Re:Roma's Wounding Confession
by dguaraglia on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:04PM
(#19230836)
I'm sure there's a great movie to be made about Cleo's life, from her perspective and showing us more of the underbelly of Mexican society at the time. My - admittedly half-assed argument - is that Cuarón might have not had that movie in mind, and analyzing the film as "Cuarón screwed up by not making the film I wanted to see" misses that point.
I wish I had seen way more about the ship that comes and picks up the baby and her mother at the end of Children of Men... but the movie wasn't about them.
Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts. In retrospect I didn’t think much of Children of Men or Gravity either, and I can’t even remember what I thought of Y Tu Mamá También, so it apparently didn’t leave much impression on me. Maybe he’s just not my cup of tea.
My upset with Roma was given how critically acclaimed it is, I was expecting a lot more. I appreciate your perspective but I still don’t think the film is worthy of the praise it’s been given. I went and read a ton of reviews after to try to understand what I might be missing and I just ended up getting more and more annoyed. Oh well.
Let me guess! You probably think the great gatsby is a classic.
The book is by definition a classic. The movie is not my favorite of Baz Luhrmann's. What's this got to do with Roma?
Speaking of Great Gatsby, I did enjoy Burning.
The Princess Bride... now that’s a classic.
Re:Roma's Wounding Confession
by armandososa on Saturday February 23, 2019 @09:55AM
(#19233538)
> but dramatically, a miss.
Well, I cried like a baby at the scene at the beach.
That's just rationalizing away the fact that the film's subject was poorly handled by the film's director. Someone else - and I'm not suggesting that has to be someone whose experiences more closely map to Cleo's - could have told this story better, or at least in a way that would have felt less out of touch.
The film was pretty beautiful but dramatically, a miss.