News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by hugs on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:11AM (#19026879)
(Disclosure: I make robots for mobile testing.)

I wish more companies realized all the spying and stealing of information would be unnecessary if they started collaborating on making open source hardware testing equipment. A robot that taps a screen shouldn't be considered a super important trade secret.

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by retSava on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:51AM (#19027274)
Nor especially difficult to recreate.

I don't get it, it should be so simple. There are three dimensions in which the tapper has to traverse, probably not changing the angle of it either. It probably has some squishiness in the tip, so it doesn't have to be super super precise.

This was in 2012, when there already where 3d-printers with much more harder requirements. Well, sure, this would run 24/7 likely so should have better components and be quite robust.

So, some development but not like inventing anything drastically new. What am I missing?

edit: ah, other comments raise some interesting points regarding detecting state of the phone and apps. I looked at it from mostly a hardware perspective since that's the impression I got from the article.

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by HillRat on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @12:48PM (#19028286)
The article discusses the lengths Huawei went to in order to obtain hardware specifications in order to build a clone. However, Tappy appears to be an incrementally-evolved version of the open-source Tapster robot, making this akin to an auto manufacturer engaging in high-stakes corporate espionage in order to obtain the precise dimensions of a competitor’s steering wheel.

Quite frankly, you’ve got to wonder about Huawei’s engineering chops if they’re going all spy-vs-spy to steal something that’s 75% available on Github already.

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by syntaxing on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @11:00AM (#19027375)
Someone bought up this point in the other discussion but 3D printers is a really bad example for a gantry for production based systems. This is mainly because of the open loop design and the asynchronous motion profiles between the motors. There was a lot of work that went into GRBL to make the axis seemed sync. Also, getting into motion profiles is super tricky as well (which is trapezoidal preset in GRBL). The thing with these devices is that it has to be working 100% of the time with a feedback making sure its doing what you expect.

That being said, besides the kinematics, instrumentation for hardware is the tricky part. Getting repeatable and consistent measurement for large production quantities is not an straight forward task. Processing and digesting the results is also another hurdle.

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by Bartweiss on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @02:16PM (#19029044)
I'm curious whether there's a better reference for gantry robotics? It looks like the hard parts here are non-mechanical, but I'd be interested to know more generally.

Automated brick-layers come to mind as another 3D positioning task with no pitch or roll, but I'm not familiar enough with the general space to know if they're at all representative. Among other things, I seem to remember they can't corner properly, which suggests they might be operating on a linear axis and a width rather than a proper 3D workspace.

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by howard941 on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @12:03PM (#19027887)
> if they started collaborating

Note possible anti-trust red flag

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by HashHishBang on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @12:13PM (#19027977)
> on making open source hardware testing equipment

Anti-trust red flag? That would be a real hard sell to even the most anti-corporate type.

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by hugs on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @12:09PM (#19027940)
Is it an anti-trust red flag if web browser vendors started collaborating on testing tools, too?
Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by jeroenhd on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:50AM (#19027262)
There was a civil lawsuit and Huawei won.

This is probably just part of the general witch hunt the US is undertaking against Huawei.

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by DannyBee on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @11:15AM (#19027490)
Actually, Huawei did not win.

The jury found for t-mobile.

See, e.g., https://www.geekwire.com/2017/jury-sides-with-t-mobile-in-ca...

They then settled the case.

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by daveguy on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @11:00AM (#19027373)
Civil suits and criminal suits are separate. I'm not sure if settling a civil suit can be seen as exonerating for a criminal suit. Standard of proof is higher for a criminal suit, and civil suits can be settled easily with money.

I don't think witch hunt is the right term, as there was obvious unethical acts (possibly criminal). Although, it is definitely an escalation and I do wish there was more communicating through diplomats than through legal systems.

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by mikeash on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @11:31AM (#19027617)
A classic example: OJ Simpson was found not guilty in his criminal trial, but was found liable in his civil trial.
Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by sonnyblarney on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:56AM (#19027337)
It's abundantly clear from the emails that Huawei was maliciously trying to steal IP, to the point wherein they snuck people into a facility to carry out industrial espionage.

There are numerous reasons why a civil suit might have failed even when the aforementioned is true.

Moreover, this seems to be not an isolated case, but a systematic behaviour instituted within the organization, and others, including the state.

However ridiculous it is for people to be trying to copy the 'tappy robot' (!!) - this is a serious issue that needs to be addressed.

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by hugs on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @11:00AM (#19027370)
My point is that one way to address it is to not consider a screen tapping device a trade secret and make these devices open source. But yes, all the stealing is wrong and should be dealt with, too.
Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by sonnyblarney on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @11:13AM (#19027467)
If one is in the business of making such robots, then it would definitely be a good idea to protect one's IP.

We don't get to automatically assume the position of one player in the value chain (say mobile manufacturer) and assume it would be 'beneficial' to just open source the IP of some supplier.

Every 'buyer' everywhere would want all the 'supplies' as cheaply and freely as possible (!) but it can't usually work that way.

In the article, there's an email referring one person to the 'manufacturer of the robot and not Tmobile' - which I guess indicates that the thing is not made by Tmo but by some 3rd party supplier.

Should that 3rd party who ostensibly invested in designing that thing just 'open source' their products? How would they benefit from that? It's possible they may, but doubtful.

I guess because this isn't exactly 'advanced robotic's it all seems a little clownish, but most of what we make isn't super hight tech, yet laden with specific know how and knowledge.

Re:Huawei's attempts to copycat a T-Mobile robot read like a... by Cacti on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:56AM (#19027335)
Witch hunt? Are you seriously suggesting that Huawei _doesn’t_ engage in corporate espionage?