News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms?

Responding to an old thread by @tboyd47 on May 1, 2017: Yes, I have long arms and most desk/keyboard setups don't work for me because my elbows are nearly at my hips. In regards to armrests, I recieved an ergonomic assessment through my employer and found out that it's better not to have them at all. I've solved the issue of "parallel arms" by making sure that I have a sliding keyboard tray mounted under my desk that nearly sits my lap. I've also gotten a standing desk, and but have to move my keyboard into the lower tray when I transition to sitting. Anyone else out there with "long arm" issues?
( 14 comments | 16 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by tboyd47 on Thursday February 07, 2019 @08:33PM (#19110566)
Wow, I can't believe you took the time to reply to a question of mine from two years ago!

Ultimately I ended up with the same solution. The keyboard tray under the desk made a huge difference. You have to sit as if you're riding on horseback to really make that work.

Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by SenHeng on Friday February 08, 2019 @06:34AM (#19113285)
> You have to sit as if you're riding on horseback to really make that work

Well then, we have JUST the thing for you here in Japan, a rodeo dieting machine!

https://www.amazon.co.jp/gp/product/B073QGLP1F/

Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by tboyd47 on Friday February 08, 2019 @11:59AM (#19116186)
That looks funny, but really you'll want something like this drafting stool:

https://images.globalindustrial.com/images/275x275/NOS_B1691...

Notice the height and the circular foot bar around the base. Hooking your feet underneath the seat pushes your center of gravity under your trunk, allowing you to sit in a balanced, relaxed posture with a straight back at the edge of your seat (important to prevent your legs from falling asleep).

Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by sethammons on Saturday February 09, 2019 @10:56PM (#19126291)
I got a desk where the table surface is about 24 inches off the ground. I thought I'd have to build one, but found an electronic standing desk that would go low enough. I keep the table as near to my knees height as possible. The desk can raise if wanted for standing. I also remove arm rests or, with my current chair, flip them up.

Edit: oh, also I use the classic Microsoft ergonomic keyboard.

Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by wmf on Thursday February 07, 2019 @10:00PM (#19111147)
I have slightly long arms and I ended up with similar solutions. Now instead of a tray I just lower my desk to almost touch my legs. These days I don't use armrests although at IBM they gave me an ergonomic chair and I pivoted the armrests outward and lowered them so that only my elbows rested on them; this looked strange but it was comfortable.
Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by julesnew on Friday February 08, 2019 @11:38AM (#19115914)
I envy that you have a desk that can go lower!
Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by cimmanom on Thursday February 07, 2019 @09:08PM (#19110811)
If you also have long legs, have you tried raising both your chair and your monitor so you’re sitting higher relative to the desk? (I’m short, so I have the not quite opposite problem of desks being too high when sitting with the chair low enough for feet to be flat on the floor. The solution was a sit-stand desk with a very low minimum height.)
Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by julesnew on Friday February 08, 2019 @11:33AM (#19115846)
I don't have particularly long legs. I usually need a higher chair to have the correct desk height, and then also need a foot rest, lol.
Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by cimmanom on Friday February 08, 2019 @12:00PM (#19116204)
yup, then you don't have long arms, it's just that most desks are too high for computer work unless you're super tall. Can you get a lower desk?
Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by julesnew on Friday February 08, 2019 @12:40PM (#19116683)
Proportionately they are -- my wingspan is a little longer than my height (my physical therpapist calls this my "ape index", ha!). If you look at the typical ergnomic desk setup (like this one: https://airawear.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/1-desk-heigh...) my desk would basically have to be in my lap to be elbow height, which is why I need the hanging keyboard tray. I would love a lower desk, or one that lowers! But not possible right now...
Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by nicolashahn on Friday February 08, 2019 @07:26AM (#19113534)
Try a split keyboard. For me the problem is that my arms come in at a high angle horizontally to meet at the keyboard, and my wrists try to correct. Split the keyboard and you no longer have that constraint.
Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by julesnew on Friday February 08, 2019 @11:18AM (#19115629)
That's actually a good call! I just inherited something that's not quite a split keyboard -- it's one of those "ergonomic" keyboards from a colleague who left, and it basically forces my elbows out so that I can still keep my traps relaxed & wrists straight, even when my keyboard is higher than I would typically have it.
Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by heyjudy on Friday February 08, 2019 @04:37AM (#19112732)
Look into Marfans related and CTDs.

My elbows nearly reach my hips and I cannot use chairs with arms or desks that are "normal" height.

Re:Ask HN: Any programmers with long arms? by julesnew on Friday February 08, 2019 @11:32AM (#19115827)
Interesting...! I have some "hints" of some of these symptoms (including fatigue), but believe I still fall within the normal range. I'm 5'5", and I think my wingspan is slightly over 5'6". Thanks for the awareness.