- Among the top 1%, 69% earn pass-through business income in some form
- At the 99th percentile, business income only accounts for about 40% of total income
The majority of what is described in the abstract (and a lot of the focus in the paper) is on the 0.1%, not the 1%. If you dig through their data and filter out the clear focus on $1M+ earners, the picture is pretty clear: the 1% are mostly working people who supplement wage income with some kind of side business income. This is exactly what you would expect if you think about lawyers, doctors, software developers, consultants, etc. When you get near the 0.1% level the picture changes significantly and business income takes over along with number of employees at owned businesses.
> the 1% are mostly working people who supplement wage income with some kind of side business income. This is exactly what you would expect if you think about lawyers, doctors, software developers, consultants
This is.... not what I would expect, at all. If you told me my thesis was just wrong and that the 1% (not .1%) just made wage income, I could accept that. But- you think it's normal for highly paid professionals to work a self-employed side gig, and that's what tips them into that top percentile? Like, a Bain consultant is going out and doing some extra side consulting in her copious spare time outside of her 80 hour a week job? This seems bizarre & unlikely (I am just relying now on your interpretation of the paper).
Worth noting that high-earning doctors, lawyers, some developers can be self-employed, and so neither an employee or employer (especially for doctors I think that's the path to the highest income). Not sure how that factors in to the paper
Back to my main point - if you want to talk about business owners in the job-creating sense vs. income, it's important to distinguish between 1% and 0.1%. The latter is composed mostly of medium-size business owners (a good thing!), but the former is not.
Looking at top 40 (because it gets boring to look up bios after a while), I see the following folks who inherited companies founded by their family members: Charles Koch, David Koch, Jim Walton, Alice Walton, Robson Walton, Jacqueline Mars, John Mars, Abigail Johnson, Donald Bren, Lukas Walton, Leonard Lauder.
That is 11 out of top 40 (or 27.5%) have inherited their wealth. That is certainly a big fraction of billionaires who did nothing but win the birth lottery.
Economic divides are a strange concern anyway; I don't see how I am unfairly disadvantaged by someone else's obscene wealth through winning the birth lottery. The issues as I see them are (1) high inequality is often an indicator of corruption and (2) many cities won't build sufficient high-density housing for political reasons.
What exactly is Jim Walton consuming that should be given to the poor? He probably doesn't eat that much food, and I doubt he is competing for housing stock with people who are struggling to make rent.
I see 27.5% as too damn high to be among the richest in the world just based on birth lottery.
> I don't see how I am unfairly disadvantaged by someone else's obscene wealth through winning the birth lottery.
Wealthy people get disproportionate benefits in: legal system [1], healthcare [2], political influence [3]. I can go on, but there few examples are sufficient to see why someone should get these privileges just because of birth.
> What exactly is Jim Walton consuming that should be given to the poor?
Don't know about Waltons, but Koch brother are consuming their wealth to purchase political influence [4]. I would rather have it spent on poor.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Thiel#Gawker_lawsuit
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/03/business/economy/high-end...
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_money
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_activities_of_the_Ko...
If r > g is true- why are the large majority self-made entrepreneurs? Wouldn't the compounding effect of inherited wealth make say the Rockefellers top the list by 2019? I couldn't find them in the top 100.
The broader point is to use actual data versus empty theorizing from first principles. While I don't personally agree with what you stated above, you're already miles ahead of Piketty by using real-world data that we have on wealthy families vs. extremely broad theorizing on stuff like 'r always exceeds g'
See where I'm going with this? I'll take arguments against r > g seriously when they account for institutional wealth instead of just personal wealth.
There are no Rockefellers on the board of the Rockefeller Foundation.
https://www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/private/board.asp?...
One of the directors of the Ford Foundation is a Ford.
https://www.tfff.org/who-we-are/board-directors
None of the directors of the Carnegie Corporation are Carnegies.
https://www.carnegie.org/about/trustees-and-staff/
Two of the directors of the Hearst Foundation are Hearsts, of thirteen.
If these foundations are attempts to keep wealth in the family they’re utter failures. At the peak of his personal wealth Rockefeller was worth over 1% of US GDP. $4 billion is nothing compared to that.
He has.... pledged to give 99% away to charity by the end of his & Melinda's life? I don't think 'foundation' in this case means what you think it means. It's not a secret tax dodge to pass it on to their children indirectly, their heirs will get very little
It doesn't look like it refute's the OP's point that the top 1% of people sorted by income are wage earners.
The abstract seems to be talking about "top income' (i.e. sort people by income and fetch from highest to lowest until you have 1% of all income in the US), which is a different measure.
But hard to tell without the paper.
'Have the idle rich replaced the working rich at the top of the U.S. income distribution? Using tax data linking 11 million firms to their owners, this paper finds that entrepreneurs who actively manage their firms are key for top income inequality. Most top income is non-wage income, a primary source of which is private business profit. These profits accrue to working-age owners of closely-held, mid-market firms in skill-intensive industries.'
Without going into the extensive exaggerations, lies and data-fudging of Piketty- do you look at the Forbes 400 list of wealthiest Americans and see a lot of inherited wealth there? A lot of Rockefellers, Morgans, and Vanderbilts? It's a bit surprising, right, because if we accept r > g then Rockefellers/Morgans/Vanderbilts should own most of the US by compounding wealth starting over 100 years ago at this point....
And in fact we find the Forbes 400 is virtually all- self-made entrepreneurs who created their own wealth. If you find a Rockefeller there who's never worked a day in his life but is simply living on rentier income, please let me know. (As I mentioned in the original comment, one of the reasons Piketty's rentier fantasies don't work is that he doesn't gauge consumption- and I suspect idle wealthy inheritant-types who don't work burn cash at a greater rate than r)