I think being "mastercard middleman" is disingenuous. Firstly, because doing that well breaks down into getting good at many domains (software, finance, management, regulatory, sales, recruiting, fundraising, etc. etc. etc.), and secondly because Stripe is far more than that.
At the very least, his intuition on these issues is very likely to be much, much better than random chance.
One thing they are at least implying, but I think they could have explored more is implementations. While you can argue whether there are less scientific breakthroughs or not, we certainly have less implementations. Were I assume I differ from their view is that I think this have to do with diminish returns for the implementations themselves.
To some extent it becomes meaningless to "cure cancer" when we have preventable diseases and situations killing people every day. So there can't realistically be a goal to do it. (Which isn't intended as an argument about the value of each). As I insinuated earlier I think a breakthrough is really in the eye of the beholder. Society these days doesn't really provide a platform for creating and implementing breakthroughs. The ambition get lost in the noise.
I think people assume when watching utopian science fiction that science resulted in society. Maybe in reality it is the other way around. Once you decide that everyone deserves e.g. housing the result becomes worth it and the science follows. That is certainly what happened in the ~60s in many parts of the world. If no one thinks that this is a worthy breakthrough why would anything happen in the first place today?
[What I really wanted to say was that I found the middle part of article surprisingly interesting].
I've reached a similar conclusion about fundamental physics. At the very least we are stuck with what we have for a very long time.
This may seem to be anti-scientific or anti-progress but who proved that scientific progress is unbounded?
This is also what what generally believed about physics in the 1890s, right before everything exploded with Relativity and Quantum Physics.
"it was generally accepted that all the important laws of physics had been discovered and that, henceforth, research would be concerned with clearing up minor problems and particularly with improvements of method and measurement"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_physics#20th_centur...
If you'd ask yuval-noah harari, an historian, he'll say that with today's and tomorrow's innovation in AI and robotics , we're at unprecedented era in history.
On the other hand, when someone starts having public opinions on pretty much anything (from buddhism to AI), I tend to be very suspicious about their expertise.
Many, many, many. But it’s hard to pinpoint them.
Lower-friction communication between researchers and better access to published science is an incredible catalyst for every kind of advance (from trivial incremental improvements through to new paradigms) in every field.
Agreed -- I'm disappointed to see this from pc. This piece reeks of the "Andy Grove Fallacy", as described by to Derek Lowe ([1] and [2]).
It's one thing to be a mastercard middleman -- it's completely different to create new fundamental knowledge about the world.
[1] "Andy Grove: Rich, Famous, Smart and Wrong" http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2007/11/06/and...
[2] "Silicon Valley Sunglasses" http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2015/04/02/sil...