Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by hevi_jos on Saturday February 23, 2019 @10:34AM
(#19233730)
The problem with killing more efficiently is that after a point you don't know if you are improving your situation or worsening it.
There is this tv series in Amazon about Einstein life and you could see him opposing using his knowledge to improve weapons, while Haber(creator of Bosh Haber process) did not.
Haber was probably murdered while traveling by secret services in the same way the US killed engineers of Iran nuclear program openly. His wife and son committed suicide because of his work.
As a technical person with decades of experience in science you can do enormous harm if you really want. All you really need is a powerful reason for that.
If you see other countries developing so strong weapons they could invade your country with no cost for them, this is a powerful reason for you to collaborate.
The US has focused so much in developing force that is seen more and more in the world as the bully while countries like China build bridges, ports or roads.
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by PopeDotNinja on Saturday February 23, 2019 @02:46PM
(#19235118)
At Rubyconf a few years ago, I saw a talk about writing software for controlling drones. As I remember it, the speaker configured the drone to "lock on" to his face & follow his movements. It was more unsettling than I expected.
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by Fej on Saturday February 23, 2019 @10:30PM
(#19236947)
Whether you agree with this sentiment or not, people waking up to ethical questions in our field is unquestionably a good thing. It's important to ask these questions.
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by mindcrash on Saturday February 23, 2019 @02:47PM
(#19235119)
Countries all around the world, including the United States armed forces, are using Microsoft software in things "designed to help people kill" for years but now the US Army under Trump has a contract with Microsoft it now becomes a problem?
We have a word for that in the dictionary, it is called hypocrisy.
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by bunnycorn on Saturday February 23, 2019 @03:18PM
(#19235252)
They are not slaves, they aren't bound to Microsoft and Microsoft is not bound to them. Step asside. I don't have any doubt that Microsoft won't have any problem in filling their positions with better professionals. Heck, if I were younger and didn't had yet a family, I would apply for a job at Microsoft and would be ok with moving to the United States, and helping the civilized world get rid of the barbarians would be an honor.
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by bunnycorn on Saturday February 23, 2019 @04:39PM
(#19235628)
Nice evasion tactic.
Also, indirection changes everything.
When a soldier fires a bullet, it's commanded by a chain of command that goes directly, in the case of the US, a leader elected by the people of the US.
It's not a question of "firing with a rifle vs using your bare hands".
Is "firing because you decided to kill that guy" vs "killing because the people of your nation decided that guy constitutes a threat".
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by tuesdayrain on Saturday February 23, 2019 @01:05PM
(#19234578)
I can't decide if it's more or less ethical to turn down these type of jobs. Even if you are anti-war, by declining such a job you open up space for the next person in line who may not be as talented of a programmer. The weapons will exist either way, but now they'll have an increased chance of having severe bugs because all the best programmers chose less morally ambiguous jobs. Maybe working for a military contractor is how you prevent the world from accidentally being destroyed. Or that's how you help it intentionally get destroyed, I don't know.
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by SmirkingRevenge on Saturday February 23, 2019 @03:08PM
(#19235209)
I almost wonder if these movements are driven in part, or at least encouraged by, foreign state actors within these companies, who have interests in hampering US military dominance.
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by educationdata on Saturday February 23, 2019 @05:18PM
(#19235804)
Not sure about this one, but in the Vietnam era, many anti-war activists were Soviet spies, or influenced by Soviet spies, or communists who have no direct connection to the Soviets but want to see communism takes over the world.
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by AtHeartEngineer on Saturday February 23, 2019 @01:25PM
(#19234707)
Would you rather be in the room with decision makers, trying to make sure it doesn't go over the line, or go in the wrong direction? Or just don't participate, not know what's going on, and have less competent "yes-man" in your seat. This is my daily struggle, it keeps me up.
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by wurst_case on Saturday February 23, 2019 @02:19PM
(#19235004)
Usually when I'm confronted with such conundrums it's a signal to me that I'm thinking about the problem too narrowly. Surely being at the table, unless you are the one making decisions, is lending yourself to someone else's cause. If you weren't a yes man one way or another you'd probably be thrown off the team anyway and replaced by another yes man. Maybe you get to sway them towards competency but you aren't changing their end goal.
There are other ways of changing the world than working with those who perpetuate violence.
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by SmirkingRevenge on Saturday February 23, 2019 @03:15PM
(#19235239)
I think the better question to ask is.. who stands to gain from slowing down the pace of innovation in the US military? Basically.. competing nation states. In a world full of liberty loving friendly democracies I might think more parity in military capability is desirable. In the world we have.. we basically have to be able to win a war against major the hostile major military powers.. at the same time (Russia, China, etc).
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by vkou on Saturday February 23, 2019 @06:11PM
(#19236015)
The decision makers won't put you in the room with them. They will take the weapons you built, pay you for them, and use them on whomever, and whenever they see fit.
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by yesenadam on Saturday February 23, 2019 @09:01PM
(#19236685)
Or maybe they'll be more talented?! But that seems beside the point.
"If I don't do this evil thing, someone else will, so I may as well" isn't a good argument. There is an enormous difference - it won't be you doing bad things. It sounds like you know it's wrong, but are coming up with a lot of justifications for not seeing it.
It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!
Re:Microsoft Workers Protest Army Contract with Tech 'Design...
by baddox on Saturday February 23, 2019 @04:31PM
(#19235591)
I don’t know. I remember reading a thought experiment years ago which I believe was presented by and to libertarians. If you were a German who found yourself conscripted into the Nazi military during World War 2 and assigned to an extermination camp, should you aspire to kill as few people as possible without getting fired? The supposed reasoning being that you are “saving” lives, since if you were fired and replaced, your replacement would likely kill even more people.
I suppose it’s supposed to be a challenge to consequentialism or the claim that the ends justify the means. Personally I think it’s a bit silly, and you just shouldn’t murder people.
There is this tv series in Amazon about Einstein life and you could see him opposing using his knowledge to improve weapons, while Haber(creator of Bosh Haber process) did not.
Haber was probably murdered while traveling by secret services in the same way the US killed engineers of Iran nuclear program openly. His wife and son committed suicide because of his work.
As a technical person with decades of experience in science you can do enormous harm if you really want. All you really need is a powerful reason for that.
If you see other countries developing so strong weapons they could invade your country with no cost for them, this is a powerful reason for you to collaborate.
The US has focused so much in developing force that is seen more and more in the world as the bully while countries like China build bridges, ports or roads.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mhXyNGX38mw
Here's the drone video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zp7czxk52bI
We have a word for that in the dictionary, it is called hypocrisy.
Ethical concerns raised by developers are an increasingly common occurance that have nothing to do with the current presidential administration.
It's not always this way. We should be glad we're here now.
Also, indirection changes everything.
When a soldier fires a bullet, it's commanded by a chain of command that goes directly, in the case of the US, a leader elected by the people of the US.
It's not a question of "firing with a rifle vs using your bare hands".
Is "firing because you decided to kill that guy" vs "killing because the people of your nation decided that guy constitutes a threat".
Sounds like you basically want to help out with a genocide.
Sadam Hussein's genocide of the Kurds?
You should perhaps consider another method of debate.
There are other ways of changing the world than working with those who perpetuate violence.
"If I don't do this evil thing, someone else will, so I may as well" isn't a good argument. There is an enormous difference - it won't be you doing bad things. It sounds like you know it's wrong, but are coming up with a lot of justifications for not seeing it.
It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!
I suppose it’s supposed to be a challenge to consequentialism or the claim that the ends justify the means. Personally I think it’s a bit silly, and you just shouldn’t murder people.