News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Insanity on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:08AM (#19152415)
It's horrible that people are dying because of malaria. I'm a bit divided on this approach though, I don't know enough about the topic at hand to suggest a different approach, but let me try.

Would it be feasible to suggest using CRISP to create another adaptation to the gene, one that preserves the mosquitoes but makes them unable to transfer the disease to humans?

Eliminating a species because we don't like it reminds me of speciesism as Peter Singer outlines in one of his books. (Animal Liberation I believe it was). Where humans assume another species to be inferior and have less of a right to live a decent life.

I do think it's a normal response to value human life more. And in fact, I also do think that in this case it makes more sense to safe the humans if no other approach is viable..

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by shireboy on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:43AM (#19152580)
The article mentions they tried to engineer mosquitos to not carry malaria, but it made them weak and so natural selection favored the non-engineered mosquitoes.

As for the rest, yeah tricky business. By all accounts we have more value than a mosquito, but as you move up the food chain what are the unintended consequences?

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Nasrudith on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:21AM (#19152795)
What about the effect of existing anti-mosquito measures? We aren't exactly using pleasant chemicals for that.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by ahje on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:01AM (#19152687)
It is indeed horrible, and it is fantastic that so many resources are dedicated to find a solution to this travesty!

Eliminating entire species deliberately, on the other hand, isn't really better. Yes, there is the us vs. them dilemma, and of course we should favour our own species if there's no other option, but this should be used as a last resort only.

I wonder if there's anyone looking into using similar methods to make humans malaria resistant instead.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Insanity on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @11:15AM (#19154130)
You'd open up another heap of ethical issues if we were to try adapting humans in such a way. Like the CRISPR babies that were born in China.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by ahje on Friday February 15, 2019 @09:01AM (#19170944)
Indeed, but which is preferable? Genetic vaccination against malaria or extinction of an entire species who are also a victim of the same parasite?

Both can potentially have unintended and disastrous consequences hundreds of years into the future.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by acallahan on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @02:19PM (#19155849)
Some interesting prior discussion in this older comment thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15929339

My understanding is that out of 3,500 mosquito species, only about 40 transmit malaria. Most of what I've read from experts implies they're not sure that mosquitoes play any biologically important role at all, and it seems like if there is some role (other than killing humans), the other 99% of non-eradicated mosquito species could fill in that gap.

In my (decidedly non-expert) opinion, that's good enough to start making moves towards eradicating the mosquito-causing species.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by arbuge on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:49AM (#19153004)
> Eliminating a species because we don't like it reminds me of speciesism

How about eliminating them because they are killing us, literally by the millions? Viewed that way, it seems more like normal self-defense to me. Currently mosquito-borne diseases kill around 700,000 people each year; this figure does not include the cost to society of the people who become ill but later recover. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosquito

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by userbinator on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:02AM (#19152691)
Where humans assume another species to be inferior and have less of a right to live a decent life.

How about if you consider things like bacteria? The rabbit-hole of "speciesism" never ends...

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by hutzlibu on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:08AM (#19152722)
People are also dying of war and hunger and lack of clean water and medicine. I would even argue that those are the bigger problems and the deaths of malaria are more symptoms of the former problems. Usually, it ain't the rich people who die of malaria.

So I would focus in those problems instead of trying to inject suicide genes into the wild.

I like the saying: the opposite of well done, is well intented.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by mrfredward on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:58AM (#19153073)
>People are also dying of war and hunger and lack of clean water and medicine.

No one can fix this with a snap of their fingers. You have to reform (replace?) governments, change cultural standards around sanitation, build tons of infrastructure. No matter how much aid is sent, it will take a long time even in the best case. These problems won't be fixed for good in the near future.

Perhaps malaria can be made a thing of the past before then. If so, don't let hundreds of thousands die because we "should" be fixing poverty instead.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by hutzlibu on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @11:17AM (#19154144)
"Perhaps malaria can be made a thing of the past before then."

Perhaps along with the last remaining shreds of intact eco systems that remained. Oh and perhaps some suicide genes end up somewhere else.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by mrfredward on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @11:29AM (#19154232)
DDT is still being used for mosquito control, because the risks and ecological damage are deemed to be less important than the half million people per year dying of malaria.

Millions of lives currently depend on reducing mosquito populations, so methods of control will be used no matter what. Targeting a specific species of mosquito rather than spraying DDT everywhere will reduce the collateral damage to the environment immensely.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by hutzlibu on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @01:04PM (#19155065)
DDT is bad. But its effect is limited to the amount of used chemical.

Altering genomes of living organisms with the intention of wiping out a species ... has a potential unlimited side effect.

I especially like the second example: fighting the toad in australia. Originally the toad was brought in to mess with the local ecosystem ... then it messed too much and now the solution is altering the genome with a exponentional bigger impact.

Isn't that real live satire? I mean how could that possible go wrong, since we understand everything about ecosystems and the genome today and are masters about controlling complex systems ...

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by vinniejames on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:34AM (#19152550)
Sounds like youre suggesting creating a mosquito malaria vaccine
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by Insanity on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:39AM (#19152564)
Not entirely - I'm suggesting still altering the species but not with extinction as a consequence.
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by vinniejames on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @02:09PM (#19155743)
I agree, a vaccine would be one way to accomplish that
Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by mrfusion on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:38AM (#19152909)
I like to paste this awesome response from reddit whenever someone doubts these approaches (since I couldn’t put it better myself)

> Malaria is only carried by a tiny number of mosquito species. Of the thousands of species only something like a dozen actually matter to humans. We can target exactly the ones we want and even better : nothing stops us from maintaining a population in some labs somewhere. If it turns out they matter in any significant way, contrary to various impact analysis... we just release them back into the environment.

> The current cost of not wiping out those few mosquito species is about half a million dead children. Imagine that someone was nuking a mid sized American city every year and you could stop it right now but you'd prefer to wait for a slightly more athsteticly pleasing solution.

> How much blood would you be willing to let stain your soul .

https://pay.reddit.com/r/biology/comments/9ivkka/genetic_mod...

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by mcguire on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:51AM (#19153021)
What exactly do you mean by "Of the thousands of species only something like a dozen actually matter to humans." How sure are you?

Keep in mind that, in this case, extinction is a side effect of another antimalarial effort.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by mrfusion on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:58AM (#19153082)
Well we know only certain species carry malaria. Is that what you’re questioning?

Also Seems like you skipped over this part:

> nothing stops us from maintaining a population in some labs somewhere. If it turns out they matter in any significant way, contrary to various impact analysis... we just release them back into the environment.

Re:CRISPR machines that can wipe out entire species by mcguire on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @01:11PM (#19155157)
I was mostly interested in the "matters to humans" part. Indirect consequences, and all that.

...Re-releasing them, after the environment has adjusted to their absence, does not return you to the original state.