News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by holdenc on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @03:13AM (#1913423)
Perhaps the government did avert a short-term disaster. But it's unremarkable that they distributed billions to companies who effectively held taxpayers hostage, threatening "if we go down, you go down with us." There was no way to not give out money without incurring intolerable short-term pain.

I'll write a thank you letter to the government when the future of our nation isn't tied to the bad judgement of a few irresponsible companies.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by pedrocr on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @03:30AM (#1913459)
> There was no way to not give out money without incurring intolerable short-term pain.

Sure there was:

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/23/business/worldbusiness/23k...

The Swedes actually solved this by nationalizing all the failing banks, wiping out the equity holders, restructuring and privatizing again. It ended up not costing much. In the US a bunch of bankers got huge bailout funded bonuses and the banks are far from solvent even now.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by marcamillion on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:17AM (#1913719)
`Sweden spent 4 percent of its gross domestic product, or 65 billion kronor, the equivalent of $11.7 billion at the time, or $18.3 billion in today’s dollars, to rescue ailing banks. `

Hrmm...so let's see...4% of $14.14T = $565B.

TARP alone was 700B - i.e. approximately 5% and that seems to not have been enough - because the Fed spent an additional $1.4T.

How much more money did you want the US to spend? Obviously if it was as simple as nationalizing every single bank, they would have done that. But the US banking industry is much more complicated than any other country - much less Sweden's (with all due respect).

To whit, so far this year the FDIC has 'nationalized' more banks than they did 2009.

https://www.fdic.gov/bank/individual/failed/banklist.html

So they are kinda doing what you suggest, but just to show you how difficult such a task really is, they are still winding them down almost 2 years later.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by pedrocr on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:33AM (#1913747)
>How much more money did you want the US to spend? Obviously if it was as simple as nationalizing every single bank, they would have done that. But the US banking industry is much more complicated than any other country - much less Sweden's (with all due respect).

If the banks had not been bailed out by TARP they could have been nationalized cheaply, restructured and relaunched. The equity holders would have been wiped out, as they should have been since their banks were broke, and the employees at these banks would not have extracted even more obscene amounts of money. By now you'd have functional banks driving the economy again. The amount of money isn't the issue here, it's the fact that it was used to prop up a failed system instead of used to restructure it.

>To whit, so far this year the FDIC has 'nationalized' more banks than they did 2009.

All of these banks are the small insignificant ones. None of the big ones have been restructured and most are still technically insolvent.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by marcamillion on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @02:39PM (#1915420)
TARP was a form of nationalization. It wasn't complete nationalization in EVERY case, but the government did buy bank common & preferred stocks. In AIG's case, they bought 80% of all outstanding stock - essentially nationalizing them.

Everybody else, it was pittances - a few % here and there.

So that goes to show the amount of money needed. If they spent so much money and only got a few % of each bank, how much more money would be needed to purchase the entire banks altogether.

Not all of the banks the FDIC has nationalized are insignificant ones. It started with IndyMac which is no small bank.

The notion that the banks are still technically insolvent - says who? I think the markets are the best indicator as to the health of the banks. As far as I can see, their bond spreads over Treasuries have fallen significantly in the last few months and their stocks have been rallying.

So are you telling me that the markets (who are extremely sophisticated and thoroughly understand the banking industry) are being fooled by these banks?

I hardly think so.

BOA is up from it's low of $3, to $11.70. Citigroup (the most damaged of them all) is up to $4.17 from a low of $1.xx - the gov't owns the biggest stake in Citi than most other banks.

Yes, their prices aren't as high as it used to be, but these things take time.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by pedrocr on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:39PM (#1916048)
>So that goes to show the amount of money needed. If they spent so much money and only got a few % of each bank, how much more money would be needed to purchase the entire banks altogether.

The banks were propped up by TARP and so their market value remained high. Without it they were probably all insolvent and so the cost of owning them would be basically zero. Otherwise the market would have been able to finance the banks.

TARP was designed to feed money into banks in a very cheap way, the size of the wealth transfer from the taxpayer to Wall Street is staggering. Buffet himself got much better conditions than the Federal Government.

>The notion that the banks are still technically insolvent - says who? I think the markets are the best indicator as to the health of the banks. As far as I can see, their bond spreads over Treasuries have fallen significantly in the last few months and their stocks have been rallying.

There is now a quite explicit assumption that the federal government won't let the banks fail. With that and the Fed helping there's plenty of reason to think banks will continue to make money. That doesn't mean the crap on (and off) their balance sheets has stopped being crap.

>So are you telling me that the markets (who are extremely sophisticated and thoroughly understand the banking industry) are being fooled by these banks?

I'm saying the markets are now useless to value the banks because the value being judged includes the federal government as a crutch. There is no market pricing for the value of the banks on their own.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by cynicalkane on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @10:38AM (#1914534)
The fed did not "spend" anything. There are three things to remember here:

* The Fed creates money

* The money supply has shrunk greatly, so the Fed needs to create money anyway

* The money is not given out, but traded for Treasury securities

Saying the Fed spent money on banks suggests a fundamental ignorance on how these things work. If anything, the Fed spent money of the government, but that viewpoint is not accurate either, only less ignorant.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by marcamillion on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @02:31PM (#1915397)
Hrmm...so when the Fed creates money, is it not 'spent' ? Yes. Why? Because there is a bill somewhere. It might be directly on the taxpayer like when the Treasury spends it, but it is on everybody else that holds and uses US Dollar assets - by way of inflation. So yes, they did "spend".

The money was technically given out - because they essentially purchased securities (not just Treasuries, but commercial paper, Mortgaged Backed paper, Gold, etc.) at significant losses to themselves in the short term - so that the banks can shore up their balance sheets.

My broader point was that the US Treasury could spend only $700B, because the Fed was there to further capitalize the banks. If you want to go ahead and be a grammar natzi, then feel free. But at the end of the day, the financial institutions were given approx $2.5T cash - in exchange for a variety of things (some securities on their balance sheets, to warrants for their own common & preferred stocks).

Although the Fed can create money out of thin air, the notion that it isn't spent (i.e. it has no cost to anyone) is a misguided notion because it typically has a greater cost to everyone than the Treasury doing so.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by nl on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @04:57AM (#1913678)
But they had one incredibly useful attribute that the US government didn't have: time.

They had time to extracted pounds of flesh from bank shareholders before writing checks, time to design policies to force banks to write down losses and issue warrants to the government

2008 was different. After Lehman collapsed, the government had to make it's initial intervention overnight, and the full package took weeks to put together, not months.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by pedrocr on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:26AM (#1913733)
>2008 was different. After Lehman collapsed, the government had to make it's initial intervention overnight, and the full package took weeks to put together, not months.

Looking this up in Wikipedia it seems the crisis started in early 2007 and Lehman collapsed in September 2008. So there was a year and a half to plan a response.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subprime_mortgage_crisis#Financ...

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by nl on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:47AM (#1913778)
Yes and no.

Yes, there were plenty of signs of the sub-prime crisis.

However, no one expected it to cause an investment bank like Lehman to collapse. It wasn't until the day of the crash that the people begun to dig into how the mortgages had been repackaged and sold, and it still wasn't widely know how badly the ratings agencies had failed in their analysis of this.

(Ok, so it seems likely that Goldman had a fair idea and possibly went short Bear Sterns based on their exposure, but they weren't exactly spreading that information around)

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by bradshaw1965 on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @08:49AM (#1914154)
Right, the famous Subprime Mortgage Problems Contained...

http://archive.newsmax.com/archives/ic/2007/3/28/110709.shtm...

March, 2007

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by borism on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:23AM (#1913727)
There were 7 months between Bear Stearns (Feb '08) and Lehman (Sep '08) events, and things started to go downhill long before that - August 2007 in particular was the turning point.

Many in the US were simply asleep at the wheel, both in government and private sector.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by arethuza on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:13AM (#1913712)
The UK government ended up effectively nationalizing monsters like RBS - which as far as I can see has been one big "Get out of Jail Free" card for the relevant organizations and their directors.
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by pedrocr on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:35AM (#1913753)
Seems like the "restructure" bit is missing
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by asmithmd1 on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @10:47AM (#1914568)
What I don't understand is why they didn't break-up any banks that were "too big to fail" into pieces that were small enough to fail. Instead they did the exact opposite, arranging shotgun marriages for failing institutions so they are now part of a bank that is too big to fail.

The Justice dept. has very successfully broken apart companies in the past: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_System_divestiture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Oil#Breakup

No government ownership is involved; one day you own 1 share of AT&T and the next day you own 1 share of the new AT&T and 1 share of each of the new baby bells.

I would argue the AT&T break-up allowed the first internet boom to happen. Can you imagine how hard it would have been to get a T1 provisioned if there had been no competition AND AT&T was offering a service just like what you were trying to start

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by Benjo on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @12:02PM (#1914826)
You mean during the crises? Would that have helped? How would you allocate the troubled assets to the baby banks?

If you put them all in one place, that bank would fail and still cause the same chain reaction, except the debt would fail entirely on the customers of the bank instead of the bank itself.

If you spread out the assets, then you'd just have lots of smaller banks fail instead of the larger bank. I suppose doing this could have spread the failures out over time.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by asmithmd1 on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @02:06PM (#1915304)
By all means put out the fire by doing what they did in the moment. But then respond not by passing ineffectual legislation that will surely be gamed and circumvented but with stress testing the banks to see which ones are too big too fail and breaking them up until they are small enough to fail.

As to who gets the "toxic" assets, who cares? They are all but worthless. Auction them off to whoever will buy them that way we no longer have this fiction that they will ever be worth anything. The US tax payer is now explicitly on the hook for these assets. The sooner we know what they are truly worth the better.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by Benjo on Thursday November 18, 2010 @12:57PM (#1918634)
Yes, I'm not sure why the government chose not to do this. My guess is that the large companies effectively have too much influence over reelection of congressmen to allow anything like this.

The government seems to have chosen instead to increase their power in handling these crises.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by guelo on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:23AM (#1913728)
Most of the $700 billion TARP money was recovered, the costs are only going to be about $30 billion which is a bargain for what it achieved. http://finance.yahoo.com/banking-budgeting/article/110920/ex...
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by JesseAldridge on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @03:44AM (#1913496)
> I'll write a thank you letter to the government when the future of our nation isn't tied to the bad judgement of a few irresponsible companies.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obama_financial_regulatory_refo...

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by marcamillion on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:07AM (#1913699)
That's the vagaries of capitalism. Can't have your cake and eat it.

Once you believe in Capitalism, there will always be systemically important companies - whether it is Google, Amazon, etc. or Banks - that should something go wrong with them will require a bailout of some nature.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by arethuza on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:17AM (#1913718)
I'm all for capitalism, but if there are companies which fall into the "too big to fail" camp I want them split up and/or their management put on special notice that if the companies do fail then the taxpayers will be coming after the assets of the the executives should the company fail.

NB I really don't think that applies to Google or Amazon.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by marcamillion on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:24AM (#1913729)
If Google went down...literally overnight, thousands if not hundreds of thousands of small businesses that rely on AdSense to pay their bills would be in serious hot water.

Not to mention those companies that rely on Adwords to drive traffic through their doors (both online and offline).

I can almost assure you that the markets would get very jittery and irrationality would likely spread to all sorts of other industries.

It is easy to take these things for granted.

Amazon is the same. There are thousands of mini-retailers that earn a living on Amazon. Amazon might even be more so - the equivalent of a Walmart going down....but almost worst.

At it's extremes, the beauties of capitalism lead to large firms that build ecosystems to entrench their positions - whose failure would be significant and potentially systemically dangerous. It is the nature of capitalism - it actually is very healthy for the system. Over time they eventually fade out and other large companies come and take it's place - e.g. the newspaper industry, telecom, etc. So you can't really escape it.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by Symmetry on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @10:01AM (#1914414)
Generally when a company fails it goes into bankrupcy, where the process is designed to keep the business functioning while things proceed. So even if Amazon or Google declared bankruptcy tomorrow Adsense and Amazon Marketplace would go on. The people who would be in trouble would be the people who Google owed money to, which was very much the concern with Lehman Brothers.
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by marcamillion on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @02:45PM (#1915439)
I would generally agree if we never just went through a major crisis and saw the failings of current processes. One of the things that was made explicitly clear, is that for some firms that are too large, the bankruptcy proceedings don't really work like they should.

I do think, however, that if Google or Amazon failed there are some elements that would stay up - but it's more than just those elements.

It's the little things, like email for 200million people disappearing overnight. I can't even imagine the amounts of things that would be lost (receipts from sales, tax information, customer data, invoices, legal contracts, etc.). Much less just a major communication channel going dark. That alone would cause a dip in GDP (in my opinion).

Might be difficult to foresee, but so was the banking crisis.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by Symmetry on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @03:00PM (#1915493)
Where did we see failing of the current process? Not the financial system, which obviously failed, but the bankruptcy process. I'm not aware of any company suddenly closing up shop during the crisis. We didn't use follow the normal rules with the automakers but that was because it would have been bad politically for the UAW to lose their pensions, rather than out of any inability of bankruptcy to keep the automakers going in some form. If you have specific examples of things suddenly shutting down during the crisis apart from debt repayments or people being less willing to spend money, I'd be really interested in hearing it.
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by jbooth on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @08:46AM (#1914148)
And we have regulations to prevent things like that. Sarbox, for all the bitching about it, does a reasonably good job of insuring that Google won't just fail overnight and shock everyone -- makes it much harder for them to cook the books and stop people from seeing it a year out.

Of course, the libertarian purists argue that we shouldn't have sarbox and shouldn't bail companies out -- which makes me think that if they were in charge the last few years, my electricity wouldn't be working by now.

Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by Bitmobrich on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @10:09AM (#1914442)
If a Business fails because AdSense, Amazon.com, or others are shutdown, than it was that Businesses fault in not diversifying their revenue streams.
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by arethuza on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @06:09AM (#1913827)
No doubt that would be really bad - don't get me wrong - but it's not quite at the scale of what almost happened in 2008.
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by RtodaAV on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @03:17AM (#1913432)
They should have saved Lehman Brothers.
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by cdavid on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @04:13AM (#1913572)
Why the downvote ? I believe it is pretty much agreed on that letting lehman brothers fall was a mistake - of course, saying it afterwards is easy.
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by thasmin on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @11:07AM (#1914651)
Where can I find details about this?
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by cdavid on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @08:49PM (#1916509)
I read mostly on French ecoblogs, but in English:

  - http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2008/09/a-very-large-in.html
  - http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/12/business/12nocera.html?_r=1&hp
You can find much more if you look a bit. I think outside the libertarian on the fringe, most people agreed the decision was certainly not obvious to make at that time. I am sure it will take time before academics agree (if ever:) )on whether this was a mistake or not.
Re:Warren Buffett: Pretty Good for Government Work by borism on Wednesday November 17, 2010 @05:28AM (#1913737)
because this is not particularly popular opinion in extremely libertarian tech circles, no matter what people more knowledgeable about those things say.