News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by jschwartzi on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:20PM (#19150078)
The only thing I really take issue with on this truck is that the spare tire is accessed through the top of the bed. There are two reasons you don't want to do this in a truck:

1.) The bed needs to be very strong because people routinely put weight on dunnage in the bed, and the door doesn't appear to be corrugated to withstand load.

2.) If you want to change your flat tire you need to unload everything in the bed, which will be a huge pain in the ass on the side of the road.

Otherwise thank god someone is actually trying to capture this market. I really want one of these and can't wait until they're closer to market.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by leetcrew on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:26AM (#19152834)
> If you want to change your flat tire you need to unload everything in the bed, which will be a huge pain in the ass on the side of the road.

aren't you already supposed to unload your vehicle before you jack it up on one side? maybe it's different for "work vehicles", but my car comes with a puny little jack that's only strong enough to support the weight of the car when there are no people or heavy items inside. I suspect the hardpoint on the car itself isn't designed with much more headroom than the jack.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by mikestew on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @09:38AM (#19153382)
The hard point of the car is part of the frame on every vehicle I can recall. And I recall a lot, because back when I was a mechanic I had to find those points to get the car on the hydraulic lift. One had to be careful of rusty VW Beetles as unibody as kind of a new thing, and a lift could punch a hole through the floor of a rusted Beetle if one wasn’t careful.

Anyway, enough resume flouting. Yes, you should unload your truck before changing the tire. What if that 1000 lbs. is pea gravel? Still unloading it first, Dr. Safety First? If I had 1000 lbs. in the bed and I had a flat? I’d change it as is. It won’t be the smartest thing I do that week, and I am going to keep my hands out from breaking the vertical plane of the wheel well as much as possible. But I am confident that the solid point of the frame will hold it, and even the puny jack is likely stringer than it looks.

But in reality, if I had a load, I’d just call AAA or a mobile truck service. They carry really nice heavy-duty jacks. Flat tires are such a rarity these days, I’d roll the dice on paying someone $200 to change my tire.

In the end, if you’re that worried about it, do what we did when I was kid with our old ‘63 Chevy: throw the spare on top of the load when you’re done loading. Doesn’t fix the jacking problem, but at least the spare is accessible.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by toss1 on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @11:10AM (#19154087)
It depends on the load, the surface, the jack, and the overall situation. For sure, many of the spindly jacks that come with small cars could be an issue.

And remember, the jack is only lifting one corner (or side in some configurations), so it sin't the whole load.

Even if it's iffy, I can easily envision a situation where the load is not massive but is still bulky or inconvenient to remove, or impossible to do so without equipment.

So, yes, this feature would give me pause (maybe not a deal-breaker, but...) in contrast to an otherwise fantastic design. If you haven't yet, definitely check it out!

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:33AM (#19152877)
>aren't you already supposed to unload your vehicle before you jack it up on one side?

Eh, maybe?

You have to take the totality of circumstances into account. The jack (depending on the style, some are better than others) can probably take the weight in most circumstances. The vehicle can probably also tolerate the extra weight so long as it's not grossly overloaded or rusted. Whether you have any problems is going to depend more on the details of the location more than anything else.

You could go on Reddit and score a bunch of virtue points for saying nobody should ever jack up a vehicle in less than perfect circumstances but I think in the overwhelming majority of real world situations you do not need to unload the vehicle.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by yyyymmddhhmmss on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:53PM (#19150249)
>you need to unload everything in the bed, which will be a huge pain in the ass on the side of the road.

Who says that’s even going to be possible? It sounds like a complete design flop to me.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by 15155 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:55PM (#19150534)
One could always place the spare in the cabin for situations where it will be less accessible.

But yeah, major design problem.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by ianai on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:16AM (#19152196)
That’s a bad idea in itself, but maybe a necessity. It’s a safety hazard to have big or heavy things that can turn into projectiles or blunt forces in a cabin during an accident.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by chiph on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @09:29AM (#19153307)
Honda stores the spare in the in-bed trunk. But there's also a threaded insert in the front of the bed where you can attach the spare. Either because you needed all of the trunk room for tools/golf-bags, etc., or in case of getting a flat while you were hauling gravel and couldn't open the trunk.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:42AM (#19152944)
What really annoys me is that the under-bed spare (or any "trunk in bed" type feature) makes having a proper drop in liner impossible. A drop in liner increases the durability of a pickup bed by an order of magnitude and is all but required for certain use cases if you don't want to tear up the bed in short order.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by SteveCoast on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @12:47AM (#19150762)
This is what the Honda Ridgeline does.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by Element_ on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:35PM (#19150152)
I think the reason the spare tire isn't more easily accessible is because of the importance of aerodynamics in electric vehicles (It can't just be bolted underneath or to the back). Also the CEO mentioned in an interview that the spare tire can be removed to gain a large water proof storage compartment under the bed.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by taneq on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @02:18AM (#19151090)
> It can't just be bolted underneath or to the back

Why not just bolt it underneath and put a cover over it? The cover would weigh less than a couple of kilos and probably improve the vehicle's overall aerodynamics anyway.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by Sendotsh on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @02:26AM (#19151129)
If it's like lots of other EVs, the batteries go completely across the bottom of the vehicle for a low COG.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by Shivetya on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @07:24AM (#19152494)
with regards to pickup trucks most spares are located behind the rear axle and current BEVs usually only have the battery pan between the axles.

So I put it down to a packaging issue. They had two choices and under the bed solution provided the extra benefit of being able to use that space for other purposes. Many newer vehicles do not carry spare tires and this trend has been accelerating as tire technology has improved greatly and road side assistance is common that people rarely if ever have to change a tire.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by jschwartzi on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @02:33AM (#19151163)
Yeah, this is probably why they went this route, and it makes a lot of sense. It's just strange to see it advertised as a design feature. Having it called out like that as if it's something I want in a truck was very jarring, like they didn't really understand what I would be using a truck for.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by ForHackernews on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @05:23AM (#19151945)
Yes, some people like you use their pickups for real work. For most American drivers, a pickup truck (or SUV) is just a fashion statement. They drive it around town with (an empty bed) instead of a Honda Civic.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by greglindahl on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @12:32AM (#19150704)
It was fun watching car spares shift to mini-spares, and now many high-end cars don't have a spare.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by kwhitefoot on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @03:09AM (#19151334)
In over forty years of driving I have had only one flat that wasn't just a slow leak. And the weather was so bad that I chose to slowly drive home, about fifteen miles, on the flat rather than change the wheel. The next day I drove another couple of miles to a tyre supply company and just had the tyre replaced.

Not sure if I would be so quick to do it in a modern car with alloy wheels and an even mass distribution but the car in question was a tough old Volvo Amazon with steel wheels and the flat was on a back wheel; in the Amazon most of the weight of the car is over the front wheels so the flat really didn't stress the wheel much.

That was about thirty five years ago.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:25AM (#19152824)
How many flats you get depends on where you drive more than anything. If you're only ever driving on well maintained roads that are free of debris then you will almost never get flats. Also just because a leak is slow doesn't mean you don't need the spare. If you had needed to be somewhere the following day (e.g. work) you would have put on the spare.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by leetcrew on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:29AM (#19152852)
weird things happen sometimes. two weeks ago, I got a razorblade embedded in one of my tires exactly parallel to the tread. I think it happened while I was parking. I came out of the store only twenty minutes later to find my tire at 0 psi.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by microcolonel on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @01:49AM (#19150975)
> It can't just be bolted underneath or to the back

Well, if it is bolted under, it needs its own cover/plate, which increases the weight of the surrounding structure (since whatever's there can't be structural).

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by jschwartzi on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @02:30AM (#19151146)
It doesn't need a cover/plate. Every full-size or mid-size truck I've owned hoists the spare underneath the bed without a cover. Tires are very durable, and if something impacts the tire it's probably destroyed your differential, brakes, and/or axle too so the spare isn't terribly useful.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by microcolonel on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @06:54PM (#19158350)
The aerodynamics, what parent was talking about, were why I said there would need to be a cover.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by decasteve on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @08:18AM (#19152780)
I agree. But the R1S is exactly the electric vehicle Tata-Jaguar-Land-Rover should have built. If somebody said this was the new Range Rover Classic it would be exactly what I’d expect. Elevate the roof at the rear end and change the window styling for the 3rd row of seats and it would be a new Discovery.

Put the spare tire on the hood, extend the wheelbase, and call it a Defender.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by chewyland on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @09:36AM (#19153363)
I'm surprised it even has a spare. Really surprised.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by cptskippy on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @10:10AM (#19153620)
Why? To me this truck is like the Mercedes G Class, it isn't meant to be practical or realistic. It's a status symbol meant to perpetuate an image. It has to meet all of the expectations one would have of a pickup truck even though it will never be used like one.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by jschwartzi on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @12:10PM (#19154594)
I would use the shit out of this thing as a pickup truck. It meets all my needs for something I can drive to a trailhead fully loaded with other hikers.
Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by yellowapple on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @02:09PM (#19155739)
And it meets all of my needs hauling stuff around on less-than-ideal road conditions (or no road at all). It's expensive and fancy-looking, but it still looks to be quite usable.

My issues with it boil down more to the exclusively-touchscreen interface (it's the exact opposite of what I want to use while driving) and the high pricetag compared to, say, a Tacoma.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by cptskippy on Thursday February 14, 2019 @04:12PM (#19166077)
Price is really the sticking point as far as I can tell. They're pricing a little over 2x what most people spend on trucks and I wouldn't at all be surprised if that price went up another 50% before it's actually for sale.

It's going to be limited audience at first, unless batteries come down in price significantly. So I can understand all the design decisions to appeal to a high end market but ... idk.

I definitely agree with you about the touch interfaces. The Model 3 needs more buttons.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by cptskippy on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @01:05PM (#19155076)
I'm not saying there isn't a market for electric trucks, I'm just saying that few people are in the market for an electric pickup truck in the $100k+ price range for off-roading.

Judging by the specs on these things, I'd honestly be surprised if they could produce these for less than $125k.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by yellowapple on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @02:13PM (#19155778)
Apparently the target starting price (for baseline) is at the mid-80k range for the large battery model and closer to 60k for the medium and small battery models: https://www.motortrend.com/news/2020-rivian-r1t-ev-first-loo...

That might very well be ambitious, though, and even if they do meet those targets, that's still considerably more expensive than a Tacoma.

Re:Amazon, GM in talks to invest in electric pickup truck ma... by cptskippy on Thursday February 14, 2019 @12:25PM (#19163742)
I would really be surprised if they could meet that price point without making serious compromises in other areas. The battery pack cost alone is going to be a large percentage of total cost.