News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to combat healthcare benefit costs as a startup by yummyfajitas on Friday November 19, 2010 @02:02PM (#1922357)
I don't understand - what's the problem with insurers colluding to reduce costs? If they successfully create a downward price pressure, isn't that a good thing?
Re:How to combat healthcare benefit costs as a startup by tptacek on Friday November 19, 2010 @02:07PM (#1922371)
The side effect of their collusion coupled with their commanding share of the market is the destruction of the private market for health care, presumably because the administrative overhead of servicing that market and ensuring that it is transparent and inefficient dominates the returns they'd expect from it.

This isn't complicated: the price list for medical procedures bears no relationship either to the cost of those services or the money changing hands between providers and insurers.

Re:How to combat healthcare benefit costs as a startup by yummyfajitas on Friday November 19, 2010 @02:23PM (#1922431)
Why do you believe the private market was destroyed by collusion between insurance companies, rather than the massive government subsidies (20-30%, I think) provided to the employer-supplied insurance market?
Re:How to combat healthcare benefit costs as a startup by tptacek on Friday November 19, 2010 @02:29PM (#1922452)
You're trying to pin down a value judgement I'm not making. Stipulate that the government played a major role in creating this problem. Now what? I'm pretty sure my point still stands: there's no free market for private health care to fall back on, no matter how efficiently you consume health services.
Re:How to combat healthcare benefit costs as a startup by yummyfajitas on Friday November 19, 2010 @02:33PM (#1922472)
I'm not disputing your main point that the market in medical services is very far from free, or attempting to pin down a value judgement.

I'm only questioning your claim that collusion among insurance companies does much of anything besides push us closer to monopsony pricing.

Re:How to combat healthcare benefit costs as a startup by tptacek on Friday November 19, 2010 @02:46PM (#1922513)
Collusion between providers and insurers has, as an externality to the actual transaction taking place, severely distorted the market for medical services in the US. I'm not questioning whether insurers should be able to negotiate prices with providers.

If employer-sponsored health insurance wasn't the primary vehicle for medical expenses in the US, maybe you could get an actual price list for hospital services even in the face of aggressive negotiation. But it is, and so you can't, and any conversation about health expenses that tries to dodge that point is disingenuous. That's my point.

Re:How to combat healthcare benefit costs as a startup by brudgers on Friday November 19, 2010 @02:25PM (#1922441)
>"what's the problem with insurers colluding to reduce costs?"

Collusion is problematic because, the insurance companies [legal] duty is to increase their profits. Their interest in reducing costs is to reduce their cost of doing business not the patient's cost for services.

Re:How to combat healthcare benefit costs as a startup by yummyfajitas on Friday November 19, 2010 @02:30PM (#1922458)
Your claim seems to be that insurance companies are colluding to reduce costs out of self interest rather than altruism. What is problematic about this?
Re:How to combat healthcare benefit costs as a startup by brudgers on Friday November 19, 2010 @02:39PM (#1922491)
That is my observation and from a business standpoint that's all well and good.

However when the insurance companies collude to deny coverage for tuberculosis, it is problematic from the standpoint of my self interest because your untreated tuberculosis will kill me. There is a difference between healthcare and insurance.

Re:How to combat healthcare benefit costs as a startup by tptacek on Friday November 19, 2010 @02:31PM (#1922466)
This branch of the discussion is a red herring.