On the counting side though, I don't fully agree. Paper voting sees some enormous mistakes. Whether they are intentional or not, but it has happened before where an entire town's votes for a candidate missed a zero. No election observers or people sent from either party noticed it until a volunteer pointed it out. Electronic voting isn't going to make such mistakes and I believe that if the process is handled well, then the secrecy of the vote shouldn't be an issue from the server side.
But again, there's nothing you can do about the client side attack vector.
Who has the skill to be able to assess such a system ? And among those, who has the time ?
I've been a programmer for 15 years and I'm pretty sure I would not be able to look at such a system and feel confident there is no error. And definitly not in the reasonable time period required for voting.
I believe the parent's example was to show that it was missed by the system that was intended to catch it. That the catch in itself was a fluke, lucky.
It should bring into question "How many times have we missed and not caught it?" not "Well it worked this time, it must always work." In fact, we can only recognize cases if we catch them. Therefore it is confirmation bias to use this example as a "proof of it working". It can only serve as an example of "We have caught failures in the system" and suggest that we should be wary of others existing (neither proving nor disproving fault in the system).
In electronic voting, you just have to trust the machine to do it right. There are multiple layers of manipulation available that are hard to detect. Sure, the bar is higher, but so are the opportunities for doctoring by the involved actors. What are the watchers to do? They simply can't watch the ballot box when it's inside a machine where no single human can fully understand its machinations.
There is an out. If no single person can prove their vote but people in aggregate can.
If a voting platform has such a trail, what becomes of ballot secrecy? And if it doesn't, how will the process be reliably audited?
I'm sure a simple, transparent, and bullet-proof blockchain solution is just around the corner. /s
There was this interesting talk years ago. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZDnShu5V99s
Does anyone in the space have a more up to date reference on where things are at ?
Contrast this with a box where you can watch the pieces of paper as they are put inside. And as they are taken out again. As long as you can watch the box, you can can verify the process.
Further, vote privacy is threatened at the client side. The fact that they specifically exclude client vulnerabilities is telling: "... known and accepted characteristics of the system will however not be accepted. Such “issues” include: Any operation compromising the vote privacy on the client-side (e.g. browser extension);" They even met "issues" in quotes, even tough these are a common attack vector. They are real and dangerous.
It's common in Switzerland to vote by mail, so there's the possibility that people get pressured into voting in a certain way by their relatives. But the scale is very different when people must expose their voting preferences to a machine they already know watches them.