News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by goodroot on Friday February 22, 2019 @05:57PM (#19229926)
I would be heart broken to learn that my work was used to facilitate killing.

I empathize for the developers involved; I hope those that feel as I do find brighter opportunities.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by leftyted on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:13PM (#19230046)
I wouldn't care.

Are the designers of TCP/IP responsible for everyone whose death was assisted by the internet? Are Orville and Wilbur burning in Hell for all the people who were killed by things dropped from planes? And God help whichever unfortunate human invented the wheel. Sorry for my tone, but I find this perspective naive and annoyingly sanctimonious.

I'm making tools. People can use them for whatever. I hope no one murderers anyone (unless they have a really good reason) but I'm only responsible for making sure I don't murder anyone, and so far I'm doing okay.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by bduerst on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:26PM (#19230556)
It comes down to intent.

I once had a neighbor who worked at Boeing, programming the guidance systems on smart bombs. The only reason I even remember him to this day is because immediately after introducing what he did for a living, he followed with, "I don't actually pull the trigger. I make the smart bombs smarter so they don't hurt innocent people."

I only remember this exchange because it can be interpreted several different ways.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by SolaceQuantum on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:32PM (#19230184)
If you're working on a technology that you know is created in contract with the military, is that not concerning?
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by leftyted on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:59PM (#19230360)
I have written software that is being used by the military and I didn't find it concerning. I find the anti-military sentiment on this website more concerning.

I'm pretty liberal but I do not think the military is a vestigial organ. Your worldview is not the only worldview. Your morality is not the only morality.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by SolaceQuantum on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:42PM (#19230678)
When did I claim a morality or worldview? You may be reading my posts in bad faith.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by leftyted on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:47PM (#19230715)
Your post implies that a person ought to be concerned if the military wants to use software that person has written. To me, it seems obvious that that perspective follows from various propositions about the world and about morality.

If you meant anything other than that by your post, feel free to explain. But I don't see any other way to interpret what you wrote. I don't think I'm guilty of misinterpretation, and certainly not "bad faith" i.e. willful misinterpretation.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by SolaceQuantum on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:19PM (#19230906)
I meant it could be reasonable to be concerned.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by Dylan16807 on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:38PM (#19231662)
Concerned why? Because of moral reasons? If not, you need to explain further.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by thizzbuzz on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:25PM (#19231620)
The examples you chose (TCP/IP, airplanes, etc.) show pretty clear willful misinterpretation, and I think you know that.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by sigstoat on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:18PM (#19230489)
i worked on software used by military police to record criminal interviews. should i be concerned that it's used by the military, or should i be relieved that the military courts have more accurate/complete recordings?
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by SolaceQuantum on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:41PM (#19230669)
I think there should be concern that surveillance is also used by the military on leaders in progressive movements, also. Military force has been used against domestic social movements in the near past and possibly continues to be used in the present.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by sigstoat on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:17PM (#19230895)
it wasn't surveillance software, and couldn't have been repurposed to that end. it was for recording people being interviewed in connection with military police investigations. it even did its best to prevent the investigators from tampering with the recordings. concerning, or not?
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by SolaceQuantum on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:19PM (#19230908)
I don't understand, it wasn't surveillance, but it was for recording people?
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by Rebelgecko on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:26PM (#19231625)
Have you ever seen a TV show or movie with an interrogation scene? I assume that's what the poster is referring to. Not recording people in their homes or anything untoward like that
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by jplayer01 on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:30PM (#19230584)
You mean the military that has helped ensure the affluence and security of the Western world? The military isn't bad just because it's the military. It serves important and necessary functions, ones that don't go away just because you want it to.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by SolaceQuantum on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:42PM (#19230673)
I never claimed to make a position. I merely said that maybe a position against the military is not entirely unreasonable.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by Dylan16807 on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:41PM (#19231671)
"It is not unreasonable for it to be concerning." is a position, by the way.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by influx on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:50PM (#19230307)
What's your line? Do you work on contracts for police? What about the United Nations? Any government contract at all, including local? I can find examples of all of them acting against populations and causing harm, as well for good.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by SolaceQuantum on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:40PM (#19230659)
My line is merely understanding and allowing others to protest things they find hurtful and believing they are valid in doing so. I never said I shared this view and I'm concerned you took my words so far from their face value.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by chillacy on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:03PM (#19231114)
> If you're working on a technology that you know is created in contract with the military, is that not concerning?

Implies to me that I should feel bad morally. Just my reading of it, but if lots of people are reading it that way as well, you may want to work on the wording if people are attributing more than you intended.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by pnw_hazor on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:11PM (#19230028)
What if your work helped reduce the amount of innocent civilians or soldiers that are killed in war?

I guess we could always go back to the good old daze when advanced tech or computers were not used in weapons systems. I wasn't around back then, but it sure seems like there sure were more innocent people killed in the bygone days of software-free weapons systems.

High-tech weapon systems save lives. But I am pretty sure you already know that.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by paganel on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:19PM (#19230096)
> High-tech weapon systems save lives. But I am pretty sure you already know that.

Not the OP, but what the high-tech weapon systems do (among other things, like killing innocent people attending weddings in remote parts of Afghanistan or Yemen) is to disengage the killers (i.e. the people making the decision to shoot, sometime from thousands and thousands of miles away) from their acts, as those doing the killing bear almost no risks of getting killed in retaliation and they also don't get to see the distorted limbs of those they get to kill. As such, the decision to make the kill becomes more and more easy and more and more random, because it doesn't have almost any effects on those who are responsible for said killings.

This is a very, very sad state of affairs for us, as a species, I mean, the fact that we've managed to make the act of killing to have almost no moral consequences on those that actually carry said killings.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by leereeves on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:32PM (#19230183)
Drone pilots are not disengaged from the psychological and moral trauma of war.

> Some say that the drone war has driven them over the edge. "How many women and children have you seen incinerated by a Hellfire missile? How many men have you seen crawl across a field, trying to make it to the nearest compound for help while bleeding out from severed legs?" Heather Linebaugh, a former drone imagery analyst, wrote in the Guardian. "When you are exposed to it over and over again it becomes like a small video, embedded in your head, forever on repeat, causing psychological pain and suffering that many people will hopefully never experience."

> "It was horrifying to know how easy it was. I felt like a coward because I was halfway across the world and the guy never even knew I was there,ā€ Bryant told KNPR Radio in Nevada. "I felt like I was haunted by a legion of the dead. My physical health was gone, my mental health was crumbled. I was in so much pain I was ready to eat a bullet myself."

https://www.salon.com/2015/03/06/a_chilling_new_post_traumat...

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by nickpinkston on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:01PM (#19230371)
Thank you for posting this.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by humanrebar on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:19PM (#19230092)
No, we should clearly go back to the days of low tech seige warfare, when battles were won by slowly starving people until they gave up.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by bduerst on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:31PM (#19230593)
This type of cost/benefit calculation was the justification for using the nuclear fission bomb on Japan in WW2.

The estimated cost of deaths of pushing the Pacific invasion without the bomb was higher than the cost of deaths using the bomb to force a surrender. Keep in mind this was in an era when total war existed, and civilians of warring nations were considered unarmed combatants.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by bassman9000 on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:14PM (#19230057)
Another example: the only technology, today, being realistic, to actually make an impact in CO2 reduction, is nuclear. And nuclear was born as a weapon. In a race to beat the enemy, who would have got the technology soon after.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by merlincorey on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:03PM (#19229982)
This particular system seems to be focused on our soldiers' "lethality, mobility and situational awareness."

So while the "lethality" certainly is all about facilitating killing, I would say the other points are at least somewhat about lifesaving for our troops.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by darkpuma on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:21PM (#19230113)
Dead soldiers aren't very lethal, so any distinction between the two seems rather arbitrary. Technology that helps soldiers survive necessarily helps soldiers kill. But this whole topic of "for the military" or "facilitating killing" is rather arbitrary.

If you work on a smartphone app for hailing taxis, that's probably not going to be plausibly military. But what if you work in a steel mill? You help in the production of steel that is necessary to create buildings and bridges, but also military ships and tanks and just about everything else. Is the production of steel a part of the military-industrial complex? Could the military-industrial complex continue operating without steel? Definitely not, the production of steel is essential to the military, yet it seems a bit strange for producers of steel to lose sleep over what their steel is used for.

But actually, let's go back to that taxi app. Most military personnel aren't in warzones, virtually all of them own smartphones, and a great many of them may be using ride hailing apps regularly. If such apps increase their personal efficiency, perhaps letting them get to work faster. If a drone operator in Utah uses your app to get to work hung over after a hard night of drinking, does that mean your taxi app is helping to kill people?

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by pnw_hazor on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:16PM (#19230472)
What about folks who work on digital skinner boxes or dark patterned tech, such as, ad networks, social media, free-to-gamble games, anything Android, gig-economy apps, or the like.

People in those industries don't even have the fig-leaf of "national defense" to help them sleep at night.

For them it is only about money, t-shirts, and free food. Who cares how many lives they ruin along the way.

They are true sociopaths, though inexplicably they would feel horrible if their work helped save a 19 year-old soldier's life or helped enable shooters recognize an incorrect target before harming innocents.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by darkpuma on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:43PM (#19231455)
Fully agree. Microsoft at least is otherwise relatively clean since they're best known for productivity software (although we could dive into what that productivity is actually accomplishing..) but when they start doing shit like promoting Candy Crush, I think that's well over the line.
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by tomohawk on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:05PM (#19230393)
The Nazis used the latest card punch tech to track people and facilitate the mass killing of people.

Joseph Stalin famously used the telephone in the middle of the night to make calls leading to the mass murder of thousands during his reign.

Churchill and Roosevelt used the first application of spread spectrum technology to securely communicate. This led to the deaths of millions of Axis personnel.

Are all of these equivalent?

I would be actually horrified to find out after the fact that I did not do all I could do to stop monsters such as Hitler, Stalin, or Mao. If something I build could stop someone like that, I'm all for it.

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by gdy on Saturday February 23, 2019 @01:53AM (#19232104)
How about stopping monsters from doing things like My Lai massacre?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Lai_Massacre

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by tomohawk on Saturday February 23, 2019 @02:38PM (#19235084)
Do you actually think there is a moral equivalence between actions directed be Stalin, Mao, Hitler, etc, and an incident that was not directed as a general policy, and was in fact against policy, and which in fact sickened the responders?
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by gdy on Saturday February 23, 2019 @03:13PM (#19235230)
Yeah, right, an incident. How is that smell of napalm in the morning?
Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by cududa on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:17PM (#19230073)
I feel like I’m living in the twilight zone seeing how far your comments been downvoted and the responses.

I totally support individuals rights to work on these kind of tools; and I totally support people demanding their work not be co-opted for lethal purposes

Re:Microsoft Workers Demand It Drop $450M U.S. Army Contract by dba7dba on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:06PM (#19230848)
Roads/oil/education/internet/mining/etc can be and used for military purposes.

Where do you want to draw the line?