News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Startup with no website - [email protected] by ReadyPlayerNone on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @09:37AM (#19095337)
Interesting, I've a few questions as food for thought.

- Is it allowed under GMail's TOS?

- Have you considered the security implications of having what is presumably a server somewhere in your name clicking on any link that's sent to it?

- You say startup - do you have monetization plans? Putting adverts on the associated website perhaps?

Re:Show HN: Startup with no website - [email protected] by dkoston on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @10:09AM (#19095618)
Google TOS is pretty broad. However, one of the main factors here is that export controls could quickly come into play. Since Google is US-based, providing this service for those in embargoed countries could get you shut down quickly.

They also have a "don't misuse our services" clause and I'm sure this would count as misuse if found.

Re:Show HN: Startup with no website - [email protected] by spdebbarma on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @12:43PM (#19097526)
Someone who works for GMail or Google has already read this HN post. I don't expect it to work for much longer unless OP has found a loophole.
Re:Show HN: Startup with no website - [email protected] by imhoguy on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @05:07PM (#19100587)
> providing this service for those in embargoed countries could get you shut down quickly.

How come Google can figure out who and where the interested end-user is when emails are actually send by web apps and clicking is done upon email retrieval (I bet some cron with POP3). Moreover emails from "bad" countries are rather filtered out as spam/scam.

Apart of this thread publicly inviting people it may be also hard to distingush the accout from any busy one. But I guess G may have some pattern matching and rate limits for such sinks.

Re:Show HN: Startup with no website - [email protected] by simonebrunozzi on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @10:36PM (#19102789)
Let me answer this: from what I know, and broadly speaking, this service is both illegal and not allowed by ToS.
Re:Show HN: Startup with no website - [email protected] by jake_the_third on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @11:32PM (#19103015)
> this service is both illegal

.. in your country. Saying something is illegal without mentioning jurisdiction is meaningless.

> not allowed by ToS

The service being signed up to, perhaps. But it isn't clear to me that it's banned by gmail's tos especially since he's using the service APIs normally.

Re:Show HN: Startup with no website - [email protected] by macspoofing on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @01:46PM (#19098272)
>Is it allowed under GMail's TOS?

Do you even have to ask? The answer is a clear 'NO'. There is zero chance that Google will allow you to abuse their email service in this way.

I hope OPs personal account isn't in anyway related to this account because when 'guerillclick@gmail' is inevitably banned, his personal account may be collateral damage.

Re:Show HN: Startup with no website - [email protected] by eralpb on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @03:18PM (#19099396)
you make a very good point, thanks for the warning.