News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by doctorpangloss on Friday February 01, 2019 @01:38PM (#19057028)
A VC friend of mine characterized these kinds of answers nicely: incredible, profound bullshit that no one seems to know how to cut through.

On a level specific to Microsoft, their biggest threat is how agreeable and self-deprecating everything they do is now. Corporate cultures thrive on hierarchy, and yet their employees are pretty comfortable admitting to their friends that Windows and Azure are crap. The quiet trie flippers at Google, Amazon, Facebook, Oracle and Apple never speak ill of the product. Those people go and hunt leakers.

Nobody at Microsoft wants to hunt leakers anymore. That bloodthirsty lust for dollars is what made it possible for a whole generation of middle managers to hit the country club in the first place. So what does it say that the us-versus-them mentality is gone?

The CEO should be going out and saying, "Come work for us. Look how much nicer we are. Trie flippers might score better on their programming quizes, but they're insufferable." Instead he's talking, in coded language, about expanding to serve the Chinese government, which is impossible in an organization that believes in personal freedoms and positive life outcomes.

On a meta-level, what do we do with all the CEOs who are essentially beneficiaries of our increasingly correlated bull runs? Has it really boiled down to, "Since non-mineral and utility revenues are correlated at huge market cap companies, you're a good CEO as long as your likable?"

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by faramarz on Friday February 01, 2019 @01:59PM (#19057270)
Bill and the board deserve credit for bringing in Satya to captain the ship and steer it.

The ship is still afloat, with a captain able and willing to navigate it into new territories. That's really what they're doing and I think that in itself is a re-invention and worth remarking about.

Now, you can give them shit for the design of their ship, failures, practices, etc.. and rightfully so, but they are definitley re-defining their business in real-time, in my opinion.

I'd love to hear if any of that resonates as I haven't worked at Google or the other companies you listed to get a scope of the culture.

edit: steer

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by markrages on Friday February 01, 2019 @02:10PM (#19057389)
steer
Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by tomnipotent on Friday February 01, 2019 @01:52PM (#19057195)
> and yet their employees are pretty comfortable admitting to their friends that Windows and Azure are crap

You make a whole lot of claims with absolutely zero evidence to back it up.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by VRay on Friday February 01, 2019 @01:56PM (#19057241)
I take it you don't know anyone who works at MSFT?
Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by bradford on Friday February 01, 2019 @02:43PM (#19057727)
I work at MSFT.

There's a difference between being critical of a product in an effort to improve it, and classifying the product as 'crap'.

My opinion, and I think most msft employees would share it, fall into the former, and not the latter. There's a lot to be proud of in both Windows and Azure, even with full recognition that they aren't perfect.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by CamperBob2 on Friday February 01, 2019 @09:55PM (#19060718)
I don't buy it. MSFT employees go home to their extended families during the holidays just like many of the rest of us do. There, just like the rest of us, they will be expected to maintain their non-technical relatives' Windows PCs, or at least explain why said computers are so badly hosed.

They are doing a terrible job on Windows and they have to know it, if only at a subconscious level.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by grumpydba on Saturday February 02, 2019 @03:55AM (#19061967)
What about bing then ?
Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by tomnipotent on Friday February 01, 2019 @02:28PM (#19057579)
Folks at every business I know eventually talk crap or otherwise grumble. Whoop de do. There's very little signal in that, especially for a business like Microsoft where everyone is an armchair analyst and can't go five minutes without mentioning "Embrace, Extend, Extinguish" because they think it makes them sound smart.
Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by dtrailin on Friday February 01, 2019 @03:05PM (#19057941)
People at Amazon and Oracle complain all the time, you should talk to them. I think honesty is far more important than pretending everything is great when isn't. If this is the case then you are part of a cult. I think you'll also seen a wide variety of opinions on Windows and Azure, mostly related to the individual products at Microsoft. Having worked there I know quite a few people that were big fans of the NT Kernel, C#, .net, and Azure services like Storage and App Insights. People will also acknowledge the bad parts, which is critical if one wants to improve.
Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by SatvikBeri on Friday February 01, 2019 @02:15PM (#19057444)
Satya became CEO in February 2014. Since then, Microsoft's stock has significantly outperformed Google and Apple, and slightly outperformed Facebook. While it significantly underperformed each of those in the years before. So it's not just the bull market.
Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by sonnyblarney on Friday February 01, 2019 @10:23PM (#19060820)
The stock rise was a function of changing analyst ratios - not changing fundamentals.

Ballmer grew the company like a machine during his tenure.

Satya has been iffy, in fact, without 2018 numbers, quite unstable in fact. It's just that that 2018 numbers were good enough to bring everything back to nice growth.

Without a lot of movement in P/E ratios, both CEO's would have really been doing about the same.

Basically, the stock was held back for whatever reason during Ballmer years, even as sales were growing well. Then when Satya took over the ratios changed and the stock flipped up like an elastic.

Satya's a good guy and the right choice but I don't think he's done anything quite fundamentally important yet relative to Ballmer.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by Qworg on Friday February 01, 2019 @01:42PM (#19057088)
The mentality is still there, but years of polish has made it hard to detect by outsiders. I wouldn't for a moment attribute any of MSFT's moves to goodwill.

They were bareknuckled and bloody for years - they got slapped by regulators for it and it was forced under the surface.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by gnu8 on Friday February 01, 2019 @01:51PM (#19057186)
Microsoft deserves to go gentle into that good night because of all the damage they’ve done to the computing industry over the years, for example killing Be and Netscape with monopolist tactics and creating a terminally insecure software monoculture of the lowest common denominator of Windows and IE, that we’re still recovering from today. (Google is repeating the lesson today - Android is the Windows 98 of mobile).

I’m glad to see them disappear and it drives me crazy to talk to all of these people who think Office 365 and Azure are sex on a stick. They’ve either forgotten the past or they don’t care.

Microsoft deserves to die.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by ggambetta on Friday February 01, 2019 @02:04PM (#19057327)
> They’ve either forgotten the past or they don’t care.

Or they're too young to know or remember!

Working with recent grads, I've discovered that for most of them Bill Gates has always been this grey-haired, well-natured philanthropist. They can't believe it when I tell them of how universally reviled Microsoft was, and I feel like Grandpa Simpson talking about onions in his belt :(

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by kazinator on Friday February 01, 2019 @02:14PM (#19057431)
I speak here perhaps not only for myself but others: although Microsoft had been reviled, and still is, somehow Gates escaped that personally. I've never felt that I dislike Bill Gates.

There had been a smaller Microsoft before the rise of MS-DOS and Windows. Microsoft was a vendor of BASIC interpreters that were integrated into some 8 bit microcomputers, which I used. The Apple II's "Applesoft" basic was derived from Microsoft's work. Its name is a portmanteau of Apple and Microsoft, a kind of touchstone that highlights a complex history of cooperation and rivalry between the two.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by sifoobar on Friday February 01, 2019 @02:50PM (#19057784)
Here, let me fix that for you:

https://www.bimmerfest.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmenti...

Bu xie, my pleasure.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by kazinator on Friday February 01, 2019 @03:55PM (#19058485)
I actually had that in an earlier edit of my comment!

I got rid of it for lack of stability in the URL. There doesn't appear to be a nice semi-permanent home on the web for these photos.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by yaseer on Friday February 01, 2019 @02:03PM (#19057315)
I am not a big Microsoft fan, having not used Windows or any MS products in about 16 years, until VS Code came along. But this kind of black and white thinking is just at odds with reality. Nothing is wholly good or bad, and so to with Microsoft.

They were part of a small group of companies that pioneered Desktop computing. They did so with forceful business tactics, but they changed the world nonetheless, and really did help place a computer in every home.

Ths history books will remember their contributions as well as their sins.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by loudmax on Friday February 01, 2019 @03:15PM (#19058054)
Seeing Microsoft die would give me great schadenfreude, but all big companies do some good things and some bad things, so it's worth focusing on their specific sins. I see two of them: their desktop monopoly and their Office monopoly.

Their desktop monopoly isn't what it once was, especially considering that most people get online today using mobile devices. But it never really went away. Windows is the only commercially successful desktop operating system. Everything else is a niche product without access to the enormous ecosystem of Windows-only desktop software. Desktop Linux exists, but it isn't any kind of commercial success. The Mac desktop exists to sell Apple hardware, it isn't a product on its own. And part of the reason it exists at all is that Microsoft publishes a version of their office suite for Macs.

MS Office is absolutely entrenched in corporate computing. Many of us here on HN can get by on non MS Office products, but if you're exchanging Office documents with customers you absolutely need to use MS Office to get a decent level of compatibility. For a huge number of businesses, there simply isn't any choice.

Microsoft isn't about to go out of business and a lot of people enjoy using their software and feel productive. People should have a choice. Microsoft could go a long way to repent for their sins if they open up both Windows and Office to the point where there are significant viable alternatives to both. Microsoft should be able to compete on quality, not on possessing the keys to their proprietary kingdom.

I'm not holding my breath.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by chiefalchemist on Friday February 01, 2019 @02:14PM (#19057426)
Then certainly Google deserves the same (i.e. gentle into the night) and then some. Not only have they done plenty of damage to the computing industry but they've normalized a lack of privacy in doing so. That is, Google has done social, if not sociopolitical damage (that makes MS looks like the tooth fairy).

Your disgust is fitting. But let's be sure the context is appropriate as well.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by gerash on Friday February 01, 2019 @07:05PM (#19060005)
> damage to the computing industry

What are you talking about? Citation needed.

Re:Microsoft’s Resurgence Under Satya Nadella by dugluak on Friday February 01, 2019 @02:04PM (#19057328)
> Android is the Windows 98 of mobile

IMO Android UX is way better than iOS when used on a right device. I switched from iPhone to Pixel and it's a delight to use. I am not going back to iPhone soon ...