Take, as a simple example, the selective pressure on any disease that would have killed someone 1000 years ago. Now whatever susceptibility lead to that is not drained from the gene pool, the person is cured at great expense and reproduces furthering the presence of the gene. Don't get me wrong, evolution runs off of death and murder. Replacing it can be amazing, but we almost have no choice.
Because it is. Who will be responsible for the suffrage that gene-edited people will inevitably go through when someone screws up (and make no mistake, someone WILL screw up). Who will pay their medical bills?
That's only addressing one small issue from an unfathomable pile of issues and unintended consequences.
I for one am glad those "luddites" have more say in issues like this than people like you.
Who will be responsible for the suffrage [sic] that accident victims will inevitably go through when an automobile driver screws up (and make no mistake, automobile drivers WILL screw up).
The answer is: yes, a few suffer, the vast majority benefits, and life goes on. Your comment insists on a notion of perfect safety that exists nowhere in the real world.
Weighing any risk against that cost? I can't make a pursuasive argument that we shouldn't proceed.
Or as John Donne quipped in 1623, "... any man's death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind. And therefore never send to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee."
I'm all for IRBs, ethics boards, whatever is necessary to bound the risk. As long as we're not shying from scientific progress solely out of fear.
Gene editing should stay exactly where it is, in the dystopic dreams of uneducated eugenics supporters.
'We could have helped you, but we weren't comfortable doing so. Sorry.'?
Eugenics is a strawman, and we're both clear designer babies aren't what we're talking about here.
Do we?
Do we really ? The best argument I’ve seen until now pro gene editing is that we foundamentally lack understanding of what the genes really do relative to each other and the whole body, and the best way to see unintended consequences is to “jut do it”
In the last discussion about the rogue chinese researcher I didn’t see sources arguing it’s the right time to do that, is it your hunchbor do you see signs pointing at the contrary ?
If this needed to be regulated in the same way as abortion to appease some folks, fine. Legal only to apply if you have one of these listed mutations.
Eugenics gets brought up a lot as a strawman (see comment a few above), but the scientific and ethical reality is there's a huge difference between treating someone with...
(a) a defective huntingtin gene
(b) a gene we believe to be associated with a disease
(c) a gene we believe to be associated with a superior outcome (e.g. intelligence)
Conflating the three to the preclusion of addressing (a) is ethically criminal.
[1] https://www.genome.gov/19016930/faq-about-genetic-disorders/
That said, you are right, most diseases involve many genes and the environment...
oopsies.. Looks like someone forgot to edit out the naughty langauge gene in this one, and we all know that's an unhealthy one..
From a moral standpoint it's inconceivable that we aren't proceeding at full speed to solve inherited diseases.
There's no ethical hand wringing over this. (In many cases) We know what the mutation is. We know what a healthy gene is. We're on the cusp of being able to change the former into the latter.
Why are we still giving column inches to people saying "This is really disturbing"?
There's a counterpoint about genetic diversity and the dangers of monoculture, but that isn't what's being brought up. It's always 'This is new and scary, and so we should spend more time studying the implications before doing it.'