Re:Modern Weather Forecasts Are Stunningly Accurate
by voyager2 on Friday February 01, 2019 @08:47AM
(#19054005)
If I move my forecast location a few hundred yards, my
elevation changes rather drastically, changing the forecast.
Elevation isn't a factor most forecasts even consider. Is
it false precision to use elevation to tailor the forecast?
Re:Modern Weather Forecasts Are Stunningly Accurate
by Majromax on Friday February 01, 2019 @11:32AM
(#19055551)
In that case, the interpolation includes a vertical component as well. You'll see the effects of the lapse rate (change in temperature with height).
That's great for you, but it means that your forecast (of [my elevation, my coordinates]) is not much more accurate than one for ([my elevation, my coordinates plus a few hundred yards]).
More technically: "surface" isn't a smooth variable when elevation changes quickly, but interpolation like that performed by weather.gov necessarily works on smooth fields. Applying post-facto elevation is great and worthwhile, but it doesn't improve the accuracy in a technical sense.
Unfortunately, this is an example of false precision. The highest resolution numerical forecasts run by NOAA have a grid of about 3km, already coarser than your one-square-mile "tailored" output. The effective resolution of numerical weather models is also 2-3 times coarser than their grid spacing (because of numerical diffusivity and similar effects).
What you're seeing isn't a "tailored" output, but instead an interpolated result from a coarser grid.
Forecasting of very high-resolution effects is the subject of active and ongoing research, but unfortunately popular meteorology does not do a good job of discussing current limitations.
Look at the confusion in this set of comments, for example, about what degree of forecast error is normal/acceptable.