I'm no macro-economist (although I do have an economics degree), but I believe deflation and inflation are acceptable as long as they are gradual changes and don't enrich or impoverish one segment of the economy over another. I think a lot of people are wary of the Fed (and Congress for that matter) overreacting to current economic conditions in order to stabilize prices AND maximize employment, messing up one or the other in the process, as Greenspan & the GSA-induced malinvestment in housing did.
The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design.
-F.A. Hayek, The Fatal Conceit
We'll probably never know for sure if QE2 was worth it or not. It's a trade-off, let's hope that the upsides justify the downsides.
Maybe macro-economists don't really get macro-economics, but who else do we have?
The government gives money to guys like Goldman which buy treasuries using these cheap money (call it "QE1" or low interest window or whatever). After that the government buys these papers back making a good profit for Goldman. "Trickle down" here is that somebody would get paid washing Ferrari and Lambo of Goldman's people.
As a consequence the price of stocks, properties and cars will theoretically rise because bond holders sell their bonds to the government and invest money in other things; The yields of those things, i.e. stocks, properties, commodities would also decrease corresponding, too.
Bond holders do really suddenly have gotten a short term gain, but after selling the bonds they hold to take the short term gain they aren't going to be trading bonds anymore. Not quite equal to giving money. Imagine if the government had a new policy to all software engineers: "We will pay $200,000 to each software engineer who stops working as an engineer for 5 years". It's something like that.
Disclaimer: I've studied only one year of commerce.
Credit contraction is happening but prices are rising. This is not the time to be telling people they need to sick it up and pay more for things. I'd imagine that credit expansion in China is the culprit on that front though.
QE has never worked. This will fail and we're going to continue to muddle along until someone allows the money supply to fall and the banks to fail. The banks are already insolvent anyway so we might as well face reality and face a few very tough years. Given our recent behavior we have it coming to us.
Nonsense. As Nobel Prize Winner Paul Krugman said, anyone who disagrees is either stupid and doesn't understand anything, or they are evil republicans who want to destroy the world or something.
The guys who did this clearly don't understand macro-economics. And yet many people will be convinced that QE2 "is bad" because "deflation is good, I can buy more stuff for less money" or "Bernanke didn't see the subprime crisis coming, therefor is incompetent".
QE2 might not be the right thing to do. But this movie doesn't educate people or make them understand why QE2 might be a bad idea (hyper-inflation is the main risk). It just make people angry and suspicious, while keeping them ignorant.