News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by rmrfrmrf on Saturday February 16, 2019 @10:41AM (#19179065)
Did you read the article? The implication is that union discussions caused the pullout, not the "toxic minority voices". It's more evidence of Amazon's relentless exploitation of labor.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by gpm on Saturday February 16, 2019 @10:45AM (#19179089)
> It's more evidence of Amazon's relentless exploitation of labor.

That's one interpretation. Another interpretation is it's more evidence of the inefficiencies and corruption created by the current unions.

The truth is probably somewhere in between.

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by awakeasleep on Saturday February 16, 2019 @11:28AM (#19179333)
How extreme would Amazon's position have to be before you would stop saying 'the truth is in the middle'?

Would it be Amazon demanding an office worker travel the day after her miscarriage?

> The Times has uncovered several cases where workers who were sick, grieving, or otherwise encumbered by the realities of life were pushed out of the company. A woman who had a miscarriage was told to travel on a business trip the day after both her twins were stillborn. Another woman recovering from breast cancer was given poor performance rankings and was warned that she was in danger of losing her job.

Would it be Amazon keeping ambulances at their warehouses rather than paying for air conditioning? Or working people hard enough that they had to pee in bottles and most people have to quit after 6 months because of the strain on their bodies?

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by rmrfrmrf on Saturday February 16, 2019 @11:02AM (#19179184)
Im not one for centrist truth synthesis. The only people who are against unions are those who are trained to be.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by dwaltrip on Saturday February 16, 2019 @02:25PM (#19180438)
> The only people who are against unions are those who are trained to be.

It hurts your credibility to fail to acknowledge any legitimate critiques.

[dead]
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by dwaltrip on Saturday February 16, 2019 @07:12PM (#19181796)
Ah yes, you have correctly identified the chief drivers of my political viewpoints: fear and stupidity. Very well then, it looks like our work here is done.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by threeseed on Saturday February 16, 2019 @01:09PM (#19179948)
There is a direct correlation between the decline in unionism and the lack of growth in wages.

So acting like having no unions is a good thing is not actually true.

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by gpm on Saturday February 16, 2019 @03:46PM (#19180842)
I'm certainly not saying "no unions are a good thing", generally speaking I think unions are a good thing (and that's as far into politics as I want to get on HN).

I am saying "there are drawbacks as well, and this 'evidence' points to the drawbacks as much as it points to the advantages". It's disingenuous to argue otherwise, and perhaps more importantly, isn't going to convince anyone who doesn't already agree with you because they will just take the other interpretation.

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by sct202 on Saturday February 16, 2019 @12:33PM (#19179715)
I think it's surprising that they'd be afraid of NYC unions, while operating without issue in Washington which is about just as union heavy as NY.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by jdavis703 on Saturday February 16, 2019 @11:20AM (#19179292)
Why do people making $150,000 a year, working safe jobs behind a desk, need a union? If this was about unionizing their warehouse staff I could understand sinking the deal. But white collar people making six figures don’t need the legal and organizing framework a union provides (for example see the employee actions at Google over the last year).
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by threeseed on Saturday February 16, 2019 @01:13PM (#19179978)
I don't think you understand how large companies work.

An engineer is never negotiating their employment conditions with HR or with senior executives. It's with their direct line manager. Who often has no power to ask for anything like parental leave or some other workplace condition.

Unions negotiate at the VP of HR level and so they can demand significant changes.

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by jdavis703 on Saturday February 16, 2019 @05:15PM (#19181275)
> I don't think you understand how large companies work.

I've worked in multi-thousand person orgs with both unions and non-unions. I've been tasked with everything from installing satellite dishes on top of downtown office buildings to writing code in a climate controlled office.

I don't have an MBA in HR, but I do have my personal experiences and those of my coworkers. When I was installing satellite dishes it was great knowing I had union backup (even if work rules like carrying a geiger counter seemed a little over the top). When writing code the biggest risk I face is a repetitive stress injury, and a coder's salary goes a long way to buying my own ergonomic equipment.

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by RhysU on Saturday February 16, 2019 @04:28PM (#19181041)
That must be why tech companies have had increasingly nice working conditions and, in particular, markedly longer parental leave policies of late. All the unions.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by threeseed on Saturday February 16, 2019 @07:56PM (#19181948)
That's more a reflection of a competitive market.

And it's definitely not all companies. Just the top tier ones.

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by danharaj on Saturday February 16, 2019 @12:22PM (#19179647)
Because controlling the conditions of your work is more than just a paycheck. Especially for tech workers whose work has a transformative impact on society. If you've ever been pressured into doing something unethical, that is a perfectly good rationale for forming a union.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by ken on Saturday February 16, 2019 @01:41PM (#19180175)
What does the average salary or the presence of a desk have to do with this at all? Trade unions aren't just for poor people. I'll flip it around: what makes you think that only lower-class workers can benefit from collective bargaining?
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by rmrfrmrf on Saturday February 16, 2019 @12:39PM (#19179755)
I assumed the union talks were for the lower-paid foundation service staff more than the professional class, though I do think there's value in devs/ops organizing to demand more favorable work conditions.

At any rate, Amazon is worried about a snowball effect of other areas unionizing in New York's wake.