News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress [a... by petra on Monday January 28, 2019 @06:12PM (#19022013)
>> I think a breakthrough is really in the eye of the beholder . Society these days doesn't really provide a platform for creating and implementing breakthroughs.

If you'd ask yuval-noah harari, an historian, he'll say that with today's and tomorrow's innovation in AI and robotics , we're at unprecedented era in history.

Re:Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress [a... by hoaw on Monday January 28, 2019 @06:37PM (#19022233)
I don't know much about him, more than what I could find on Wikipedia. I just don't think most of these people have a significant enough hypothesis to warrant the expectation of breakthrough. If someone can propose the specific way AI will change e.g. medicine once it reaches a certain level, that might be something. At least if the difference is great enough. "It will change society", doesn't have so much standing in my opinion. I guess if you are a historian it probably does. Until someone start spending money for something specific (which might already be happening) I wouldn’t expect a breakthrough, because it doesn’t really matter.
Re:Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress [a... by x3tm on Monday January 28, 2019 @07:20PM (#19022530)
Impact on society doesn't mean impact on science. What scientific breakthroughs were due to the internet? Yet, the internet had/has an unprecedented impact on history.

On the other hand, when someone starts having public opinions on pretty much anything (from buddhism to AI), I tend to be very suspicious about their expertise.

Re:Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress [a... by jacobolus on Monday January 28, 2019 @08:15PM (#19022827)
> What scientific breakthroughs were due to the internet?

Many, many, many. But it’s hard to pinpoint them.

Lower-friction communication between researchers and better access to published science is an incredible catalyst for every kind of advance (from trivial incremental improvements through to new paradigms) in every field.

Re:Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress [a... by x3tm on Monday January 28, 2019 @09:08PM (#19023065)
Better/faster communication can facilitate work, but it's not the same as causing a breakthrough like say new data/theory. In that regard, English as a unified scientific language has probably a bigger impact than the internet.
Re:Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress [a... by jonny_eh on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @01:25AM (#19024244)
I've read two of his books. He's an amazing historian and writer, but I'm not a fan of his futurology. Studying history is important but it certainly doesn't predict the future.