News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by tacomonstrous on Saturday February 16, 2019 @10:23AM (#19178942)
>Many people do not realize that Amazon leaving doesn't mean +$3B in their pocket it means $0 and even less than zero in the long term.

How is this any less laughable than the position you're chastising? LIC was already booming before the Amazon investment. The idea that Amazon will be replaced by nothing at all is ludicrous.

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by beaner on Saturday February 16, 2019 @10:30AM (#19178987)
I dunno if that's accurate. "Lots of development + Amazon" is more than "lots of development." Amazon not being there doesn't necessarily mean there will be more of something else.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by bilbo0s on Saturday February 16, 2019 @10:41AM (#19179067)
>Amazon not being there doesn't necessarily mean there will be more of something else...

I don't know man?

In most places I might agree with you, but in places like NYC and Silicon Valley?

Yeah, I'm pretty sure it means more of something else. Sometimes it can be easy to underestimate the size and dynamism of those two economic engines.

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by esoterica on Saturday February 16, 2019 @10:46AM (#19179096)
So you think the number of jobs in NYC is a fixed constant? That every extra job created by amazon is one less job elsewhere? That’s the literal opposite of dynamism.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by geofft on Saturday February 16, 2019 @11:46AM (#19179450)
If we're not able to significantly increase infrastructure for getting to work, whether roads, subways, ferries, or whatever, yes, the number of jobs in NYC is going to hit a cap pretty soon.

The usual way of solving this problem and continuing to scale a city is that you use tax revenue from new jobs to build additional public infrastructure. But the HQ2 deal made a point of giving up that tax revenue....

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by smokeyj on Saturday February 16, 2019 @01:15PM (#19179992)
> But the HQ2 deal made a point of giving up that tax revenue....

But the subsidies will largely still be available to the next people to move in right? Meaning, you’ve effectively accomplished nothing, right?

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by geofft on Saturday February 16, 2019 @01:31PM (#19180094)
If that's true, then yes, I agree that nothing was accomplished. Is it? I don't know the details of the deal and I'd be pretty unhappy if it's true....

(If you just mean "Amazon proved it's negotiable," I think Amazon pulling out equally proves that it's a political quagmire to try to negotiate it.)

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by sdenton4 on Saturday February 16, 2019 @10:54AM (#19179136)
That's basically what full employment means, and we pretty much there.

So a pile of 'something else' jobs would be replaced with shotty Amazon jobs - and the stories from their corporate offices and from their warehouses have been harrowing.

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by nerfhammer on Saturday February 16, 2019 @11:50AM (#19179472)
This is the opposite of what full employment means. Full employment means a fixed number of workers who mostly all have jobs already, not a fixed number of job opportunities. Adding more competition for labor during full employment means employers will be forced to make workers better offers, not worse offers. It does not mean every job can only be replaced by a worse job, it means the opposite of that.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by CPLX on Saturday February 16, 2019 @11:01AM (#19179175)
The amount of jobs in global leading cities is usually constrained by housing, rather than the other way around. It’s an important point to note.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by mikeash on Saturday February 16, 2019 @10:33AM (#19179011)
It’s highly likely, though. Supply and demand: less demand for real estate and employees means prices will be lower, which in turn means others will buy more.

Economics isn’t a zero-sum game, but neither is it a completely uncorrelated bag of stuff.

Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by ineedasername on Saturday February 16, 2019 @10:45AM (#19179084)
This view of supply and demand is incomplete. Under your line of thinking there would never be issues of over supply. Which is of course wrong. During the financial crisis there was too much supply of housing that wouldn't be purchased at any price. See farming as an industry where too much supply can result in the need to sell product at a loss. Supply and demand is not some magical system that always balances. Artificial interference and externalities can absolutely throw it into negative-sum territory.
Re:Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal by mikeash on Saturday February 16, 2019 @11:14AM (#19179252)
That’s true in general, but we’re talking about 25,000 jobs in a thriving metro area of 20 million people. The situation isn’t anywhere near these extremes.