News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by dwheeler on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:09PM (#19080136)
Mostly sortof true, but there are lots of complications.

I've delved into this. For lots of detail on the current situation, see my paper, "Publicly Releasing Open Source Software Developed for the U.S. Government" by David A. Wheeler, https://www.csiac.org/journal-article/publicly-releasing-ope...

In almost all cases, if a US Federal employee writes software as part of his/her official duties, then there is no copyright IN THE UNITED STATES. There are a few exceptions (e.g., US Post Service Employees). Also, copyright doesn't apply in the US - but outside is a different matter (though enforcing said copyright is more complicated, and I would argue the US shouldn't try). More importantly, there may not be a copyright, but that doesn't guarantee release to the public (and often there isn't). You can ask via a FOIA, but that's no guarantee you'll get it.

HOWEVER: Most software developed by government funds is developed, at least in part, by contractors. And that is a COMPLETELY different circumstance. The details, unsurprisingly, depend on the contract.

If you're interested in the DoD, I suggest going to the MIL-OSS mailing list: https://groups.google.com/forum/#!forum/mil-oss

It's possible to release software to the public. One approach is to get pre-approval where "as long as the changes meet this scope, and follow these rules, it's okay to post the changes." But you have to get local buy-in.

In short: In a lot of places in the US federal government it's definitely difficult to do what in the rest of the world is normal.

In the US, state/local/tribal is completely different, and I definitely don't claim to know the laws of other countries. Others can explain that better.

Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by prepend on Monday February 04, 2019 @07:32PM (#19082062)
The most common clause for it contracts that produce software is called “Rights in Data - General” [0] and by default, without alternatives explicitly stated, it allows the government to distribute in an unlimited manner anything created by the contractor.

So the good news is that any government contractor overseeing a contract should be able to release it as OSS, if ve wants. Bad news is that it’s effort and risk to do it correctly.

[0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/48/52.227-14

Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by pbhjpbhj on Monday February 04, 2019 @05:50PM (#19081461)
>Most software developed by government funds is developed, at least in part, by contractors. And that is a COMPLETELY different circumstance. The details, unsurprisingly, depend on the contract. //

Isn't the point that the contact should have a non-negotiable OSS clause of it's using public funds.

My impression, from my seat in Europe, is that USA government is run by rich capitalists that would as soon eat faeces live on TV as suggest private corporations be required to service the public good?

Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by da_chicken on Monday February 04, 2019 @09:43PM (#19082678)
> Isn't the point that the contact should have a non-negotiable OSS clause of it's using public funds.

Okay. Say you're a vendor for student information systems. It handles registration, enrollment, scheduling, attendance, report cards, state and federal reporting, teacher gradebooks, parent portal, etc. You sell your product to one school district with 800 students for an initial fee of $100,000 plus an annual fee of $5 per student and $10,000 for up to X hours of direct support (note: these numbers are not far off the actual costs).

Except now it's open source, and every one of the hundreds of thousands of school districts in the country suddenly has access to your software without charge.

Sure, you can come up with dozens of reasons why that's great for schools, but you're the SIS vendor that just spent a couple million dollars producing the software. Why would you be in a business where the moment you sell your product, you can no longer sell your product? Support? Okay, but you'll immediately be competing with other support vendors, etc.

Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by gizmo686 on Monday February 04, 2019 @10:10PM (#19082766)
What does it mean to be funded "with public money". In your example, it sounds like the software was funded with private money then sold as a product to the schools.

The relevant scenario is that the school approached the company and paid them to develop the software.

Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by da_chicken on Monday February 04, 2019 @10:22PM (#19082813)
That's a fair point. I hadn't thought of it that way, it's just what I went to because it's what I'm used to thinking in terms of.
Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by gizmo686 on Monday February 04, 2019 @10:51PM (#19082905)
Its still not as clear cut as I make it sound.

Another potential model is for the government to partially fund development. For instance, if the government wants a piece of software that costs $1,000,000 to develop, a company might offer to develop it for them for $500,000 and the rights to resale it to other customers.

This isn't an intractable problem though. You would just need to make a clear delimination between what components the government is paying for, and which ones is coming out of the company's R&D budget. Due to billing, this is already how many of these projects work, but the publicly funded portion is often far less useful without the privately funded portion; and there often is not a good solution to this (think a government funded plugin to Microsoft Excel, where an Excel license costs $5,000)

Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by Godel_unicode on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @12:39AM (#19083212)
You should Google redhat.

Edit: or elastic. Or automattic. Or black duck, or canonical, or cloud bees...

Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by dragonwriter on Monday February 04, 2019 @06:01PM (#19081555)
> My impression, from my seat in Europe, is that USA government is run by rich capitalists that would as soon eat faeces live on TV as suggest private corporations be required to service the public good?

Not quite true. Rich capitalists largely have better things to do than bother with the details of running government.

But it is, to a large extent, run by people under the influence of (whether directly seeking money, or just manipulated by paid propaganda) rich capitalists who would rather engage in public coprophagia than have such requirements imposed.

Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by anth_anm on Monday February 04, 2019 @06:36PM (#19081768)
They don't care about what the government does, subject to the bounds of "don't touch my money".

The ones who do care more than that tend to be absolutely awful.

Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by Godel_unicode on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @12:50AM (#19083251)
Like Tesla? Or Patagonia, or REI, or allbirds, or bullfrog power, or seventh generation?
Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by anth_anm on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @12:59PM (#19087728)
Like Mercer, who buys up local news outlets to push his propaganda.
Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by killjoywashere on Monday February 04, 2019 @07:49PM (#19082198)
This DoD CyberSecurity Policy Chart in the sidebar is epic: https://dodiac.dtic.mil/dod-cybersecurity-policy-chart/

Clearly, they don't want new ideas.

Re:If Software Is Funded from a Public Source, Its Code Shou... by spydum on Monday February 04, 2019 @08:22PM (#19082351)
I think they just try to idiot proof too much, which ends up a bureaucratic nightmare.