> the 1% are mostly working people who supplement wage income with some kind of side business income. This is exactly what you would expect if you think about lawyers, doctors, software developers, consultants
This is.... not what I would expect, at all. If you told me my thesis was just wrong and that the 1% (not .1%) just made wage income, I could accept that. But- you think it's normal for highly paid professionals to work a self-employed side gig, and that's what tips them into that top percentile? Like, a Bain consultant is going out and doing some extra side consulting in her copious spare time outside of her 80 hour a week job? This seems bizarre & unlikely (I am just relying now on your interpretation of the paper).
Worth noting that high-earning doctors, lawyers, some developers can be self-employed, and so neither an employee or employer (especially for doctors I think that's the path to the highest income). Not sure how that factors in to the paper
Back to my main point - if you want to talk about business owners in the job-creating sense vs. income, it's important to distinguish between 1% and 0.1%. The latter is composed mostly of medium-size business owners (a good thing!), but the former is not.
- Among the top 1%, 69% earn pass-through business income in some form
- At the 99th percentile, business income only accounts for about 40% of total income
The majority of what is described in the abstract (and a lot of the focus in the paper) is on the 0.1%, not the 1%. If you dig through their data and filter out the clear focus on $1M+ earners, the picture is pretty clear: the 1% are mostly working people who supplement wage income with some kind of side business income. This is exactly what you would expect if you think about lawyers, doctors, software developers, consultants, etc. When you get near the 0.1% level the picture changes significantly and business income takes over along with number of employees at owned businesses.