News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by thomasfl on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:06AM (#19068732)
I cant't see how this experiment is set up, can give any answers to what effects general basic income has on the society. A selection of only 2000 people seems too small. 560 USD a month is not enough to get by in scandinavia either. If an experiment is going to prove that society wont't get ruined by general basic income, then an experiment has to be done on a much greater scale than this.
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by raptorraver on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:26AM (#19068807)
Finnish here. On top of that 560 people got support for their rent expenses. Depending on the amount of rent one could get more than 1000€ per month. It’s not much but you can get by with it. What went wrong with the experiment was that it included only people who were registered as unemoloyed so we don’t know how it would have affected home moms, entrepreneuers, students etc.
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by 13415 on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:41AM (#19070140)
It's hard for me to understand why this called a "basic income" experiment then.

The central idea of basic income is that you get one fixed amount of income per month that needs to be sufficient for all expenses, including rent, and everybody gets the same sufficient amount of money no matter what he or she uses it for and no matter whether the person works or not. I'm writing "sufficient amount", because it is obvious that a basic income experiment that doesn't allow people to get by without working would not be basic income either, but a subsidy to the salary, as they already exist in many social welfare systems.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by zozbot123 on Sunday February 03, 2019 @11:04AM (#19070310)
> I'm writing "sufficient amount", because it is obvious that a basic income experiment that doesn't allow people to get by without working would not be basic income either, but a subsidy to the salary, as they already exist in many social welfare systems.

This is not "obvious" at all, and there's no reason why we couldn't start meeting people halfway, in a sense. Realistically, no amount of BI would allow people to "get by" in a highly-desirable urban location like SF or the Valley. It would probably be priced for areas with a more manageable cost of living, and even there most folks would be supplementing it with at least part-time or "gig" work.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by GuB-42 on Sunday February 03, 2019 @11:41AM (#19070542)
> Realistically, no amount of BI would allow people to "get by" in a highly-desirable urban location.

Isn't it part of the idea for a UBI?

If you can't live where it is expensive, go find a better job or move out.

UBI, at least my idea of it is far from easy, it is something to ensure your survival, but if you want confort, and choosing where you want to live is part of it, then you need to work. There is only so much money that can be allocated do welfare, and you can't give more to some people without taking it from others.

It means that if you are already living on subsidies, chances are that your situation is going to get worse with UBI. OTOH, part timers in poor areas will be much better off since they will get full UBI + pay with low expenses.

Maybe that's why UBI doesn't work. Not because it is an incitation to do nothing, but because it may be devastating to families who already live on subsidies. And if we don't remove existing subsidies, then there isn't enough money.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by 13415 on Sunday February 03, 2019 @12:32PM (#19070902)
I kind of agree. A very low UBI that barely allows people to subsist will not solve any existing social problems, it might instead effectively become a subsidy for extremely low income classes without increasing vertical social mobility, and therefore in the long run further increase the gap between the poor and the rich that has been increasing since WW2.

Personally, I believe that the best way to decrease social tensions and prevent a dystopian impoverishment of the majority of the population is to lower the gap between the rich and the poor and to limit the amount of wealth that can be transmitted by heritage, for example with a Skandinavian tax and welfare model and by putting a strict upper bound on the amount of assets and resources that can be inherited.

It seems to me that UBI can only work as intended if it was fairly high, and that is perhaps not realistic for political and economic reasons.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by phamilton on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:53AM (#19070232)
If rent was covered, 560€/month is plenty. I lived in Sweden on 1500 kr/month (after rent and a public transportation pass) and that was fine.
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by denzil_correa on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:45AM (#19070175)
> A selection of only 2000 people seems too small

The population of Finland is 5.503M. A sample size of 663 represents 6M population at 99% confidence levels. 2000 is more than a decent sample size. You may argue for the sample quality but the size seems beyond question here.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by alkonaut on Sunday February 03, 2019 @12:04PM (#19070706)
It’s not about sample quality or size - it’s about the behavior of a group when condition change, but the conditions didn’t change. For example, under a proper UBI I’d quit my job and start a business. Under this time limited experiment I never would have. In a proper UBI environment I might scale down my living to fit in only the UBI so I won’t be dependent on a job. Under a 2 year experiment I don’t.

There are some minor effects that don’t need universal+indefinite basic income to show up, but tbh those aren’t very interesting.

It would have been a more interesting experiment to fund just 100 people for life, with the same money, even though that sample would have been smaller! But even with say 10k people funded for life, you wouldn’t see the most important effects on the job market, prices, rents...

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by improbable22 on Sunday February 03, 2019 @12:47PM (#19071007)
> more interesting experiment to fund just 100 people for life

Are there any good natural experiments like this?

Some lottery winners take the annuity, maybe that is close? (Although they are selected both to play the lottery, and to have the sense not to immediately buy a ferrari.)

Some places have pretty generous disability pay, I wonder if people who just got it or just didn't might be a useful experiment?

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by banthar on Sunday February 03, 2019 @12:55PM (#19071064)
> For example, under a proper UBI I’d quit my job and start a business. Under this time limited experiment I never would have.

What business would you start that takes more than 2 years to validate but takes basically no funding?

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by alkonaut on Sunday February 03, 2019 @01:04PM (#19071124)
With UBI I’d be happy if my new business made 50% the money I need for my lifestyle because the UBI could provide the rest. I’m confident I could start a business that does that. But what it would validate would be that the business would not be sustainable when the UBI disappears.

So by “business” I mean a UBI subsidized hobby, basically.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by wongarsu on Sunday February 03, 2019 @11:41AM (#19070538)
I agree that the other critizism are much worse (too little money for a too short time).

But while a sample size of 2000 is statistically enough, a study this small can't find the effects of giving a basic income to an entire country. Giving income to one person changes that person, giving income to everyone changes the entire economy.

For an initial experiment this is actually fine. You first want to check that the effect on the individual is beneficial and people don't just stop contributing to society. But to draw useful conclusions you would need a second experiment that gives basic income at least to an entire community, preferably even an entire region, for a duration that allows people to forget about the "after".

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by cf498 on Sunday February 03, 2019 @11:48AM (#19070595)
>For an initial experiment this is actually fine. You first want to check that the effect on the individual is beneficial and people don't just stop contributing to society.

Is it though? With the knowledge that it will be over in 2 years you get a different sort of behavior then if it actually functioned as a guaranteed support net.

I would have found it much more interesting, if it supported people 10 year from retirement for those 10 years. They could just stop everything and dont have to care for after the project ends.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by justaguyhere on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:08AM (#19068738)
That is true, but they gotta start somewhere! Isn't it okay to start small and repeat it a few times, incorporating learnings from the previous round?
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by function_seven on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:24AM (#19068796)
It might not actually be okay. Quantity has a quality all its own. Whatever learnings produced from a small scale study may not actually apply to a large scale implementation. It’s possible you could “learn” the wrong lessons.

A couple problems with these basic income experiments are that the participants know they are receiving their money for a limited time, which does not allow them to change their economic participation in meaningful ways. There is also the network effects to be considered. When only a tiny subset of the population is receiving basic income, the effects that you would like to study can’t be observed.

I don’t know how those two issues can be controlled for. Basic Income seems like a system where you just have to dive in a cross your fingers.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by daenz on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:33AM (#19070090)
>Basic Income seems like a system where you just have to dive in a cross your fingers.

You do understand why people want to start small right? Because if the experiment fails on a large scale, the results are catastrophic to society. In my opinion, proponents of UBI had better find a way to conduct the experiment in a meaningful way on a smaller scale first if they expect to convince any rational person that it's worth pursuing on a larger scale. This idea of "well let's fundamentally change society in an irreversible way and hope it all works out" is absolutely a non-starter for me.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by zanny on Sunday February 03, 2019 @12:01PM (#19070690)
Its not irreversible. Just like you can start UBI whenever you want you can technically stop it too.

Yea, people would modify their behavior to account for it and thus just eliminating it outright would cause a lot of transitional pains, but thats no different than if western governments tried eliminating retirement income, subsidized / free medicine, public infrastructure upkeep, etc.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by function_seven on Sunday February 03, 2019 @02:41PM (#19071712)
Yeah, I do realize that and I agree with you. It may be the best idea ever, or an economic disaster. I don’t see how micro studies can figure out which.
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by mbfg on Sunday February 03, 2019 @09:14AM (#19069641)
Fantastic point. These people were focused on getting a job, any job, so that when the 2 year period was over, they could survive. Which of course is a good thing, but really won't produce what the idealistic goals of basic income are. I doubt (m)any of the participants sat down and thought, now that i can survive forever, what can i do to change my life, build a company, chase a great idea, do something special.
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by justaguyhere on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:30AM (#19068821)
Fair enough. It is then a tough balancing act between the amount of resources (money especially) available for such experiments and the desired size of them to be actually useful. Finland is very small and very homogeneous, so it reduces the number of variables they need to think about. And they are rich enough to afford such experiments.

Must be fun for those working on the such problems :)

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by boomboomsubban on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:20AM (#19068780)
Doing such a small scale trial prevents any of the impact UBI would have on the job market, so anything learned may not be relevant. Removing 2000 people from the job market doesn't mean much.
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by duchenne on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:39AM (#19068855)
If you want a bigger scale experiment, you could have a look at the French RMI/RSA, it is not exactly a basic income, because it is given only to unemployed people. But, it is 550 euros/months, it has existed since 1988, and it is given under very loose conditions. It is now given to more than a million people. People that have recently lost their jobs receive another bigger help.

It is unclear what is the outcome. Some people will say that it is helping poor people, others will say that it demotivates people to find a job and is contributing to French high unemployment rate. It is really unclear.

edit: To receive RMI/RSA, one also need to be looking for a job, but it is not really enforced.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revenu_minimum_d%27insertion

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by bergerjac on Sunday February 03, 2019 @09:22AM (#19069667)
One of my friends received this. He was previously a rugby player and coach, but was feeling heavier and heavier every day. So he quit.

I think this type of income is best when 'between careers'.. when someone desires to walk a new path.

The alternative seems to be to leap into a new job, which could perpetuate misery.

But if a person has time to step away, and create stillness and clarity, then that decision can become obvious.

For him, the income was enough to live, for him to become a more conscious spender, and when he stopped receiving the money, he chose a new career in door-to-door sales which he's loving.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by Rainymood on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:59AM (#19068925)
Unemployment benefits =/= basic income
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by bertil on Sunday February 03, 2019 @09:30AM (#19069710)
Unemployment benefits (Chômage/Pôle Emploi) are only allocated to people actively looking for a job after they lost a previous job. They are typically 70-80% of your previous income and are granted for 2 years. It comes with monthly oversight and training program. Entrepreneurs are welcome to it and can ask to be given a lump sum and have dedicated training.

RSA (Revenu de Soliarité Active) is given to anyone, based on their resources: young graduates without a first paying job, refugees waiting for immigration decision, people who haven’t found a job in more than two years, even unpaid members of religious orders. It comes with medical coverage (“universal” medical insurance is based on your status in France).

Both are revoked when you find a job. It used to be possible that a part-time job would pay not much more than either stipend; because of that, both programs were described a possible “disincentives” by opponents (typically right-wing small-government, aka “Libéraux”). Even proponents saw a lot of edge-cases: people having to wait, seeing their hours cut or being fired soon after they changed status and struggling in the transition. To ease the transition, partial stipends were made possible.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by 13415 on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:52AM (#19070222)
Social welfare keeps people in Ghettos and drives them into a life of criminality, drug addiction, tax and social welfare fraud, and pretty much ensures that their children will never get any higher education and move up on the 'social ladder'. As if someone in France could live off 550 EUR/month - and German welfare levels are similar, to make this clear. The levels are unrealistically low, because politicians are detached from the reality of being poor, most of them have never even remotely experienced that life, and the budgets for social welfare systems are extremely high in percentage of GDP. Moreover, social welfare recipients are not a large voter group. So the budgets are cut down every now and then.

The whole idea of real BI is that everybody gets it indiscriminately and that it's high enough to be able to live off it.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by Phenix88be on Sunday February 03, 2019 @06:04AM (#19068946)
RSA is not at all a basic income... Basic income should be unconditional and would affect every one in our society.

RSA just prevent people from dying too soon.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by FartyMcFarter on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:18AM (#19068771)
I still don't understand how UBI will be paid for. If my calculations are correct, even 560 USD per month would require Finland to increase tax revenue by a third in order to fund it, if the UBI was provided to everyone in the country.

That already seems hard enough. How realistic would it be to give even more?

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by Sharlin on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:36AM (#19068843)
Any realistic UBI scheme works by adjusting marginal tax rates to compensate. Everyone gets the BI but it’s effectively taxed away from those with enough other income. Assuming the BI replaces many of the current benefits, it can be implemented by only slightly increasing tax rates for the highest income brackets.
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by notahacker on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:59AM (#19068927)
That's a fairly optimistic assumption though.

Finland currently has unemployment at 5.4% and working age economic inactivity (i.e. people who do not pay income tax but are also mostly not eligible for benefits) is closer to 30%.

If the state is paying out the equivalent of a livable income to >5x as many working age people as before that's a big increase in [net] income tax burden on the employed. Given that many of these economically inactive people are not looking for work by choice (probably because they don't need the money), there's a big question over whether that's an income tax burden worth imposing.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by zanny on Sunday February 03, 2019 @12:08PM (#19070742)
It is true that the best place to fund UBI is not from a pure income tax. In the same way raising the minimum wage inflates the general cost of goods, but at a lesser rate than the poorest earners see their incomes rise, having a UBI with a (preferably progressive with annual per-capita credit) generalized transnational / sales / exchange tax across the whole economy would work better. That would include income, but it wouldn't exclude capital gains, trade, consumer purchase, etc.
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by maxerickson on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:32AM (#19068831)
Lots of people net $0 or a negative amount.

The payments are not contingent on anything, but people earning enough more than the payments are getting less basic income than they are paying in taxes towards basic income.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by jrs95 on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:30AM (#19068823)
Hypothetically let's say you raised taxes by a third across the board. Only people who's taxes went up by more than that 560 a month would be paying more than they received in UBI. So it's a little bit deceptive in terms of how much taxes would need to increase by. The tax increase and monthly UBI amount should be tuned together to have the desired redistributive effect.
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by FartyMcFarter on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:36AM (#19068840)
Good point. It would be interesting to see some studies on the expected tax increases to make this work in practice.

There would still be the potential problem of people choosing not to work (affecting tax revenue), but this is much harder to predict of course.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by Phenix88be on Sunday February 03, 2019 @07:25AM (#19069239)
> There would still be the potential problem of people choosing not to work (affecting tax revenue), but this is much harder to predict of course.

I know a lot a people who don't have a job, but do a shit tons of work. Think of all those retired people building stuff for the family.

People who really don't want to do anything exist, some of them are mentally sick and need help, but I think every one want to do something (at some point in their life).

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by bertil on Sunday February 03, 2019 @09:39AM (#19069752)
One aspect of UBI in Finland that isn’t talked about as much as it used to be, is that it was meant to replace the rather extensive National health benefits notably the handicap pension. The argument was to save on the management cost of those programs.

Some people with a significant handicap, typically those who benefit from assistance to afford a powered wheelchair, were against it because it was likely that their benefit would be greatly reduced. There is also a large portion of the country that is considered handicapped for not obviously somatic reasons (depression and alcoholism) that would lose a lot. I have never heard any Finn disagree with the support that the latter group receives but I would assume that the assistance that they receive is controversial.

The initial goal there was to reduce the cost of managing all assistance programs (not to reduce inequality which isn’t necessarily seen as a major problem as long as everyone has a roof & eats) and was more a fringe right-wing idea.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by belorn on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:33AM (#19068833)
The idea of UBI is that you will replace most of current social support methods, reducing the administrative cost.

The disagreements I often see are on how large portion of social support can be replaced by UBI. In your calculations, how much of the 560 per month would be needed to be supported by new taxes?

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by FartyMcFarter on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:39AM (#19068858)
Unemployment benefits are more than $560 per month in Finland apparently, so this wouldn't be able to replace that (certainly not in a way which makes the administrative cost unnecessary).
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by belorn on Sunday February 03, 2019 @07:15AM (#19069204)
The general idea is that you do not get UBI on top of current unemployment benefits, and by having a universal income a lot of benefit programs will become obsolete.

One can for example look at people with part time and compare the average dependence on social support vs those who are unemployed. The assumption is that those with some income are part of fewer benefit program and interacts with fewer social administrators.

Do Finland have a similar system to Sweden where Unemployment benefits depend if the person paid a unemployment insurance when they were employed?

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by tuukkah on Sunday February 03, 2019 @12:37PM (#19070935)
I'm not familiar with the Swedish system but in Finland the unemployment benefit depends on whether you paid an unemployment insurance fund a membership fee during your employment. It's something like an insurance except the fees don't cover most of the costs and the state covers them instead.
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by icebraining on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:40AM (#19068864)
Arguably, the tax increase is zero: all the money is immediately returned. What matters is the redistribution: who pays more (and how much) and who gets more.

Also, for those who pay more, part of the tax increase is fictitious, since it would be compensated by their UBI. Someone paying $2000 before and $3000 now would not actually see an increase of $1000, just $440.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by roenxi on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:59AM (#19068923)
> Arguably, the tax increase is zero

You can't really argue that, because that applies to all taxation. It is like answering "Who is going to pay for the army?" by saying "the money is given to soldiers who spend it, and put it back into the economy - so really it costs nothing".

The flaw in that thinking is that, by design, a UBI will involve the consumption of real resources (like how maintaining an army involves lots of sunk resources including people's time) that could have gone into something else that creates more resources. The consumption of resources is going to appear as a cost to someone, because the people and activities consuming them didn't directly create anything.

At the moment we have an economic system that ensures consumption of real resources is matched by creation of real resources, using money as a measuring stick to prove that nobody in the chain of production believes value is being lost (net value, anyway). The cost of short circuiting that, as UBI does, is never going to be 0 and someone will have to pay it.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by icebraining on Sunday February 03, 2019 @09:47AM (#19069805)
In the soldier's case, they will spend their time and then get paid that money, with which they'll spend more resources. So for each tax dollar that enters, more than one dollar of resources is spent.

In the UBI's case, this is not true: the expense of resources is exactly the same, the State is just taking away the decision on which resources to spend it on from one group (net tax payers) to another (net tax receivers).

> At the moment we have an economic system that ensures consumption of real resources is matched by creation of real resources

But that's true with UBI as well (assuming it's done with taxation instead of issuing currency). If you give part of your paycheck to another person, the resources accounting is still net zero (society-wide).

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by roenxi on Sunday February 03, 2019 @04:50PM (#19072457)
> So for each tax dollar that enters, more than one dollar of resources is spent.

That is true; which imposes an interesting upper bound on army size before the economy collapses.

> In the UBI's case, this is not true

A UBI is exactly the same, except that the resource burn is smaller than employing someone in the army because instead of being guarenteed to waste a soldiers time there is only potential to waste a citizens time, which is an improvement.

> the State is just taking away the decision on which resources to spend it on from one group ... to another

Yes. Group 1 is the group that will decide to create more resources with what they are given and Group 2 are consumers. We know that is true in practice, because if it wasn't a UBI would be pointless.

> If you give part of your paycheck to another person, the resources accounting is still net zero (society-wide).

That is not so. If you get given your paycheck automatically you clearly have not created any real resources. If you spend it, you are clearly claiming something of value. For the overwhelming majority of people in the overwhelming majority of cases, the resources are for immediate or medium-term consumption, and the society wide net is reduced resources.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by behringer on Sunday February 03, 2019 @09:26AM (#19069687)
That's why automation and taxing those who use automation to generate income should be the driving force behind UBI.

Let the robots do the grunt work.

Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by doyoulikeworms on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:30AM (#19068827)
What if it was more like a negative income tax than UBI?
Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video] by skybrian on Sunday February 03, 2019 @11:49AM (#19070599)
I'm actually more interested in what happens with lower amounts that aren't enough to live on. On the margin, this should still have some good effects, and is more likely to be implemented.