Re:Senate Panel Approves Domain Name Seizure Bill
by mindslight on Thursday November 18, 2010 @08:19PM
(#1920028)
Distribution of update authority doesn't require decentralization of the namespace itself. As long as the independent authorities can agree on what constitutes a valid update (say by requiring the domain-owner's signature), they'll stay consistent. Meanwhile a corrupted authority will only affect its own clients.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Senate Panel Approves Domain Name Seizure Bill
by wmf on Thursday November 18, 2010 @08:57PM
(#1920109)
In that case I would be worried about having a quorum of authorities located in the USA and all "corrupted" by law, thus outvoting the non-censored authorities.
Re:Senate Panel Approves Domain Name Seizure Bill
by mindslight on Thursday November 18, 2010 @09:28PM
(#1920182)
I'm not talking about any sort of voting, just restricting the inconsistencies only to answers from the corrupted authorities. If cryptome.org redirects to thoughtcrime.dhs.gov for DNS servers using US roots, it has the same localized effect as any current national dns tampering. All uncorrupted authorities would all continue to agree that the domain hadn't been deregistered because they saw no signed update from cryptome.org. (And of course an 'authority' can even be your local upgraded DNS server if you care enough about having uncensored DNS)
edit: Actually I guess I'm talking about a quorum of 1 for legacy clients (nationality of chosen root servers), and updated authorities/clients relying on the total quorum that's easily established before the domain becomes "of interest".