Re:Did Finland’s basic income experiment work? [video]
by roenxi on Sunday February 03, 2019 @04:50PM
(#19072457)
> So for each tax dollar that enters, more than one dollar of resources is spent.
That is true; which imposes an interesting upper bound on army size before the economy collapses.
> In the UBI's case, this is not true
A UBI is exactly the same, except that the resource burn is smaller than employing someone in the army because instead of being guarenteed to waste a soldiers time there is only potential to waste a citizens time, which is an improvement.
> the State is just taking away the decision on which resources to spend it on from one group ... to another
Yes. Group 1 is the group that will decide to create more resources with what they are given and Group 2 are consumers. We know that is true in practice, because if it wasn't a UBI would be pointless.
> If you give part of your paycheck to another person, the resources accounting is still net zero (society-wide).
That is not so. If you get given your paycheck automatically you clearly have not created any real resources. If you spend it, you are clearly claiming something of value. For the overwhelming majority of people in the overwhelming majority of cases, the resources are for immediate or medium-term consumption, and the society wide net is reduced resources.
That is true; which imposes an interesting upper bound on army size before the economy collapses.
> In the UBI's case, this is not true
A UBI is exactly the same, except that the resource burn is smaller than employing someone in the army because instead of being guarenteed to waste a soldiers time there is only potential to waste a citizens time, which is an improvement.
> the State is just taking away the decision on which resources to spend it on from one group ... to another
Yes. Group 1 is the group that will decide to create more resources with what they are given and Group 2 are consumers. We know that is true in practice, because if it wasn't a UBI would be pointless.
> If you give part of your paycheck to another person, the resources accounting is still net zero (society-wide).
That is not so. If you get given your paycheck automatically you clearly have not created any real resources. If you spend it, you are clearly claiming something of value. For the overwhelming majority of people in the overwhelming majority of cases, the resources are for immediate or medium-term consumption, and the society wide net is reduced resources.