Re:Affirmation of the Open Source Definition
by wmf on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:43PM
(#19101401)
The term "open source" is not a trademark and at this point it probably cannot be trademarked by anyone. In uncontroversial cases people are happy to let the OSI be the arbiter of open sourceness but in controversial cases people tend to decide that OSI doesn't control the meaning of open source.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Affirmation of the Open Source Definition
by chrisseaton on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:58PM
(#19101519)
That's my point. It isn't a trademark. They should come up with something new that is. 'OSI Approved' would be fine.
Re:Affirmation of the Open Source Definition
by massonpj on Thursday February 07, 2019 @09:25AM
(#19105366)
The term "open source" can not be trademarked (just like Kilogram can not); the mark is too "descriptive." The OSI does have trademarks for "OSI Approved Open Source License", as well of course for its own branding, e.g. the "OSI Keyhole Logo" and the name "Open Source Initiative."
Re:Affirmation of the Open Source Definition
by chrisseaton on Thursday February 07, 2019 @11:38AM
(#19106295)
> The OSI does have trademarks for "OSI Approved Open Source License"
So why don't they encourage people to use that then?
Rather than telling people how to use another exiting term with a debated definition?
Re:Affirmation of the Open Source Definition
by wmf on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:14PM
(#19101659)
Nobody would ever care about new terminology.
Re:Affirmation of the Open Source Definition
by zzzcpan on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:50PM
(#19101454)
OSI actually attempted to trademark "open source" and failed.
Re:Affirmation of the Open Source Definition
by sparkie on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:01PM
(#19101547)
In uncontroversial cases, it is not that people let the OSI be the arbiter, but rather, they have no need to argue with the OSI about the use of the term in those cases because their goals are aligned. The controversial cases make this clear - many people do not see the OSI as the authority on the term, and never have.