Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by adolph on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:20AM
(#1906488)
The problem isn’t that precious college graduates have to get their hands dirty. Rather, the issue is that people who paid for a college education aren’t getting the expected return on that investment – and might never get it.
This sounds a lot like the underwater mortgage issue. Maybe people are overpaying for college because of easy government-backed credit?
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by pashields on Monday November 15, 2010 @09:54AM
(#1906390)
I don't know why they made up a new word for this or why they think it is different from underemployment. From wiktionary definition of underemployed: "Employed in a job for which one is overqualified" http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/underemployed
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by aplusbi on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:35AM
(#1906553)
I suppose that depends on what you mean by "overqualified". I'm a computer programmer, and let's say I lost my job and started looking for a job in construction. I've never worked in construction before and while I'm not out-of-shape I'm not exactly ready for heavy-lifting.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by jhamburger on Monday November 15, 2010 @11:04AM
(#1906685)
I would think of it like this- If the job on paper requires you to be a high school graduate, you're overqualified because you have education beyond high school. If the job requires vocational training/certification/licenses/experience etc, that's a different story. The fact that you wouldn't be that good at the job in practice doesn't mean you're not overqualified.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by JonnieCache on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:48AM
(#1906612)
A bit of anecdotal evidence; I graduated university in the UK the summer before last, and "malemployment" as defined in this article applies to almost all of my friends and classmates. I have been very lucky to land a job doing what I love. Many of my newly graduated friends are doing service jobs or doing brainless admin tasks in offices. Most are simply unemployed, they cannot bring themselves to settle for these jobs and would rather sit at home on unemployment benefit. Often these jobs only pay one or two pounds more per week than what they are receiving in benefits.
The worst thing about this situation is the sense of helplessness and having been lied to it instills in young people. We have been told by our parents, rightly or wrongly, for the first two decades of our lives that if we simply work hard in our education we will land well paid, secure jobs. This was the reward for all the hard work at school, and for all the debt uni now requires. Now these kids are graduating, and finding that their £30000 of debt and three years of hard work might get them a job in macdonalds, if they're lucky.
When you combine that with the fact that those responsible for this situation got all their education completely free and were given large grants to pay their way through, you end up with the events of last week: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pE3IEKWu4rA
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by patio11 on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:56AM
(#1906648)
Was there an option in, say, 1980, or 1990, or 2000 for people with brand spanking new English degrees that wasn't a braindead job in an office? The entry level job mix changed a bit but the character strikes me as fairly consistent: if you have no commercially valuable skills at graduation (and if you majored in English, you probably don't), you get a low-responsibilities job while becoming acclimated to your industry and learning some soft skills.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by gaius on Monday November 15, 2010 @12:38PM
(#1907098)
The elephant in the corner of the room is that all degrees are not equal. I remember the teachers at my secondary school saying that it didn't matter what you study at university because you are "learning to learn". But even my 17-year-old self could see that that was obviously nonsense.
The brutal truth is that you are either studying for a career or you are pursuing a hobby full time for 3 years.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by rdouble on Monday November 15, 2010 @12:46PM
(#1907128)
The brutal truth is that you are either studying for a career or you are pursuing a hobby full time for 3 years.
I double majored in math and philosophy. I wouldn't say my studies were either career prep or a hobby. "Learning to learn" seems like a reasonable way to put it.
It has actually worked out great, career-wise. I am qualified for nothing, so I can seek employment doing whatever seems interesting.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by gaius on Monday November 15, 2010 @12:49PM
(#1907143)
It's certainly possible to parlay a hobby into paying work - musicians, writers, photographers all do it.
Nevertheless my point stands: from the perspective of industry, there is no difference between an irrelevant degree and no degree at all, and the evidence for this is holders of those degrees having no advantage in the job market.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by rdouble on Tuesday November 16, 2010 @01:13PM
(#1910979)
I'm not sure that is true, my math degree has been helpful in getting jobs. The math I specialized in (abstract algebra) was pretty irrelevant to any job I've ever been hired to do.
Related, I'm not sure what degree "product managers" are supposed to have. Every product manager I've worked with has had a very different educational background. Philosophy degree, MBA, art history degree, "American Studies," sociology degree, etc.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by harshpotatoes on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:39AM
(#1906569)
I liked where the article started out, but the only advice they offered was keep your chin up and go to mint.com. The line between news and advertisement is thinning.
Of course, maybe good financial planning is helpful if students are graduating with $4000 of credit card debt... That is the nu
mber I will never understand.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by twymer on Monday November 15, 2010 @09:42AM
(#1906357)
In 2000, about 30 percent of 20- to 24-year-olds were working in jobs that did not require college degrees. By 2010, that percentage had risen drastically to almost 40 percent.
20-24? A lot of students are taking more than four years for degrees these days. This statistic doesn't specify if it counts students enrolled in college working at a campus job or not.
At the beginning of this year, there were twice as many four-year college graduates working as waiters and bartenders as engineers.
Is the problem just that it's mostly expected that everyone moves on to college, whether or not they can pick a degree they care enough about to make a real effort in succeeding with?
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by twymer on Monday November 15, 2010 @12:02PM
(#1906978)
I assume this is related to my point, though, that most people aren't going to college because they care about something but rather because they are expected to. They then wind up picking something easier somewhat at random and can't get a job because of it.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by patio11 on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:43AM
(#1906589)
That shifts the pocket the wasted money comes from, but does not unwaste the money. It also possibly exacerbates the problem, since it creates a moral hazard in that the student can pick a degree known to be non-renumerative but otherwise desirable ("I always wanted to study anime... and now I can!"+), and the rest of us get to foot the bill for it.
+ In addition to my degree in making stuff, I have a degree in making stuff up, and one course was literally Manga As Literature. Nothing wrong with studying it on the side, but I know people who literally designed a course of study to focus on it, and the options for being a professional anime geek are rather constrained (particularly, cough, if you drop out of Japanese because "it is too hard").
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by z0r on Monday November 15, 2010 @11:25AM
(#1906790)
I think most education is not wasted - your example is not unheard of, but relatively uncommon. I think most people would complain about tax dollars paying for useless "arts majors". I think it is in general always better for society to have more highly educated populace, and it is no good to look down our noses at anything that isn't math, engineering, and science.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by sp4rki on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:41AM
(#1906579)
Education itself is cheap enough, you're not buying education by going to an expensive University, you're buying social interaction and a piece of paper. If the benefits of networking at Ivy League schools and the prestige of a diploma were available to everyone, they would cease to matter.
"you dropped a hundred and fifty grand on a fuckin’ education you coulda’ got for a dollar fifty in late charges at the public library"
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by jamesbritt on Monday November 15, 2010 @04:32PM
(#1907943)
"Society should pay for it, since society will benefit from it."
OK, but if someone is paying for it then it's not free.
Whether "society" (whihc I'm guessing really means tax payers) should foot the bill is a different matter.
There's a good self-interest argument that one is better off in a society where more people are better educated, but the devil is in the details: Who gets funding, with what strings attached, and so on.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by RyanMcGreal on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:34AM
(#1906552)
Education is a positive externality, i.e. the economy as a whole benefits as well as the individual receiving the education. In a free market, individuals tend to under-invest in education and the overall economy misses out on a higher aggregate education level.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by todayiamme on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:51AM
(#1906623)
You know if you set up research based institutes that actively encourage spin offs based upon the knowledge generated and gained inside their walls. Then, this problem won't exist.
For example, if I start a company/business the school will help me out with resources and in return take some amount of equity. Thus, what happens is that you have a VC-esque institution that remains true to the objectives of a university; learning.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by clistctrl on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:52AM
(#1906630)
I think this is a great idea, and I'd pay more taxes for it right away! but there needs to be limits around it. I'm more than willing to have my tax dollars go to help Little Timmy go to school for engineering (actually in the end that would benefit me twice, once as a consumer, and anther as an employer) however I would hate to pay taxes so little Timmy can learn more about art history, then get into the working world and make swirl pictures in my coffee.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by mswen on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:46AM
(#1906602)
Conversation at a wedding reception the other day. Approx. 120 Civil Engineering BA graduates for the 2009 and 2010 graduating classes from a major university. As of this fall only 5 graduates from those two classes, actually have been hired into engineering positions. My friend's son happened to be one of those 5 but what a dilemma for the other 115, do you double down and go to graduate school? Do you take whatever you can get and hope to enter engineering later? I don't know.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by devmonk on Monday November 15, 2010 @08:09AM
(#1906097)
Malemployment is very subjective. I can't see how you could effectively measure it and it mean that much.
I think a job happiness index would be better. You could just ask, "From 1-10 how happy are you with your current job (1=couldn't be more unhappy, 10=couldn't be happier)," would be enough. If this score dipped, morale is lower overall, and productivity will suffer.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by devmonk on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:28AM
(#1906523)
Yes, but just being accredited by an institution as having been educated in a subject doesn't mean that you are qualified for a job. I'm not saying that it isn't a valid indicator, just that it seems subjective and fuzzy.
If some "over-educated" employees still happy and perhaps have substantially greater output than their "less-educated" counterparts, then there could be a significant enough ROI on their education to justify it. However, you can't differentiate those from the "over-educated" workers that are unhappy that would be more productive in other roles. This is why I think a work happiness index would be a better indicator of how well those that are employed are fairing.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by grannyg00se on Monday November 15, 2010 @10:07AM
(#1906442)
How long do we have to hear the same "college is a ripoff" fact, wrapped in different stories, before people actually stop promoting a four year degree as the primary post secondary path for young adults? The return on investment has been questionable for quite some time now.
That looks like a solid ROI to me. I think this article is indicative of the fact that education + not much experience means you get left out in the cold when people with the same education and more experience are looking for work. Note that they talk about recent college grads in the low 20s - these typically aren't people with lots of degree-related work experience. You can also argue that not all degrees are created equal, in terms of employment. But hearing 'college is a ripoff' a lot (like, say, here) doesn't make it true.
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by grannyg00se on Monday November 15, 2010 @11:03AM
(#1906684)
Those statistics don't show an ROI, they show a correlation between education and unemployment. There could be many reasons that people with higher education aspirations have lower unemployment. Correlation does not imply causation.
I'm sure you can imagine that if somebody has the drive and mental capacity to finish a college degree, they also likely have the drive and mental capacity to land and keep a job. It is not the college degree that matters necessarily.
Using your own statistics, 89.9% of college dropouts have a job.
And 95.3% of college grads have a job.
Is four or five years of your life and tens of thousands of dollars worth a 5.4% increase? What if you were to dedicate those four years to personal study and lower job market experience and work your way up for four years instead? Can you be sure that the college route is the better solution, knowing that it only gives a 5.4% increase in those statistics?
Re:'Malemployment' on the Rise
by sudont on Monday November 15, 2010 @09:51AM
(#1906383)
This situation's looking a lot more like Iceland's (right country?) workplace dimorphism, with a majority of women graduating college and entering office, technical and desk jobs, and men working more traditional (manly) jobs such as fishing and oil-rigging.
This sounds a lot like the underwater mortgage issue. Maybe people are overpaying for college because of easy government-backed credit?
So am I overqualified or underqualified? Or both?
The worst thing about this situation is the sense of helplessness and having been lied to it instills in young people. We have been told by our parents, rightly or wrongly, for the first two decades of our lives that if we simply work hard in our education we will land well paid, secure jobs. This was the reward for all the hard work at school, and for all the debt uni now requires. Now these kids are graduating, and finding that their £30000 of debt and three years of hard work might get them a job in macdonalds, if they're lucky.
When you combine that with the fact that those responsible for this situation got all their education completely free and were given large grants to pay their way through, you end up with the events of last week: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pE3IEKWu4rA
Edit: this was also due to the relatively smaller proportion of the population with degrees at that time.
The brutal truth is that you are either studying for a career or you are pursuing a hobby full time for 3 years.
I double majored in math and philosophy. I wouldn't say my studies were either career prep or a hobby. "Learning to learn" seems like a reasonable way to put it.
It has actually worked out great, career-wise. I am qualified for nothing, so I can seek employment doing whatever seems interesting.
Nevertheless my point stands: from the perspective of industry, there is no difference between an irrelevant degree and no degree at all, and the evidence for this is holders of those degrees having no advantage in the job market.
Related, I'm not sure what degree "product managers" are supposed to have. Every product manager I've worked with has had a very different educational background. Philosophy degree, MBA, art history degree, "American Studies," sociology degree, etc.
Of course, maybe good financial planning is helpful if students are graduating with $4000 of credit card debt... That is the nu mber I will never understand.
I'm not even talking about unskilled jobs - just jobs that require some other kind of training that academia.
20-24? A lot of students are taking more than four years for degrees these days. This statistic doesn't specify if it counts students enrolled in college working at a campus job or not.
At the beginning of this year, there were twice as many four-year college graduates working as waiters and bartenders as engineers.
Is the problem just that it's mostly expected that everyone moves on to college, whether or not they can pick a degree they care enough about to make a real effort in succeeding with?
Umm, maybe this is because 60% (or more) of college students studied the humanities rather than engineering?
+ In addition to my degree in making stuff, I have a degree in making stuff up, and one course was literally Manga As Literature. Nothing wrong with studying it on the side, but I know people who literally designed a course of study to focus on it, and the options for being a professional anime geek are rather constrained (particularly, cough, if you drop out of Japanese because "it is too hard").
"you dropped a hundred and fifty grand on a fuckin’ education you coulda’ got for a dollar fifty in late charges at the public library"
Do you mean no one should be paid to provide it?
OK, but if someone is paying for it then it's not free.
Whether "society" (whihc I'm guessing really means tax payers) should foot the bill is a different matter.
There's a good self-interest argument that one is better off in a society where more people are better educated, but the devil is in the details: Who gets funding, with what strings attached, and so on.
For example, if I start a company/business the school will help me out with resources and in return take some amount of equity. Thus, what happens is that you have a VC-esque institution that remains true to the objectives of a university; learning.
I think a job happiness index would be better. You could just ask, "From 1-10 how happy are you with your current job (1=couldn't be more unhappy, 10=couldn't be happier)," would be enough. If this score dipped, morale is lower overall, and productivity will suffer.
If some "over-educated" employees still happy and perhaps have substantially greater output than their "less-educated" counterparts, then there could be a significant enough ROI on their education to justify it. However, you can't differentiate those from the "over-educated" workers that are unhappy that would be more productive in other roles. This is why I think a work happiness index would be a better indicator of how well those that are employed are fairing.
Education / Unemployment Rate:
Didn't finish high school 15.3%
No college degree 10.1%
College Degree 4.7%
That looks like a solid ROI to me. I think this article is indicative of the fact that education + not much experience means you get left out in the cold when people with the same education and more experience are looking for work. Note that they talk about recent college grads in the low 20s - these typically aren't people with lots of degree-related work experience. You can also argue that not all degrees are created equal, in terms of employment. But hearing 'college is a ripoff' a lot (like, say, here) doesn't make it true.
I'm sure you can imagine that if somebody has the drive and mental capacity to finish a college degree, they also likely have the drive and mental capacity to land and keep a job. It is not the college degree that matters necessarily.
Using your own statistics, 89.9% of college dropouts have a job. And 95.3% of college grads have a job. Is four or five years of your life and tens of thousands of dollars worth a 5.4% increase? What if you were to dedicate those four years to personal study and lower job market experience and work your way up for four years instead? Can you be sure that the college route is the better solution, knowing that it only gives a 5.4% increase in those statistics?