News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fire your designer by DavidPP on Friday November 19, 2010 @04:41PM (#1922910)
To me it's seem he put more than one "job" under the designer bucket.

To me, an integrator (HTML / front-end JS) an art director, a usubility expert are different roles. Can you find somebody that do all this ? Of course, but if you just hire a "designer" without being more specific about your needs, you will end up in a situation like this.

Re:Fire your designer by haribilalic on Friday November 19, 2010 @04:55PM (#1922956)
Absolutely. If you want top-tier results, you'll have to hire top-tier people and I don't know a single "designer" who's great at every aspect of design and front-end development. It's important to realise that great design is a balancing act between all these aspects and to ensure your team manages them, e.g. a designer designing isolated from the front-end developers.

If you're not hiring employees, but are relying on freelancers, I question just how reasonable it is to have a designer use your templating languages and other tools instead of standard ones such as plain HTML and CSS. There are exceptions though: things like Wordpress and jQuery are common enough that you can easily find freelancers who'll be able to use them (but they're not common enough that every freelancer will).

Re:Fire your designer by pan69 on Friday November 19, 2010 @04:51PM (#1922940)
This is where a lot of the problems come from. To many "designers" think that they're also usability experts and information architects. The main problem comes from the fact that those disciplines can be subjective in their nature. A lot of decision making in those roles is about personal "opinion" as in; "Well, I think the search box should sit in the top-left corner of the page". What's easier than stating your opinion? And we all love doing that. A lot of employers simply do not understand this.
Re:Fire your designer by ThomPete on Friday November 19, 2010 @08:24PM (#1923522)
Actually to few designers do ux and vice versa.
Re:Fire your designer by pan69 on Friday November 19, 2010 @11:16PM (#1923832)
Did you meant to say; Few designers "understand" ux and vica vera?