nation
by whatislovecraft on Saturday February 23, 2019 @05:34PM
(#19235874)
100 years ago, maybe, as cited in your wiki link, that could have some interesting discussion behind it. But that model of the world quite clearly does not fit today, and viewing modern society like that is exactly the kind of attitude that results in our infrastructure - and morals - crumbling.
I can't find anything in that article that has any relevance to today.
Re:U.S. Is a Rich Country with Symptoms of a Developing Nation
by krapp on Sunday February 24, 2019 @06:51AM
(#19238224)
The monopoly on violence is the way all civil societies work, even in the present day. It's why the police are legally allowed to beat someone, kidnap them against their will and throw them in a cage, and you aren't. It's why the social contract isn't a literal contract you needed to sign first before being subject to your government's authority.
Re:U.S. Is a Rich Country with Symptoms of a Developing Nation
by fucking_tragedy on Saturday February 23, 2019 @12:56PM
(#19234528)
Tax liens and wage garnishments are violence, apparently.