News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:20PM (#19230107)
Humans are a part of nature. Everything we do and all our technology is based on the laws of nature. Therefore by definition, everything we do is natural. Animals in general try to create an environment that is suitable for them - whether it be be birds building a nest, or beavers building a dam. Humans are just really, really good at modifying their environment, but we are still a part of nature.
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by pygy_ on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:07PM (#19230854)
This is the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis at work.

The way common language defines "nature" doesn't map well to reality and we end up developing contorted thoughts rather than re-evaluating the tools we use to think.

I like to contrast wild/raw stuff to artificial stuff, both of which are part of nature. Many things that are commonly considered "natural" are actually far from wild. Fields in the countryside? Artificial. Vegetables and farm animals? Artificial, even before GMO. Etc...

That being said, the way we've shaped the planet these last 200 years is radical, and possibly too radical for our own survival. Fossil fuel gave us an immense power and we probably didn't use it wisely. We'll see.

Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by yummypaint on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:28PM (#19230561)
This line of reasoning appears frequently, but it misses the concept people are referring to when they say nature. Words are defined through their use, and no person would describe a parking lot or the inside of a building as a natural environment.

I think most people picture a place without human activity at all when they imagine a fully "natural" environment, like an island thats never had people on it. In this interpretation, people living naturally would cause their environment to deviate minimally from how it would be in their absence.

We are currently the direct cause of an ongoing mass extinction. We have yanked the surface of the planet so far from equilibrium that it may never return to its previous state. We are from being a part of nature.

Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by whytaka on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:42PM (#19230676)
I agree with this definition of words and their utility, but I also agree with GPs definition of nature. Now we have two running definitions and they contradict, thus a debate ensues. Political debates are often a matter of warring sides trying to establish their meaning of a word over the other's.

Thankfully, we also have a reasonable expectation in the use of words in that they map to something real. The broader the internal consistency of that word, the more 'authoritative' it should be - although, admittedly, this is just my opinion. (Politics will surely have some say about this.)

On defining nature, we have witnessed two definitions.

1. Not human.

2. All of the cosmos.

Those who appreciate the theory of evolution, I think, will have a harder time determining where the threshold between human and nature would be.

Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by ravenstine on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:02PM (#19231110)
> Those who appreciate the theory of evolution, I think, will have a harder time determining where the threshold between human and nature would be.

All human terms are subjective that way. The universe is relative and probabilistic. Ideas like "nature" can be useful, but that's not to say the universe has a boolean type called "Nature" that actually exists in any objective sense.

Yet we keep having these sorts of debates year after year. Nothing exists in the ways that most people think them to be. I could care less whether something is "natural" if the conclusion has no use.

Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by longerthoughts on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:33PM (#19230612)
When was the planet at equilibrium? This is not a rhetorical question and I don't advocate for the destruction (or indifference to destruction) of the environment. But what is the natural state of the planet?
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by ravenstine on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:04PM (#19231117)
Equilibrium is a delusion of humans whose lives are too short, and whose brains are ill-equipped to comprehend the universal constant of change.
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by ploubus on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:37PM (#19230637)
Nature is and never has been equilibrium. Nature is chaos.
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by whytaka on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:27PM (#19230559)
I wholeheartedly agree. The concept of 'nature' in contrast to 'the human' seems to me something leftover from when we determined ourselves divine and separate from the rest. It's a word with arrogance deeply embedded in it.

The most useful meaning of this word is simply, "Not Human". But the human belongs to the natural.

Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by NeedMoreTea on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:29PM (#19230166)
What humans do stops being natural when it is no longer person-power but powered machines. That gives huge amounts of leverage.

You would consider a car, or a chainsaw natural? I wouldn't.

Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by x3n0ph3n3 on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:55PM (#19230343)
Some of us believe that artificial is merely of a subset of natural and saying that they are disjoint is a kind of naturalistic fallacy.
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by ianai on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:34PM (#19230204)
Humans can light the earth on fire with thousands of nuclear explosions. Almost nothing would survive. I’d say we’re well past natural. But your ways less extreme.
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by jedmeyers on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:55PM (#19230771)
A long long time ago some organisms “polluted” the athmosphere with oxygen. It wasn’t a natural event in your opinion?
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by x3n0ph3n3 on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:57PM (#19230354)
An asteroid can hit the earth and do the same thing. Is it not natural either?
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by User23 on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:51PM (#19230752)
And cyanobacteria transformed the entire atmosphere, to such a degree that almost everything else died out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by 11235813213455 on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:54PM (#19230338)
Humans are natural, and just another species among animals, that's true. But they have a very different responsibility since they completely control the rest of the ecosystem. Every grown-up human individual must be responsible and preserve the complex balance in the ecosystem
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by chongli on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:57PM (#19230352)
If everything we do is natural, why even have the word?
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by whytaka on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:20PM (#19230502)
It is a leftover piece from our arrogant past when we considered our image a reflection of the divine.

It is now just a way to say, "not human". Unfortunately, the embedded arrogance is still perpetuated.

Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by incompatible on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:56PM (#19230775)
Is it possible to make a distinction between things that are designed, with intelligence, and things that have obtained their form through haphazard forces or the actions of organisms following their genetically pre-programmed behaviour? Even if "nature" vs "artificial" are not the right words for it?
Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by jrochkind1 on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:45PM (#19231026)
Why do we have words for, oh, "phrenology" or "phlogiston"? Or, you know, um, "Caucasian".

We've got plenty of words whose referents aren't sound concepts.

Re:We Are Living in the Anthropocene by Retra on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:45PM (#19231270)
Naturalness is a useful abstraction. It contrasts things we will interact with through discovery to those we interact with through design. It is a sound concept, it is just biased to be human-centric.