My answer to that is 'who cares?'
It's not my problem, let me delete all my data.
In fact it's required by law in some places.
This is not a science problem and it is not hard to solve: a scientist would delete the data and re-derive their models because they want the best data possible. This is how you "preserve the usefulness of those models," by ensuring that the data has integrity.
facebook has to figure out a way to understand exactly how thousands of records per user, being deleted, will affect it's models.
This is looking through the telescope backwards. You create your models with the data that you have, and if some data is removed then you regenerate.
You can bet your ass they groom their data after detecting stuff like new botnets and fake clicks, and individual user data does not have to be different.
That is an entire community and classification of people that facebook has to figure out how to reconcile the loss of data for, and fix its machine learning models
Again, they already know how to do this, and they do it all the time. There are no nuances to it outside of roadblocks installed by FB themselves.
It's 110% a business problem, and 110% Zuckerberg's choice to make it difficult, and to invent difficulties in bringing it about.
I for one would be OK with a machine learning model that's been trained using my data. I wouldn't demand that it be "re-trained" just because I asked for my history to be deleted. I think most people, given an explanation of what a machine learning model is, would be fine with this.
The clear history thing is about personally identifiable information though. It's not having your information dangling around after you leave Facebook. It's having the option to delete your shadow profile.
Throughout all the hearings, FB execs have been very wishy-washy about how they handle your browsing history, particularly what they collect outside of FB properties.
People should continue to call them out on this until they get their act together.
2. That's it. Problem solved.
Question for extra credits:
These machine learning models you speak of, do they mostly do stuff that...
a) is in the interest of the users
b) goes against the interest of the users
Society does not have an obligation to tolerate negative externalities just to protect someone's business model. That is precisely what regulation is for.
Also, worth noting that FB has 2 primary users: you and advertisers. The second class of users is very interested in having your data. Unfortunately, FB seems to favor them bc they are the user who's paying them.
99.9% of the people are not even aware of the distinction. This is an attempt to follow the letter of the law to create an excuse not to follow the spirit of the law. What people want is personal privacy and cognitive freedom. They don't care about implementation details.
> Also, worth noting that FB has 2 primary users: you and advertisers. The second class of users is very interested in having your data. Unfortunately, FB seems to favor them bc they are the user who's paying them.
You are right. Sorry for the typo. I did not mean "users", I meant the "used".
Supermarkets have two types of users: customers and other businesses that use supermarkets to distribute their products. It would be in the interest of those other businesses if, for example, food safety standards were more lax. But not in the interest of the customers. The food industry has a lot more money and power than the customers, so we solve this with regulation. It's kind of Civilization 101, really.
In our world of Big Data, where it's easy to combine many disparate databases, effectively anonymizing data is also a very hard problem to solve.
Indeed, that sounds like a hard problem.
So the question becomes "how much of the hundreds of millions in R&D are being allocated to solve the record-deletion problem?". I'd like to see spending reports, new research publications from Facebook (e. g. retroactive record-deletion, attempts to build models that are robust to deletion, attempts to build k-anonymity into models from the start).
> I know there are more nuances here, but I think there are some challenges Facebook has in implementing this, and business wise it's a drain on resources that will hurt them.
I can give Facebook the benefit of the doubt and suppose that they're trying to figure out how to transition smoothly without destroying their models. But I'd also like to see a hard timeline when they promise to roll out user.delete.all.data() anyways (business value be damned).
The real test of whether a company really "takes your privacy seriously" is whether they ever reach a point where privacy becomes a priority, i. e. whether there are decisions to do the right thing even when it could be bad for the bottom line (under the current business model).
The easiest explanation is that Zuckerberg was lying. We could give him the benefit of the doubt but since he’s always lying it makes more sense to save time and assume he’s lying about this as well.
That may not be as simple as you think. FB probably has thousands of data types and each one needs to define how a deletion should affect everything else. E.g. if I delete my comment, what happens to your reply? That one is obviously solved already since it's a core part of the product, but there are probably lots of pieces of data that were never designed to be deleted so will need effort to support.
Given they solved that insanely hard problem pretty well, I’d suggest they could also solve this if they had sufficient motivation.
The sheer number of records per user is probably astounding, and facebook has to figure out a way to understand exactly how thousands of records per user, being deleted, will affect it's models.
Thought experiment: Imagine, all of the hacker news community and other privacy minded people go right into the tool and delete everything. That is an entire community and classification of people that facebook has to figure out how to reconcile the loss of data for, and fix its machine learning models. The difficult part is since so much current AI logic is based on historical data, a user deleting data, will be nearly impossible to untrain from the model.
I know there are more nuances here, but I think there are some challenges Facebook has in implementing this, and business wise it's a drain on resources that will hurt them. It's easy to think it would be so simple for FB to just call user.delete.all.data(), but the reality is the loss of data could seriously mess up their algos.